# Why is a beam supported by two cables more stable than one?

• Tom Lever
In summary, when a steel I-girder is lifted by a single wire rope, it will rotate about a horizontal latitudinal axis through its centroid if the rope is not centered perfectly along the girder length. However, if the girder is lifted by two wire ropes, with one on each side of the centroid, each five percent away from the centroid, there will be a net moment or torque about the latitudinal axis if the ropes are not equidistant from the centroid. In the third scenario, where the girder is lifted by two ropes, each five percent away from an end, the net moment will be equal to the previous scenario but the girder will be more stable. This is because slight asymmetries
Tom Lever
Imagine a steel I-girder lifted by a single wire rope. If the rope is not perfectly centered along the girder length, the girder will rotate about a horizontal latitudinal axis through its centroid.

Imagine a girder pair lifted by two wire ropes, with one rope on each side of the girder centroid, each about five percent of the length of the girder away from the centroid. If ropes are not perfectly equidistant from the centroid, the girder will rotate.

Imagine a girder pair lifted by two wire ropes, each about five percent of the length of the girder away from an end. If the ropes are not perfectly equidistant from the ends, there will be a net moment / torque about the latitudinal axis, equal to the net moments above, but this situation will be more stable. Why?

Additionally, for a rigid girder, cables at the ends would be most stable (stability score of 50), cables at the centroid would be least stable (stability score of -50), and cables each halfway between centroid and end would be stable in an intermediate way (stability score of 0). Why is this a linear relationship?

Last edited:
In your second case, there will be zero net moment on the girder, which will be enabled by a slightly different tension in each of the two ropes. It's more stable because slight asymmetries in geometry can be compensated with slight asymmetries in cable tension to enable an overall zero net moment across a range of cable locations, while the first scenario has no margin for error in cable positioning before you start to have an applied moment.

The stability is directly related to the restoring force. When there is a slight disturbance, is there a restoring force that opposes the disturbance? In each case that you mention, you can understand the answer by describing the sign and magnitude of the restoring force.

PS. If this is a class exercise, there is a format that you should use.

## 1. Why is a beam supported by two cables more stable than one?

A beam supported by two cables is more stable because it distributes the weight and force evenly between the two cables, preventing the beam from sagging or tipping over. This creates a balanced and strong support system for the beam.

## 2. How does the number of cables affect the stability of a beam?

The more cables that support a beam, the more stable it will be. This is because each cable helps to evenly distribute the weight and force, reducing the chances of the beam bending or breaking under pressure.

## 3. Can a beam be supported by only one cable?

Technically, a beam can be supported by only one cable, but it is not recommended. This is because a single cable may not be strong enough to support the weight and force of the beam, leading to potential instability and safety hazards.

## 4. Are there any advantages to using two cables instead of one to support a beam?

Yes, there are several advantages to using two cables instead of one to support a beam. These include increased stability, better weight distribution, and a stronger support system for the beam. Additionally, using two cables allows for more flexibility in the placement and design of the beam.

## 5. How do the angles of the cables affect the stability of a beam?

The angles of the cables play a crucial role in the stability of a beam. The closer the cables are to being perpendicular to the beam, the more stability they provide. If the cables are at a sharper angle, they may not be able to fully support the weight of the beam, leading to potential instability.

• Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
14
Views
9K
• Mechanics
Replies
1
Views
4K
Replies
1
Views
6K
• Quantum Physics
Replies
13
Views
6K
• Other Physics Topics
Replies
0
Views
771
• General Discussion
Replies
4
Views
7K