Why LED Lights Aren't Used in Camera Flashes/Strobes

  • Thread starter Thread starter RNickl
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Led Xenon
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

LED lights are not commonly used in modern camera flashes and strobes primarily due to their spectral output and efficiency limitations compared to xenon lamps. While newer multi-die LED arrays can produce more light and strobe faster, xenon lamps offer superior color rendering and a broader spectral output that is crucial for photography. The high current densities required for optimal xenon output produce a white light that is more effective for capturing images, making xenon the preferred choice despite its higher cost. Modifying existing flashes to incorporate LEDs may improve manageability for macro photography, but challenges related to spectral quality and intensity remain significant.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of xenon flash technology and its spectral output
  • Knowledge of LED light characteristics and limitations
  • Familiarity with current density concepts in lighting
  • Basic principles of color rendering in photography
NEXT STEPS
  • Research the spectral output differences between xenon and LED lights
  • Explore modifications for integrating LED arrays into existing flash units
  • Learn about current density effects on light quality in photography
  • Investigate alternative lighting solutions for macro photography
USEFUL FOR

Photographers, lighting technicians, and anyone interested in optimizing flash performance for photography, particularly in macro settings.

RNickl
Messages
12
Reaction score
2
Any input on why LED's are not used in modern camera flashes/strobes? I've searched a bit and it seems newer multi-die LED arrays not only put out more light but can strobe faster than xenon lamps, sounds win/win? I feel I must be missing something?!

I was considering trying to modify a small flash I have by getting rid of the xenon and placing LED's direct into a lighting diffuser mounted on the front of the lens. It would make my light setup for macro photography WAY more manageable and durable.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
RNickl said:
Any input on why LED's are not used in modern camera flashes/strobes?
Size, maybe? Focus?
 
Xenon seems to have a number of advantages.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flashtube#Xenon said:
Xenon[edit]
220px-XeTube.jpg

Xenon, operated as a 'neon light,' consists of a collection of mostly spectral lines, missing much of the continuum radiation needed for good color rendering.
220px-Flashlamp_ion_spectral_line_radiation_output.jpg

Spectral line radiation from a xenon flashlamp. Although invisible to the naked eye, the digital camera is able to image the strong, IR spectral-lines, which appear as the blue light reflected off the table.
As with all ionized gases, xenon flashtubes emit light in various spectral lines. This is the same phenomenon that gives neon signs their characteristic color. However, neon signs emit red light because of extremely low current-densities when compared to those seen in flashtubes, which favors spectral lines of longer wavelengths. Higher current-densities tend to favor shorter wavelengths.[13] The light from xenon, in a neon sign, likewise is rather violet. The spectrum emitted by flashtubes is far more dependent on current density than on the fill pressure or gas type. Low current-densities produce narrow spectral-line emission, against a faint background of continuous radiation. Xenon has many spectral lines in the UV, blue, green, red, and IR portions of the spectrum. Low current densities produce a greenish-blue flash, indicating the absence of significant yellow or orange lines. At low current-densities, most of xenon's output will be directed into the invisible IR spectral lines around 820, 900, and 1000 nm.[14]Low current-densities for flashtubes are generally less than 1000 A/cm2.

Higher current-densities begin to produce continuum emission. Spectral lines broaden and become less dominant as light is produced across the spectrum, usually peaking, or "centered", on a certain wavelength. Optimum output-efficiency in the visual range is obtained at a density that favors "greybody radiation" (an arc that produces mostly continuum emission, but is still mostly translucent to its own light; an effect similar to sunlight when it passes through a cloud). For xenon, greybody radiation is centered near green, and produces the right combination for white light.[9][11]Greybody radiation is produced at densities above 2400 A/cm2.

Current densities that are very high, approaching 4000 A/cm2, tend to favor black-body radiation. Spectral lines all but disappear as the continuum radiation dominates, and output center shifts toward the ultraviolet. As current densities become even higher, visually, xenon's output spectrum will begin to settle on that of a blackbody radiator with a color temperature of 9800 kelvins (a rather sky-blue shade of white).[1] Except in cases where intense UV light is needed, such as water decontamination, blackbody radiation is usually not desired because the arc becomes opaque, and much of the radiation from within the arc can be absorbed before reaching the surface, impairing output efficiency.[11][14][15]

Due to its high-efficient, white output, xenon is used extensively for photographic applications, despite its great expense. In lasers, spectral-line emission is usually favored, as these lines tend to better match absorption linesof the lasing media. Krypton is also occasionally used, although it is even more expensive. At low current-densities, krypton's spectral-line output in the near-IR range is better matched to the absorption profile of neodymium-based laser media than xenon emission, and very closely matches the narrow absorption-profile of Nd:YAG.[16][17] None of xenon's spectral lines match Nd:YAG's absorption lines so, when pumping Nd:YAG with xenon, the continuum radiation must be used
 

Attachments

  • 220px-XeTube.jpg
    220px-XeTube.jpg
    5.8 KB · Views: 521
  • 220px-Flashlamp_ion_spectral_line_radiation_output.jpg
    220px-Flashlamp_ion_spectral_line_radiation_output.jpg
    2.3 KB · Views: 489
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jim hardy
Thanks both for the input.
Spectral bandwidth is a very important consideration and not forgotten. Much easier to compensate for in these digital days but may still cause some issues.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K