- 42,640
- 10,429
Unfortunately it is not.PeroK said:The detailed analysis of internal energy within the rope is outside the scope of the this homework.
You made the force/momentum approach produce the work conservation answer by assuming that a perfectly elastic string of very little extensibility pulled up at a steady rate would not acquire significant persistent vertical oscillations. It is unclear to me whether that is the case.
Even then, to get your answer, the significant lateral KE which would come from pulling up from a horizontal loop (as discussed above) has to be ignored. I have not checked whether including that gives one of the listed answers.
Other valid models can produce other answers.
E.g. consider the model of a chain in which each segment, length L, starts standing vertically. The segments have no width. As each segment is lifted to height L it engages the next segment. If that is a coalescence then the work required is doubled. Even if it is perfectly elastic, would there not be persistent vertical oscillations?
Or start with zero width segments lying horizontally in a stack in a zigzag arrangement. As a segment is lifted it rotates about its lower end. Will the energy that goes into that rotation be recovered in helping to lift the next segment, or will there be residual horizontal wiggles?
Such considerations are only outside the scope of the question if those models are somehow excluded.