Youtube embedding in Chat (shoutbox)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Matterwave
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
Embedding YouTube videos in the shoutbox is problematic because the video resets with each new message, making it difficult to watch. While a link to the video on YouTube is provided, this undermines the purpose of embedding. The chat system uses BBCode processing but lacks specific YouTube functionality, leading to the suggestion that automatic embedding may not be ideal. Users express concern that this issue significantly impacts the usability of embedded videos. A potential solution discussed includes disabling automatic embedding for YouTube URLs.
Matterwave
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
Messages
3,971
Reaction score
329
So, since the shoutbox refreshes its page every time a message is entered, an embedded youtube video will also reset when I type something into the shoutbox, making actually watching the video difficult.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Yeah, at the top left of the embedded video there's a link to youtube itself. But this seems to pretty much defeat the purpose of embedding, rather than just posting the URL in the first place.
 
There really isn't a way to handle this. New content will push old content down.
 
But I think the problem is not moving the content down, but that the video reloads after every message. Even if the video moves down, couldn't you make it not reload so that you could keep watching?
 
Matterwave said:
But I think the problem is not moving the content down, but that the video reloads after every message.
Ah interesting, yes that is a problem. One that we likely can't fix.
 
Ah =/ Seems like a pretty big dent in the functionality of youtube embedding then...
 
Matterwave said:
Ah =/ Seems like a pretty big dent in the functionality of youtube embedding then..
The chat simply inherits bbcode processing. It doesn't specifically have youtube functionality.
 
Greg Bernhardt said:
The chat simply inherits bbcode processing. It doesn't specifically have youtube functionality.

Maybe in that case a youtube URL should not be automatically embedded then? o.o
 
  • #10
Matterwave said:
Maybe in that case a youtube URL should not be automatically embedded then? o.o
We can make that happen
 
Back
Top