Is it Safe and Worthwhile to Build a Homemade Particle Accelerator?

  • Thread starter -NikolaTesla-
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Design
In summary, the conversation was about a high school student's interest in building a small linear particle accelerator and their search for a simpler design. The student expressed prior experience with high voltage applications and an understanding of the dangers of radiation. Others cautioned against the dangers of the project and suggested working together in groups. The conversation also touched on alternative projects and ways to mitigate the dangers involved in building a particle accelerator.
  • #1
-NikolaTesla-
5
0
I'm a high school student and i have a great interest in particle physics. I'm looking to build a small linear particle accelerator. I have come across the designs attached
files.php?pid=91557&aid=2775.jpg

files.php?pid=91559&aid=2776.jpg
i was wondering if there is a simpler design? I'm new to the forum so any help would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
First, do you have any knowledge of how to safely use high voltage and how to deal with radiation? Those are REQUIRED if you are going to build anything like this.
 
  • #3
Yes i have prior experience with high voltage applications (examples, 900,000 Volt Tesla Coil-500,000 volt Van De Graaff generator. all of which i have built.) I am familiar with the fact that particle accelerators emit radiation. I would like some help and information about controlling the radiation and protecting my self from it, there was some suggestions in the attached link to a pdf file on the last page on protection from the radiation. I understand this is a very complicated project. I'm just trying to accelerate particles at a slower rate than what this particular design runs at. I'm not trying to create antimatter or anything of that nature, I'm just trying to run my own experiments in which i can study the collisions of atoms.

http://www.sciencemadness.org/talk/files.php?pid=91439&aid=2765"
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #4
i was also planning on running this in my backyard as it is about 1/4 of an acre. By controlling it remotely, about 25 to 30 feet away using a switch board and a wireless camera. I would suppose this would eliminate the possibility of becoming in contact of any radiation, gamma rays and x-rays. The link to the pdf recommended using 18 inches of concrete to shield yourself, which i would have no problem setting up, in which case it will probably be more like 25 inches just to be safe.
 
  • #5
I don't have any experience with accelerators, so I can't really say whether or not there are simpler ones available.
 
  • #6
you are seems to be too much curious and brave. I think we should think about what we are trying to achieve by all this, definitely you would have some purpose and aim. We should work together in groups for achieving something great.
 
  • #7
You should stop now. The most likely outcome from this project is your injury or death, or perhaps someone else's injury or death. There are many dangerous aspects to this, and it's evident that your experience is nowhere near where it needs to be to do this safely.

It would be like someone saying "I want to go skydiving, and I'll just hold on to a bedsheet to be my parachute. What color should I use?"
 
  • #8
humanistic said:
you are seems to be too much curious and brave. I think we should think about what we are trying to achieve by all this, definitely you would have some purpose and aim. We should work together in groups for achieving something great.

that sounds great. I'm very interested in working with others on this project.
 
  • #9
Vanadium 50 said:
You should stop now. The most likely outcome from this project is your injury or death, or perhaps someone else's injury or death. There are many dangerous aspects to this, and it's evident that your experience is nowhere near where it needs to be to do this safely.

It would be like someone saying "I want to go skydiving, and I'll just hold on to a bedsheet to be my parachute. What color should I use?"
I appreciate your input as this is a very serious project. I understand that this is a very complex and dangerous undertaking. I noticed that you have a PhD and i was wondering where you work ex. Fermilab, Stanford's LINAC. I was also wondering if you have an idea of a better project that would perhaps be safer that would still be related to the field of particle physics.I'm somewhat confused on what your finding is the dangerous part. I have no problem with dealing with the high voltages in evolved as i have built a series of high voltage apparatuses, so I'm thinking you are thinking of the radiation, the gamma rays and x-rays, which do present a dangerous problem.

Also I'm the kind of person who does like constructive criticism and or ideas and opinions.
So please give any input you may have.

Thanks
 
  • #10
-NikolaTesla- said:
I appreciate your input as this is a very serious project. I understand that this is a very complex and dangerous undertaking. I noticed that you have a PhD and i was wondering where you work ex. Fermilab, Stanford's LINAC. I was also wondering if you have an idea of a better project that would perhaps be safer that would still be related to the field of particle physics.


I'm somewhat confused on what your finding is the dangerous part. I have no problem with dealing with the high voltages in evolved as i have built a series of high voltage apparatuses, so I'm thinking you are thinking of the radiation, the gamma rays and x-rays, which do present a dangerous problem.

Also I'm the kind of person who does like constructive criticism and or ideas and opinions.
So please give any input you may have.

Thanks

One other dangerous aspect is the hard vacuum that you need to pull. There is a lot of energy stored in the pressure gradient across your vacuum enclosure.
 
  • #12
As long as you follow appropriate safety measures you should be fine. It looks like you already work with high voltage, so as long as you learn how to deal with radiation you should be ok. It really doesn't seem that much more dangerous than building a homemade Fusor. (Tabletop fusion reactor)

Hit up the forums at fusor.net and you can find a lot of info buried around in there about appropriate ways to deal with the hazards related to what you are wanting to do. Just realize that you CANNOT cut corners with safety. And especially if you do this in your backyard or somewhere with nearby neighbors.

Also, it is very unlikely that you will really be able to learn much from a homemade accelerator in my opinion. We've had accelerators for over 50 years, ranging from small ones the size of something you are thinking of making, up to the Large Hadron Collider. I'm not sure what you would really gain from making one of these.
 
  • #13
If I was you I'd study classical mechanics first, then classical E&M, then quantum mechanics, then find a graduate school who is doing research on particle physics and join them.

That's my idea for you...
 
  • #14
Drakkith said:
As long as you follow appropriate safety measures you should be fine. It looks like you already work with high voltage, so as long as you learn how to deal with radiation you should be ok. It really doesn't seem that much more dangerous than building a homemade Fusor. (Tabletop fusion reactor)

Hit up the forums at fusor.net and you can find a lot of info buried around in there about appropriate ways to deal with the hazards related to what you are wanting to do. Just realize that you CANNOT cut corners with safety. And especially if you do this in your backyard or somewhere with nearby neighbors.

Also, it is very unlikely that you will really be able to learn much from a homemade accelerator in my opinion. We've had accelerators for over 50 years, ranging from small ones the size of something you are thinking of making, up to the Large Hadron Collider. I'm not sure what you would really gain from making one of these.

Just to add one more thing before I lock this thread. Please find an in-person Mentor for any high voltage, high vacuum, radiation producing (etc.) projects you undertake. It's great that you have the curiosity and drive that you have. But speaking as somebody who has accidentally started fires, almost blown up my ChemE room-mate in undergrad, and have received numerous slightly sub-lethal HV shocks, you would benefit a lot from an in-person Mentor.

Thread locked.
 

1. What is the purpose of designing a simpler design?

The purpose of designing a simpler design is to increase efficiency and functionality. A simpler design can make a product or system easier to use, maintain, and understand, ultimately improving user experience.

2. How can a simpler design be achieved?

A simpler design can be achieved through the process of simplification, which involves eliminating unnecessary components, features, or complexities. This can be done through user research, prototyping, and testing to determine the most essential and effective elements of a design.

3. What are the benefits of a simpler design?

A simpler design can have numerous benefits, including increased user satisfaction, reduced production and maintenance costs, improved usability, and a more streamlined and intuitive experience for users.

4. Are there any downsides to a simpler design?

While the benefits of a simpler design are numerous, there can also be potential downsides. For example, simplifying a design too much can lead to a lack of necessary features or functionalities, reducing the overall effectiveness and user satisfaction.

5. How do you determine if a design is simple enough?

Determining if a design is simple enough can be a subjective process, as it depends on the intended purpose and target audience. However, conducting user testing and gathering feedback can help determine if the design is easy to understand and use, and if any further simplification is needed.

Similar threads

  • DIY Projects
Replies
2
Views
362
  • New Member Introductions
Replies
2
Views
52
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
1
Views
713
  • DIY Projects
Replies
21
Views
3K
  • DIY Projects
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
18
Views
2K
Back
Top