Recent content by spoirier

  1. S

    Can modern physics be understood qualitatively?

    I see you implicitly assuming a radical opposition between being mathematical (accurate) and being described in words without equations. I disagree with the idea of such an opposition. Indeed some of the math needs equations hard to understand for the majority, but I still see possibilities to...
  2. S

    Redesigning Mathematics Curriculum, thoughts?

    I also have a plan to redesign the math and physics curriculum. For this the way I found best was most often to just rewrite everything from scratch rather than collect external references, as in most cases I don't know good enough references compared to what I can make myself. My work remains...
  3. S

    Interesting articles online on academia and the PhD problem

    Moreover, my contribution was NOT off-topic. There are many ideas in my speech that are on-topic. But you need to actually take the time to read or hear it to notice this.
  4. S

    Interesting articles online on academia and the PhD problem

    Sorry but I see no legitimate right to pretend that I should shut up and let you conclude by such an awful and completely mad personal attack that you are making against me. I think I was clear about the problem. Not only my intelligence, my shyness, my natural temptation to respect and trust...
  5. S

    Interesting articles online on academia and the PhD problem

    Yes absolutely I was forced. Especially by my mother, who behaved as a tyrant, under the influence of some authoritative voices around (teachers, etc). I'm very tired of all those people who can't believe that this could happen. As I wrote here :
  6. S

    Interesting articles online on academia and the PhD problem

    I agree that, unfortunately, academic degrees are nonsense, and I'm very angry at people around who forced me to "study" up to PhD, following all that academic nonsense after I had already managed to rediscover a mathematical expression of General Relativity when I was 16. I just posted my...
  7. S

    An interesting way to get an interference pattern

    I think you made the right guess at the end of your video already : it's the pixels, the dense periodic succession of vertical lines in the structure of the screen. You can find more detailed explanations in the wikipedia article "Diffraction grating". An interference from 2 slits, alternates...
  8. S

    Definition of the Einstein Tensor

    I provide an answer this question in my page General Relativity : the Einstein field equation. I just wrote this page in the last days; see also the cosmology page linked there for a more intuitive, less formal description. This explanation is quite brief and assumes some familiarity with tensor...
  9. S

    The axiom of choice one a finite family of sets.

    It depends. Only if you have an explicitly finite family of nonempty sets, that you can list : E1,...En then you can use a proof whose length is proportional to n : Let x1 in E1, Let x2 in E2, ... Let xn in En then (x1,...,xn) is in the product, which is thus nonempty. But for the mathematical...
  10. S

    What counts as an observation in QM?

    Why post links to articles that cannot be read online for free ? and the title does not sound like a consensual position. The concept of observation in QM indeed first appears as fuzzy and undefined. But it is only so as long as you keep applying the equations to a small isolated system. In...
  11. S

    What is the explanation behind the binary result in the EPR thought experiment?

    According to John Baez's page of http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/open.questions.html, I would describe things like this : QM does not predict anything like a preference for [either "horizontal" or "vertical"] polarization over diagonal polarization, because there is not such a thing as a...
  12. S

    How Do Photons Entangle Electrons?

    If you look for a process that can produced entangled particles, a natural one is to take a pair of electrons and separate them passively in a spatial manner without using a magnetic field. Then their spins are entangled (opposite to each other in any direction of measurement). Still it is not...
  13. S

    How can a machine be created to produce energy in GR?

    Energy in GR can no more be described as a precise quantity simply obtained by integrating some explicit field along the space-like 3D surface we consider. This does not mean that there is no conservation of energy. But it takes a more subtle, complex form. In particular we can roughly define...
  14. S

    Conceptual underpinning(s) of the QM projection postulate

    In my opinion the only reasonable interpretation is the "Mind makes collapse" interpretation. I explained this starting with introductions of metaphysics, noting that purely mathematical laws of physics can only describe a mathematical universe, with a merely mathematical existence. There...
  15. S

    How does light lose energy as it travels over distance?

    I already answered this question in https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=613451.
Back
Top