Calculating Tension in a Telephone Wire: Physics Problem Help

  • Thread starter Thread starter sisigsarap
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Tension Wire
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the tension in a telephone wire when a bird lands on it, causing the wire to sag. The user initially calculated the tension using incorrect angles and equations, leading to a result of 610 N instead of the expected 613 N. Another participant clarified the correct approach, emphasizing the use of the right triangle formed by the sag and the distance between the poles. They pointed out that the y-components of the tensions must equal the weight of the bird, and suggested using the correct trigonometric functions for accurate calculations. Ultimately, the user was able to arrive at the correct answer after receiving guidance on the equations and angles involved.
sisigsarap
Messages
17
Reaction score
0
I am having a little difficulty with a physics problem, hopefully someone can help!

Q. The distance between two telephone poles is 50.0m. When a 1.00kg bird lands on the telephone wire midway between the poles, the wire sags .200m. Ignore the weight of the wire.

Using the data given I used 25.0m and .200m as legs of a right triangle and solved for the hypotenuse which I found to be 25.0007999. Then I found the angles that made up that triangle.

Then I did the sum of Force x = T1 sin89.54 + T2sign89.54 = 0
and the sum of Force y = -T1cos89.54 + -T2cos89.54 = 9.8
Then solving for T2 I get approximately 610 N as well as 610 N for T1. So a net Force Y of -9.8.

What am i doing wrong? I know the answer is 613 N, but I am lost.

Thanks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Actually

\tan\theta = \frac{0.2}{25} = 0.458^o

Also i notice on your Y-axis analysis you should have

T_{1}sin(0.458) + T_{2}sin(0.458) = mg

and on your x-axis

T_{1}cos(0.458) = T_{2}cos(0.458)

Hint: Tensions are equal!
 
Last edited:
venom, what program do u use to typ in the math symbols? how can i do that so I can type things easier?
 
CinderBlockFist said:
venom, what program do u use to typ in the math symbols? how can i do that so I can type things easier?

The program is called LaTeX, and this forum has it integrated.

Check this link
https://www.physicsforums.com/misc/howtolatex.pdf
 
Thank you for your help Cyclovenom! I was able to get the correct answer using the information you gave me.

I do have 1 other question though,
In the work I did, I was using T1 Cos 89.54 + T2cos 89.54 = 9.8
This should give the same answer I would think, however it gives 610 N rather than the 613 N. Why is there a difference?

To get the angle of 89.54 I simply did ArcTan 25/.2

Thanks again,
Joshua
 
sisigsarap said:
Thank you for your help Cyclovenom! I was able to get the correct answer using the information you gave me.

I do have 1 other question though,
In the work I did, I was using T1 Cos 89.54 + T2cos 89.54 = 9.8
This should give the same answer I would think, however it gives 610 N rather than the 613 N. Why is there a difference?

To get the angle of 89.54 I simply did ArcTan 25/.2

Thanks again,
Joshua

Well if you see the triangle actually the oposite side will be 0.2 and the adjacent side will be 25 m.

so the x-component of a tension like T will hace been Tcos(angle) and the Y component Tsin(angle), also weight points directly to the center of the Earth, so it will be pointing down the bird while the tensions point in the direction of the wire, so the y-components of the tensions will relate with weight in the equation above. Remember we are considering equilibrium situation.
 
Also Imagine you put a coordinate system with origin in the bird's location. You can brind the angle you found between the space the straight line and x-axis make, that is a geometry postulate very useful, If i remember correctly it was altenate inner angles are equal.
 
Back
Top