Understanding the Doppler Effect: Common Misconceptions in Physics Explained"

AI Thread Summary
The discussion explores the Doppler Effect in relation to electromagnetic waves and sound waves, highlighting the differences in how each behaves as the source moves. It explains that as a wave source approaches, the wave compresses, increasing frequency, while it stretches and decreases frequency as it recedes. Electromagnetic waves maintain a constant speed (the speed of light, c) regardless of the medium, unlike sound waves, which vary based on environmental conditions. Additionally, it notes that gravity can influence wave energy, causing redshift in light escaping from massive objects like black holes. This explanation serves as a foundational understanding of the concepts before more detailed insights are provided.
Evilinside
Messages
20
Reaction score
0
Hi, I am sort of a new to physics. So far I've only been doing motion, up to the formula for average power. However I was reading something in Earth Science as I was going to help someone study for their regents test, you know how school is almost over and all. Then I read about the Doppler Effect. I must be wrong, but it seems to propose that Electromagnetic energy contains some sort of structural force and there in resisting motion. To my knowledge that's what would cause it bend or stretch due the position proximity of Earth. Where is the error of my thinking?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
It might be easiest to envision the electromagnetic wave in the same way as a sound wave, since the Doppler effect applies to both. There is a difference that I'll mention in a minute.
As the source of the wave approaches, the wave is compressed in front of it. As it recedes, the wave is stretched out behind.
With EM, the speed must remain at c (whatever that is in accordance with the medium of transmission), so the energy gain in approaching is expressed as an increase of frequency so that the wavelength can shorten while still maintaining the proper relationship among the 3 components. Going away, the wavelength stretches and the frequency decreases.
Sound works the same way, except that rather than being a constant, the speed varies dependent upon the ambient temperature & pressure as well as the medium. It also does require a physical medium of some sort, whereas EM radiation does not.
Since gravity saps energy from waves, proximity to a significant mass can effect a redshift in light trying to escape. For a black hole, the redshift becomes infinite.
This is a preliminary explanation only, to tide you over until someone like SpaceTiger can supply you with something more proper.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top