Frame of reference Definition and 199 Threads

Does the existence of the "Axis of Evil" observed by WMAP and Planck mean that there is a special frame of reference in the universe?

Astronauts on a long space journey are playing golf inside their spaceship, which is traveling away from the Earth with speed 0.6c. One of the astronauts hits a drive exactly along the length of the spaceship (in its direction of travel) at speed 0.1c in the frame of the spaceship. What is the...

If light has a maximum speed of c, what frame of reference is that speed determined from? For example, if you were to turn on a light bulb moving at a constant rate and measured when the light in every direction got to one light year away from it's source, wouldn't some of it reach that...

Why does one particular 'frame of reference' have fictitious forces (like inertia) whilst another one doesn't. I understand the basics, but more interested in 'why' space seems to have magically chosen specific frame to be the 'non inertial frame'. Could space be more absolute than we...

I've researched about it and watched a few videos, but I can't seem to get my head around it. Would saying that "it's a marker that is fixed relative to your position, in which Newton's first law holds" be an accurate way to define it?

Lift and Drag...Which frame of reference? Hi, When expressing the Lift and Drag acting on an airplane as: F_{lift}=qSC_L F_{drag}=qSC_D where q is the dynamic pressure, S is the wing ref. area, and C's are the lift and drag coefficient. My question: Some sources, like this one...

I have doubts of how can I put my frame of reference in a simple harmonic motion vertical spring. Normally the books choose the origin in the equilibrium position and the positive distance (x>0) downward, and in this conditions Newton´s second law is: ma=-kx; but instead of putting the positive...

Newton's laws of motions are not applicable in Non-inertial frames of reference which means only mutually accelerated frames of references, My question is how can we apply Newton's laws of motions for practical experiments such as simple pendulum, motion of a ball, etc. conducted in near surface...

I've got a problem regarding tensors. Premise: we are considering a fluid particle with a velocity \mathbf{u} and a position vector \mathbf{x}; S_{ij} is the strain rate tensor, defined in this way: \displaystyle{S_{ij}=\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{\partial u_i}{\partial x_j} +\frac{\partial...

(Please forgive me for the obvious stupidity of this question) I'm trying to understand Newton's laws down to the last detail, because that is how I study things. However, where would the principle of inertia ever take place? And since Newton's laws are only applicable in an inertia frame...

Hi, I've seen the forces in a turn depicted two different ways: http://selair.selkirk.ca/Training/Aerodynamics/images/lf-turn.gif http://www.free-online-private-pilot-ground-school.com/images/forces_during_turn.gif Which one is correct? I think the first one would be since it's...

Homework Statement Generic collision question. For example, let's say you are asked the following question: Object 1 is 10kg and is traveling at 10 m/s [right] Object 2 is 5kg and is traveling at 2 m/s [right] Find their final collisions after impact Homework Equations m1v1 +...

How does the concept of frame of reference apply to quantum mechanics? Classically something can be a frame of reference as long as it is not accelerating. I often picture in my head an atom with the nucleus fixed and the electron cloud surrounding it. Would it be possible to describe an atom...

Suppose I'm considering particles of mass \mu_i, 1 \leq i \leq 3, located at positions r_i. Suppose I ignore the potential between \mu_1 and \mu_2. Then the Hamiltonian I'd write down would be H = -\frac{1}{2\mu_1}\Delta_1 -\frac{1}{2\mu_2}\Delta_2 - \frac{1}{2\mu_3}\Delta_3 + V_1(r_3 -...

I'm working problem from the upper division classical mechanics course on MIT OCW. No solutions are available. This is form the first P-set, question 4. Homework Statement A particle moves in a two dimensional orbit defined by x = A(2αt-sin(αt)) y = A(1-cos(αt)) Find the tangential...

As I understand it, Einstein's dismissal of the "luminiferous aether" was based on his discovery that there is no universal frame of reference, i.e. that no frame of reference is privileged in relation to all other frames. My question is whether this principle can also be stated in the inverse...

I've been giving some thought to the new scientist article about the equivalence principle. What initially seems like a very simple issue is remarkably tantalising. (please note- I'm not a physicist so this may be quite stupid) This led me on a little to the question of gravity and direction...

I know that you're going to probably say that a frame of reference doesn't make sense for light, but I've uploaded a discussion (warning: has profanity) from another website (reddit.com) and I'm curious to see if the user Imhtpsnvsbl makes a valid point.

hello, in relativity something can go faster than the speed of light as long as it is not in the observer's frame of reference which would say that a FOR has a size but i read that a FOR was infinite in all directions. Someone explain this contradiction please!

Hi! I think this should be a fairly easy question to resolve, but it's currently giving me fits... Suppose we consider a system of three interacting particles where we assume two of the particle (at positions r1 and r2) have infinite mass (such that we can ignore their kinetic energy) and do...

Before I say anything, I don't really have any experience in physics. But this question just popped into my mind concerning cause and effect and I can't seem to find the answer to it on the web. Here it is...Are cause and effect the same thing if a frame of reference is not present? For...

In studying SR, I've been subscribing to a particular definition of a Frame of Reference that makes sense to me. Recently, I've been made aware by another PF member that there may be other, broader, definitions that are valid and that people use. I would like to know more about these broader...

Practicing Lorentz transformations but still not absolutely clear about conditions for observer's frame of reference. For example: Suppose that just as one of Einstein's long and surreally fast trains is passing a station platform, lightning strikes the platform at two points making scorch...

Homework Statement I wanted to know if I consider the frame of reference as a rotating body itself, then will the points lying on the body rotating be stationary with respect to the rotating frame of reference? Homework Equations None The Attempt at a Solution As per me, if I am...

Homework Statement You are flying your personal rocketcraft at 0.9c from Star A toward Star B. The distance between the stars, in the stars' reference frame, is 1.0 ly. Both stars happen to explode simultaneously in your reference frame at the instant you are exactly halfway between them...

Hi there! I'm working on a couple of problems regarding simultaneity. For one I'm given events X_a = (ct,x,y,z) = (2,1,-3,2) and X_b = (6,3,-1,5) I want to find out if there's a frame of reference where the events are simultaneous. I find the change vector X_b - X_a = (Δct,Δx,Δy,Δz) =...

Homework Statement When the box is at the bottom of the incline it will have a velocity of vf The person is an inertial frame of reference with a velocity of vf When the person starts moving, the box is moving backwards with the velocity of vf. This means at the top of the hill the box has...

We know that we can't say whether we are at rest or uniformly moving if we're in a einstein cage..but if the same medium is accelerating/decelerating can we being inside(and can't see outside) claim abt state of cage..?I ve read that a non-inertial can be converted to inertial by incorporating a...

I have just completed my class 10th. I was presently reading the class 11th H.C Verma physics textbook and here is what I confronted which seems to me as if I am unable to fathom : Now I can't understand that how come acceleration of book with respect to Earth isn't 0 ?! Please see bold part...

If we have light, any particle, and maybe car, the particles travel at 0.98c and car let say 50m/s. Let them start moving at the same time to the given point let say 300 metres away. The difference between times of arrival of light and particle will be small compared to that between light and...

I found out that Proxima Centauri is 4.2 light years away from earth. If someone was on a voyage to this star via space ship, would this person measure the time to be shorter than 4.2 years if their spaceship was traveling 99.99999 percent the speed of light, assuming that the 4.2 years is...

Hi All! I found discussions on this here while researching the subject to see if anyone else has attempted to explore the subject. I saw that several people asked questions pertaining to this, but the question was never really answered. It seemed unanswerable. While many discussions of...

Breit Frame of reference ("Brick Wall") I am having a lot of trouble understanding breit frame of reference.I was trying to solve griffiths problem 3.21 (1st ed.): Consider elastic scattering- A+B----->A+B If particle A carries energy E, and scatters at an angle theta in the CM, a) what is...

Can the kinetic friction be in the direction of acceleration? I am thinking of the example of a box on a flatbed truck accelerating to the right from rest. The box accelerates to the left due to the inertial force as seen by an observer on the truck where the kinetic friction is opposite to the...

A large heavy box is sliding without friction down a smooth plane of inclination Ɵ. From a point P on the bottom of the box, a particle is projected inside the box. The initial speed of the particle with respect to the box is 'u' and the direction of projection makes an angle α with the bottom...

Please help, I am confused with part c and d. 1. Doug in a lab on Earth observes a π-meson is created 2.8 km from the surface of the Earth. It has a rest decay time is 9.0 x 10-6 s and it travels straight down to the Earth at 0.95c. a) What distance would the π-meson measure to the lab...

If a solid object rotates at constant angular velocity, is it possible to chose an inertial reference frame in which the object will not rotate?

I am confused about the twin paradox. Let's imagine Mike and Angela are twins. Mike stays on Earth, and Angela rockets off, away from Earth at close to the speed of light, with the intention of making a round trip back to Earth at the end of her voyage. My question is this: why wouldn't...

The Earth is an approximately inertial reference frame since it's acceleration with respect to the stars is very small. But if a group of stars is accelerating with respect to another group of stars which group is the inertial frame? Or thinking on an even larger scale, if a universe is...

Einstein's theory of relativity is based on the fact that all motion is relative, which precludes the existence of a universally defined state of rest (priviledged reference frame). Einstein also recognises the existence of rest mass. If an object were at its rest mass, wouldn't it be perfectly...

Okay, so I know what inertial and non-inertial frames of reference are: 1. Inertial is when Newton's laws of motion hold. 2. Noninertial is when they do not hold (the object is accelerating without a force). And I have a few examples as well, such as when you are is in a car and the car is...

I have been doing some study on the theory of relativity and it has got me thinking. We say that the Earth revolves around the Sun but from what reference frame? From the reference frame of Earch, we are stationery and the Sun simply spins. Why is any reference frame more accurate than another...

My thinking has been that a photon, in its own F of R, in a vacuum, travels through space, but not through time. This seems to have been "confirmed" in various things I have read. However, I recently came across the assertion that "...in physics, there is no theory that defines the frame...

So I was studying some physics, and I keep encountering how many things depend on the frame of reference. For example, kinetic energy and momentum. My question is if there is an absolute frame of reference? Can we define one? I remember reading somewhere that the absolute reference...

Hi, I have a simple question in my mind, I could not find the answer anywhere so I came here. Here is my question, Assume a source of light and observer are five light seconds apart, and are travling parllel to each other at a constant speed of say 200 meters per second. Now if the source of...

Major difference of Inertial and non-inertial frame of reference ?? What is the major difference or differences of Inertial and non-Inertial frame of reference?? Is it only: Inertial - Constant velocity, obeys the law of inertia Non-inertial - Acceleration, disobeys the law of inertia

Okay, weird question. Sorry if this is really stupid but it's been bugging at me for days now. First, let me lay out my current assumptions/understanding of what's going on. The current theory seems to be (to an amateur like myself) that there is no fixed space-time. That to talk about...

I know that in Newtonian mechanics an inertial frame of reference moves relative to absolute space. But why does Newtonian mechanics include the contention that two inertial reference frames move relative to each other? It seems that if you have an absolute reference frame then there is no...

Hello, I've always wondered about the "relativity" of the De Broglie wavelength. The wavelength depends on the momentum of the specific thing we are observing, thus on different frames of reference(F.O.R from now on :P) we might get different answers. I have been looking through the web to...

Consider I am in the train with a ball traveling at normal speed of a train. I drop the ball, it follows a straight path of descent and falls in front of my feet. For an observer on the platform, the ball follows a parabolic path and falls in front of my feet. (Please go to this...