What If You Could Build a Rocket with Infinite Exhaust Speed?

  • Thread starter peron
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses the possibility of a rocket with infinite exhaust and whether it would be able to move. The concept is deemed impossible and any force or velocity would be meaningless. The idea of light pressure and a flashlight as a propulsion unit is also mentioned.
  • #1
peron
15
0
What if you could build a rocket, with the exhaust "leaving" the engine at a instantaneous speed, would such a rocket with a infinite exhaust move?

The particles leaving the engine will reach a different destination as soon as the rocket was switched on, so how could such a rocket exert a force?

I'm kinda confused.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Force is the change of momentum of a body. Presumably in your scenario (which is kind of impossible) the particles leaving the rocket would change the momentum of the rocket and propel it forward. Ultimately what you are describing can't happen and that makes it sort of meaningless. The velocity of the particles would be meaningless and therefore the force they exert would also be meaningless.
 
  • #3
Non-physical assumptions will lead to nonsensical conclusions.
 
  • #4
I built an engine that had an exhaust speed of C.
It wouldn't move at all. (turn your flashlight on...)
 
  • #5
PaulS1950 said:
I built an engine that had an exhaust speed of C.
It wouldn't move at all. (turn your flashlight on...)

There is a well known phenomenon of 'light pressure'. The beam from your torch represents a steady change of momentum - so your torch is a (very feeble) propulsion unit.
 

FAQ: What If You Could Build a Rocket with Infinite Exhaust Speed?

1. What is the purpose of asking "What if?" questions in science?

The purpose of asking "What if?" questions in science is to explore different possibilities and scenarios in order to better understand a concept or phenomenon. It allows scientists to think critically and creatively about potential outcomes and to test their hypotheses.

2. How do scientists come up with "What if?" questions?

Scientists come up with "What if?" questions through observation, experimentation, and research. By observing patterns or anomalies in data, scientists can identify areas that require further investigation and formulate "What if?" questions to explore those areas.

3. Can "What if?" questions help in problem-solving?

Yes, "What if?" questions can be a useful tool in problem-solving. By considering different scenarios and outcomes, scientists can develop potential solutions and strategies to address a problem. "What if?" questions also help in identifying potential obstacles and finding ways to overcome them.

4. How do "What if?" questions contribute to the scientific method?

"What if?" questions are an essential part of the scientific method. They help scientists to formulate hypotheses, design experiments, and analyze data. By asking "What if?" questions, scientists can also identify potential variables and controls to ensure their experiments are valid and reliable.

5. Are there any limitations to using "What if?" questions in science?

While "What if?" questions can be a valuable tool in the scientific process, there are also limitations to their use. For example, "What if?" questions are based on assumptions and may not always reflect real-world situations. Additionally, some "What if?" questions may be too hypothetical to test through experimentation, making them more difficult to answer definitively.

Back
Top