Air resistance - freefall and horizontal projectile motion

3 replies · 3K views · last reply
ChessEnthusiast
Messages
115
Reaction score
3
We have two identical balls sitting at the same height. One of them is released without applying any force (it falls freely) and the other one is given a non-zero horizontal velocity. Which of them will hit the ground first?
The force of air resistance is proportional to the square of the velocity.

Based on what I've experienced solving typical projectile problems, I am inclined to answer that they will hit the groudn at the same time. Also, I believe that at any given time, the vertical component of the force of air resistance will be equal in both cases.

Am I missing something?
 
The question is perhaps a little trickier than it seems. My intuition was that the ball given an initial velocity will slow down more quickly and therefore stay in the air longer. Unfortunately, projectile motion with air drag involves a set of coupled non-linear differential equations so one must solve them numerically for an exact solution (though the vertical-motion-only case is analytically solvable). I used Mathematica to generate some plots to check. In the following graphs the terminal velocity of the object is about 31m/s and it is dropped/fired from a height of 5 meters. The dashed curve represents the dropped object and the solid curve represents the fired object. First set of graphs is for an initial speed about 1/3 of the terminal velocity:
Line graph of vertical position against time, starting at height 5 and falling to 0 near time 1.05, with a solid curve and a nearly overlapping dashed curve.
Line graph of vertical velocity against time from 0 to 2 seconds, with vertical velocity falling from 0 to about -17 at 2 seconds; a solid and a dashed curve nearly overlap, the dashed one slightly lower at the end.
Line graph of vertical acceleration against time from 0 to 2 s, with two curves starting near -10 and rising to about -6.5; the solid curve lies slightly above the dashed curve.


The difference in all parameters is minimal.

Next, a firing speed near terminal velocity:

Line graph of vertical position against time: a solid curve and a dashed curve both fall from height 5 at time 0, the solid curve reaching zero slightly later, near time 1.05.
Line graph of vertical velocity against time from 0 to 2, showing two downward curves; the solid curve falls more slowly than the dashed curve, ending near -15 and -17.5 respectively.
Line graph of vertical acceleration against time from 0 to 2.0, with a solid curve and a dashed curve both starting near -10 and rising toward -6 and -7.


Finally, for good measure, firing at roughly twice the terminal velocity:

Line graph of vertical position against time for two falling objects: a solid curve and a dashed curve, starting at height 5 and reaching zero, with the solid curve landing slightly later.
Line graph of vertical velocity against time from 0 to 2 seconds, with a solid curve and a dashed curve both falling below zero, the dashed curve falling faster and ending near -17 while the solid curve ends near -14.
Line graph of vertical acceleration against time from 0 to 2.0 s; solid curve rises from about -10 to about -5.5, dashed curve from about -10 to about -6.8.


Indeed, the greater the initial horizontal velocity the greater the impact on the vertical components of the motion.
 
Attachments
  • Line graph of vertical position against time, starting at height 5 and falling to 0 near time 1.05, with a solid curve and a nearly overlapping dashed curve.
    upload_2018-8-13_20-52-44.png
    2.7 KB · Views: 735
  • Line graph of vertical velocity against time from 0 to 2 seconds, with vertical velocity falling from 0 to about -17 at 2 seconds; a solid and a dashed curve nearly overlap, the dashed one slightly lower at the end.
    upload_2018-8-13_20-52-50.png
    2.8 KB · Views: 675
  • Line graph of vertical acceleration against time from 0 to 2 s, with two curves starting near -10 and rising to about -6.5; the solid curve lies slightly above the dashed curve.
    upload_2018-8-13_20-52-56.png
    2.2 KB · Views: 621
  • Line graph of vertical position against time: a solid curve and a dashed curve both fall from height 5 at time 0, the solid curve reaching zero slightly later, near time 1.05.
    upload_2018-8-13_20-54-14.png
    3 KB · Views: 643
  • Line graph of vertical velocity against time from 0 to 2, showing two downward curves; the solid curve falls more slowly than the dashed curve, ending near -15 and -17.5 respectively.
    upload_2018-8-13_20-54-21.png
    2.9 KB · Views: 651
  • Line graph of vertical acceleration against time from 0 to 2.0, with a solid curve and a dashed curve both starting near -10 and rising toward -6 and -7.
    upload_2018-8-13_20-54-27.png
    2.6 KB · Views: 604
  • Line graph of vertical position against time for two falling objects: a solid curve and a dashed curve, starting at height 5 and reaching zero, with the solid curve landing slightly later.
    upload_2018-8-13_20-55-56.png
    2.9 KB · Views: 671
  • Line graph of vertical velocity against time from 0 to 2 seconds, with a solid curve and a dashed curve both falling below zero, the dashed curve falling faster and ending near -17 while the solid curve ends near -14.
    upload_2018-8-13_20-56-3.png
    2.9 KB · Views: 641
  • Line graph of vertical acceleration against time from 0 to 2.0 s; solid curve rises from about -10 to about -5.5, dashed curve from about -10 to about -6.8.
    upload_2018-8-13_20-56-12.png
    2.5 KB · Views: 612
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: ChessEnthusiast, Delta2 and PhanthomJay
It might help to explain that when drag force is split up into components (parametric equations), you end up with something like:

$$drag_x = 1/2 \rho\ C_d\ v_x |v|$$
$$drag_y = 1/2 \rho\ C_d\ v_y |v|$$
$$|v| = \sqrt{v_x^2 + v_y^2}$$

Where |v| is the magnitude of the velocity, independent of direction. There isn't a closed form solution to this problem, so some type of numerical integration is used. Trying to find a source for these equations requires doing a search for parametric drag equation. Page 30 of this pdf file includes equations similar to what I wrote above.

https://www.whitman.edu/Documents/Academics/Mathematics/2016/Henelsmith.pdf
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: ChessEnthusiast, Delta2 and brainpushups
Indeed. And a much more intuitive way of seeing why increasing the x component of velocity will have an affect on the vertical component of force.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2