Are there any advantages to a one-hose (portable) air-conditioner?

  • Thread starter hmmm27
  • Start date
In summary: No, sorry, it ejects hot air as well. The exhaust hose is quite warm (and - at 20 feet long, running the length of my closet - rather inefficient).In summary, the conversation was about a single-hose portable air conditioner that the speaker had purchased. They discussed the limitations of using a single-hose unit, such as the fact that it exhausts warm room air to the outside, making it less efficient. The speaker plans to DIY the unit into a two-hose for better performance. They also touched on the difference between evaporative coolers and air conditioners, and the role of outside air in cooling. They also discussed the speaker's experience with a dehumidifier, which also has the function
  • #1
hmmm27
Gold Member
1,242
672
TL;DR Summary
The only thing I can imagine is that a mfr can advertise a higher BTU/hr figure.
So, I picked up a used single-hose portable a/c (window is better than portable of course - and cheaper - but my back is shot and for some reason the super takes a dim view of window units on the 20th floor).

It was 31C for a few days, earlier in the week : this normally means I'm screwed without a cold sink on hand (yes, it's on the laundry list of medical issues I'm currently trying to have addressed). I was prepared for the advertised 8,500BTU/hr to be around 5k net instead : it's not a large room(12x 12'?) and should be doable.

On the one hand, the room went from 90F down to 80F, but I was looking for the ability to drop it down to 65F, or so (enough wiggle room that I can count on 70F : a comfortable sleeping temperature for yours truly).

It's not (or at least doesn't appear to be) a faulty unit - the air coming out of the vent is cold enough - but, the fact that the damned thing is actively exhausting warmed room air to the outside at about the same rate it's providing cold air is pretty annoying. Also, within context of an apartment building, 5/6 sides of the room are non-radiative into nighttime relative coolth.

I'm going to DIY the thing into a two-hose for the obvious reason, having the requisite amount of cardboard and duct-tape on hand to build a plenum for the short length of 5" hose I'm going to use. It does appear to have two inlets for air (two grills; one has a filter, behind it). But, that's probably next week's post.

Meanwhile, the mystery I'd like to solve is "Which idiot designed this thing ? and in what context would it actually be useful ?"Thanks
 
Last edited:
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
It's not clear what you mean. Is this an evaporative cooler? Can't you just vent the warm air out the window?
bb2ea1c5-bdaa-464b-9b14-dadff7d8e725.__CR0,0,1500,1500_PT0_SX300_V1___.jpg
 
  • #3
The pic is similar to the unit I have. That's an actual air-conditioner, not a swamp (evaporative) cooler.

With the two-hose models, outside air is inletted, warmed and exhausted to the outside ; inside air is cooled.

With the one-hose models, the inside air is used to dump heat to the outside, thus only one hose is necessary.

Comparison

I'm honestly trying to figure out how the one-hose a/c's got past design quality-control.
 
  • Like
Likes russ_watters
  • #4
bob012345 said:
It's not clear what you mean. Is this an evaporative cooler? Can't you just vent the warm air out the window?
The problem is that if you exhaust the hot air to outside, you need to bring in make-up air from somewhere, otherwise you will deflate the room. So yeah, they're not great.
 
  • #5
russ_watters said:
The problem is that if you exhaust the hot air to outside, you need to bring in make-up air from somewhere, otherwise you will deflate the room. So yeah, they're not great.
That makes sense. Thanks. So I presume window units reject the heat using already outside air just like my AC compressor at my house. Now I get what hmmm27 is planning to do, to turn a one hose into a two hose.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes russ_watters
  • #6
bob012345 said:
That makes sense. Thanks. So I presume window units reject the heat using already outside air just like my AC compressor at my house. I suppose you could bring in outside air, run it over the coils and send it back outside to reject heat. Is that what's going on here?
https://www.physicsforums.com/attachments/284317
Yep, you got it!
 
  • Like
Likes bob012345
  • #7
I'm interested in this problem because I live in Dallas and it's been humid. I keep my house on the warmer side as it is to limit stress on the AC system. I just bought a dehumidifier to dry out the air inside. One thing I noticed is that is rejects warm (not hot) air into the room. Sure, it's dryer air but I still need to compensate for it with the central air. I wasn't expecting that yet I suppose I should have.

So basically this dehumidifier is similar to an AC unit. My theory is that is cools the air (a lot) to condense out the water (three gallons so far in less than 24 hours!) then mixes that cool air back with the hot air to attempt to be neutral. The extent the air is warm is a measure of the slight mismatch between hot and cold air due to basic inefficiencies.

I conclude its still worth it since the dryer air will feel cooler and will actually cool more efficiently in the central AC.
 
  • #8
My one-hose portable unit pulls air from the room, cools it (dehumidifying it in the process), then uses the heat to evaporate the collected water, and ejects it outside. I never have to dump the water.
 
  • Like
Likes Evo
  • #9
DaveC426913 said:
My one-hose portable unit pulls air from the room, cools it (dehumidifying it in the process), then uses the heat to evaporate the collected water, and ejects it outside. I never have to dump the water.
So you're saying it recycles the room air and only rejects the water vapor?
 
  • #10
DaveC426913 said:
My one-hose cportable unit pulls air from the room, cools it (dehumidifying it in the process), then uses the heat to evaporate the collected water, and ejects it outside. I never have to dump the water.
That's what I thought (as a sole advantage) until I read where a two-hose unit does the same thing. I thought that the exhaust would be extremely hot (to minimize blowing out inside-air) but it's just warm.

[OT'ically ; I remember your thread regarding that; how did it turn out ?]

Back to 1 vs 2 hose, I suppose a one-hose could be used parasitically in a domicile that already has central A/C, but one room isn't cool enough for its purpose... and simply sticking a fan in the (house HVAC) vent to increase flow wouldn't occur to everybody.
 
  • #11
bob012345 said:
So you're saying it recycles the room air and only rejects the water vapor?
No, sorry, it ejects hot air as well. The exhaust hose is quite warm (and - at 20 feet long, running the length of my closet - rather inefficient).

No, that does not mean my closet is 20 feet long...

Also, whatever happened to the font size options in messages?
 
  • #12
hmmm27 said:
[OT'ically ; I remember your thread regarding that; how did it turn out ?]
Er. I don't. :sorry: What was I doing?
 
  • #13
DaveC426913 said:
Er. I don't. :sorry: What was I doing?
Well, somebody was going on about trying to configure a one-hose portable in their attic. I'd a fleeting thought of lending a spare dehumidifier I had, but (I don't think) the thread continued long enough to get to that stage.

Alternate universe, mebbe.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes bob012345
  • #14
hmmm27 said:
Well, somebody was going on about trying to configure a one-hose portable in their attic. I'd a fleeting thought of lending a spare dehumidifier I had, but (I don't think) the thread continued long enough to get to that stage.

Alternate universe, mebbe.
I was, and I did, and I vaguely remember asking about it. Oh yeah. I was trying to figure out where to place it in relation to my BR/closet doorway for best efficiency.

I finally cut an 8" hole in the wall between the two rooms so I could run the hose into the BR and not have the AC sitting in the doorway where someone* would trip and fall down the stairs.

*inevitably my wife
 
  • #15
Well, in your case it might actually work reasonably well, considering that - from childhood memory - the upper floor is still broiler hot long after the sun's gone down : useful thermal mass in the winter, not so much in the summer.

bob012345 said:
I'm interested in this problem because I live in Dallas and it's been humid. I keep my house on the warmer side as it is to limit stress on the AC system. I just bought a dehumidifier to dry out the air inside. One thing I noticed is that is rejects warm (not hot) air into the room. Sure, it's dryer air but I still need to compensate for it with the central air. I wasn't expecting that yet I suppose I should have.
A dehumidifier in a closed system (ie: not venting to or from the outside) will heat the air a little... but "at least it's a dry heat". I put one in my niece's condo basement ; it cleared things right up and almost completely ditched the musty smell. You'll have taken a load off the regular A/C by using it.
 
  • Like
Likes bob012345
  • #16
hmmm27 said:
Well, in your case it might actually work reasonably well, considering that - from childhood memory - the upper floor is still broiler hot long after the sun's gone down : useful thermal mass in the winter, not so much in the summer.
This is an attic, converted by an amateur, for his own occasional visit. There was 2 inches of air gap - and nothing else - between drywall and shingle.

I once measured the room temp to be 107F before I got the AC in. :))

I had 10" candles in 4" holders. They had melted and fallen over till they touched the table.
 
  • Wow
Likes Evo
  • #17
bob012345 said:
I'm interested in this problem because I live in Dallas and it's been humid. I keep my house on the warmer side as it is to limit stress on the AC system. I just bought a dehumidifier to dry out the air inside. One thing I noticed is that is rejects warm (not hot) air into the room. Sure, it's dryer air but I still need to compensate for it with the central air. I wasn't expecting that yet I suppose I should have.

So basically this dehumidifier is similar to an AC unit.
You are correct - an AC unit and dehumidifier are basically the same device. So if you need cooling, it is best to locate the condensing unit outside (a normal split system air conditioner), so it isn't rejecting the heat into the room.
I conclude its still worth it since the dryer air will feel cooler and will actually cool more efficiently in the central AC.
This is unlikely. Yes, it's probably more efficient than an AC unit in a certain way of measuring (heat movement at the coils), but the heat rejection into the room means you need another way to cool the room otherwise the overall feel will be hotter. In other words, the cycle itself is more efficient if you use the same equations, but the math doesn't "know" the heat is being rejected into the room. If you instead measure efficiency based on heat movement for the room, the efficiency of the dehumidifier is negative. It's heating the room instead of cooling it, and it is unlikely to even "feel" cooler for being dehumidified.
 
  • #18
I have a '1 hose' unit that I use during Hurricane power outages (my generator will carry it). One of the 'sneaky' problems with these units is that the latent heat (moisture) of the air that is drawn into the room to make up for the air used to expel the heat/condensate is typically high. Condensing water 'uses up' a whole lot of what would (otherwise) be cooling capacity. As a result, BTU comparisons between Conventional AC systems and '1-hose' units are not apples-apples.
 
  • Like
Likes russ_watters
  • #19
russ_watters said:
You are correct - an AC unit and dehumidifier are basically the same device. So if you need cooling, it is best to locate the condensing unit outside (a normal split system air conditioner), so it isn't rejecting the heat into the room.

This is unlikely. Yes, it's probably more efficient than an AC unit in a certain way of measuring (heat movement at the coils), but the heat rejection into the room means you need another way to cool the room otherwise the overall feel will be hotter. In other words, the cycle itself is more efficient if you use the same equations, but the math doesn't "know" the heat is being rejected into the room. If you instead measure efficiency based on heat movement for the room, the efficiency of the dehumidifier is negative. It's heating the room instead of cooling it, and it is unlikely to even "feel" cooler for being dehumidified.
Buying the dehumidifier was an experiment. I can see good uses for it such as removing a large amount of humidity in a basement to prevent mold and not caring too much about temperature since it tends to be cool in basements anyway.

My goal was to have dry cool air in the house without having to have the central AC on all the time to dehumidify. I figured it would be easier and cheaper to cool the house with central air if the air was dry even if I had to run it a little bit more to make up for the extra rejected heat. It took about 3 gallons of water out of the air in 24 hours. I doubt that would go on forever once things even out.

Alternatively, I could buy a supplemental window AC unit which would help dehumidify the house air while cooling it somewhat without rejecting the heat inside. Maybe I should have just done that instead?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes russ_watters

1. What is a one-hose air-conditioner?

A one-hose air-conditioner is a type of portable air-conditioner that uses only one hose to expel hot air from the room and bring in fresh air from the outside to cool the room.

2. How does a one-hose air-conditioner work?

A one-hose air-conditioner works by taking in hot air from the room through the intake hose, cooling it down using a refrigerant, and then releasing the cooled air back into the room. The hot air is then expelled through the exhaust hose to the outside.

3. What are the advantages of a one-hose air-conditioner?

One of the main advantages of a one-hose air-conditioner is its portability. It can easily be moved from room to room and does not require any permanent installation. It is also more energy efficient compared to traditional window air-conditioners, as it only cools the room it is in rather than the entire house.

4. Are there any disadvantages to using a one-hose air-conditioner?

One of the main disadvantages of a one-hose air-conditioner is that it may not be as effective in cooling larger rooms or spaces. It also requires a constant supply of fresh air from the outside, which can be a problem in highly polluted areas. Additionally, the single hose design may result in the unit working harder and using more energy to cool the room.

5. Can a one-hose air-conditioner be used in any room?

While a one-hose air-conditioner can be used in most rooms, it is best suited for smaller spaces. It may struggle to cool larger rooms or those with high ceilings. It is also important to ensure that the intake and exhaust hoses are properly sealed to prevent hot air from entering the room and impacting the cooling efficiency.

Similar threads

  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
473
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • DIY Projects
2
Replies
36
Views
7K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
3
Views
7K
Replies
152
Views
4K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Thermodynamics
Replies
4
Views
5K
  • General Engineering
Replies
1
Views
6K
Back
Top