Are there upper and lower limits to the inverse square law?

In summary, Carlo Rovelli believes that space must have a minimum dimension, and posits that atoms of space must exist. This is necessary to prevent infinities from arising during normalizations from quantum physics to classical physics. However, the inverse square law is not really broken because distance in curved space is altered.
  • #1
KurtLudwig
Gold Member
144
31
TL;DR Summary
Does the inverse square law hold for luminosity distance at very, very large distances?
Does the inverse square law hold for gravity at very, very small distances?
Quoting from Modern Cosmology by Andrew Liddle on pages 130 and 131: "Let me stress right away that the luminosity distance is not the actual distance to the object, because in the real Universe the inverse square law does not hold. It is broken because the geometry of the Universe need not be flat, and because the Universe is expanding."
In the book "Reality is not what it seems", in the chapter on "Quanta of Space", Carlo Rovelli, states that space must have a minimum dimension and posits that atoms of space must exist. This is part of the proposed Loop Quantum Gravity theory. In the book, it is explained that this assumption is necessary to prevent infinities from arising during normalizations from quantum physics to classical physics.
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
  • #2
"Very very small distance" depends on what you mean. Quantum effects are not relevant if you are talking about an astronomy observation of some object. A cosmic ray hitting your retina might be close enough. Should not matter because a single event is not an astronomy observation. Everything beyond the lens of your eye is definitely far enough away for distance squared to be observed as expected.

I am skeptical about the idea that expansion of the universe effects the inverse square law. The light is still spreading out over an area as it travels. It's intensity decreases with square of distance traveled because the area illuminated is a surface. If space is expanding the light from an event will be spread out over the new larger surface area.
 
  • Like
Likes russ_watters and KurtLudwig
  • #3
Have you ever seen a fun house mirror. The image of a light in that mirror might be spread over a large area, or it might be concentrated in a bright spot. In that respect, a curved mirror appears to break the inverse square law.

1577916274851.png


Curved space can also distort images, and appear to break the inverse square law. But the law is not really broken because what we mean by distance must be altered in curved space, so distance squared must also be different.
 
  • Like
Likes KurtLudwig and stefan r
  • #4
Expansion causes any light emitted over interval ##dt_e## to be received over a longer interval: ##dt_0=(1+z)dt_e##, since the emitter is receding as it is emitting;
AND
the received light has its frequency reduced by a factor of (1+z), i.e. the regular cosmological redshift effect.
So any time we measure bolometric flux from a standard candle source, the received flux is reduced not only by the inverse square law, but by and additional factor of ##(1+z)^{-2}##:
$$F=\frac{L}{4\pi S_k(r)^2 (1+z)^2}$$
where ##S_k(r) is the curvature dependent part of the FLRW metric, and which for a flat universe is just the comoving distance (r) while being a function of r and the radius of curvature in the other two cases.
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Likes KurtLudwig and anorlunda
  • #5
Thanks for your explanations.
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman
  • #6
KurtLudwig said:
Does the inverse square law hold for gravity at very, very small distances?
It has been verified down to ~100 micrometers, there is ongoing work to test even smaller distances. If there are small extra dimensions then maybe this can be detected at particle accelerators (probing interactions in the attometer range). Nothing found so far.
 
  • Like
Likes sunrah and anorlunda
  • #7
Thank you for your reply.
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman

Related to Are there upper and lower limits to the inverse square law?

1. What is the inverse square law?

The inverse square law is a principle in physics that states that the intensity of a physical quantity, such as light or gravity, is inversely proportional to the square of the distance from the source.

2. Are there any exceptions to the inverse square law?

There are some cases where the inverse square law does not apply, such as in the presence of strong gravitational fields or in certain quantum phenomena. However, it is a fundamental principle that holds true in many physical systems.

3. What are the upper and lower limits to the inverse square law?

The upper and lower limits to the inverse square law depend on the specific physical system being studied. In general, the law holds true as long as the distance between the source and the object is not too large or too small. However, at extremely small distances, quantum effects may come into play and the law may break down.

4. How is the inverse square law used in scientific research?

The inverse square law is a fundamental principle that is used in many scientific fields, including astronomy, physics, and engineering. It is used to understand and predict the behavior of physical phenomena, such as the intensity of light from distant stars or the gravitational force between two objects.

5. Can the inverse square law be applied to non-physical systems?

While the inverse square law is primarily used in physical systems, it can also be applied to other systems that exhibit similar behavior, such as social networks or economic systems. However, the specific parameters and variables may differ from those in physical systems.

Similar threads

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Mechanics
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
842
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
14
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
18
Views
7K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
2
Views
4K
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
4
Views
2K
Back
Top