Average Speed Of a and b where d and t is not given

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on calculating the average speed of a body that travels half its journey at speed a m/s and the other half at speed b m/s. The average speed is defined as total distance divided by total time, not simply the average of the two speeds. Participants emphasize the importance of using the correct physics definition to avoid errors in calculation. To simplify the problem, one should denote the distance of each leg as d and recognize that the total distance is 2d. The conversation aims to derive an expression for average speed solely in terms of a and b.
rajatbbsr
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
A body covers half its journey with a speed of a m/s and the other half with a speed of b m/s Calculate the average speed of the body during the whole journey
 
Physics news on Phys.org
rajatbbsr said:
A body covers half its journey with a speed of a m/s and the other half with a speed of b m/s Calculate the average speed of the body during the whole journey

What have you tried so far?
 
Curious3141 said:
What have you tried so far?
(d1/t1+d2/t2)/2
 
rajatbbsr said:
(d1/t1+d2/t2)/2

The definition of average speed is

v_{avg} = \frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t} = \frac{\Delta x}{t_1+t_2},

if we let t_1 and t_2 denote the times for the two parts of the trip. You'll lead yourself astray if you try to use shortcuts on calculating average speed.
 
Steely Dan said:
The definition of average speed is

v_{avg} = \frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t} = \frac{\Delta x}{t_1+t_2},

if we let t_1 and t_2 denote the times for the two parts of the trip. You'll lead yourself astray if you try to use shortcuts on calculating average speed.

Can you please explain it to me couldn't get you
 
All I'm saying is that the formula I posted is the definition of average speed, the way it's commonly understood. Sometimes you can also calculate average speeds in physics I by appealing to the notion of "average" that you might already have in your head, like calculating the mean of a set of numbers. But you might get the wrong answer if you do it that way unless you're very careful. So use the physics definition that I posted instead of the algebraic mean definition. And that definition is just the total distance divided by the total amount of time.
 
Steely Dan said:
All I'm saying is that the formula I posted is the definition of average speed, the way it's commonly understood. Sometimes you can also calculate average speeds in physics I by appealing to the notion of "average" that you might already have in your head, like calculating the mean of a set of numbers. But you might get the wrong answer if you do it that way unless you're very careful. So use the physics definition that I posted instead of the algebraic mean definition. And that definition is just the total distance divided by the total amount of time.

hmmm got you isn't the answer is d/(t1+t2) can it be more simplified
 
Yes, it has to be simplified. The goal here is to write the answer only in terms of a and b, since that's the only information you have, in the sense of actual numbers.
 
Steely Dan said:
Yes, it has to be simplified. The goal here is to write the answer only in terms of a and b, since that's the only information you have, in the sense of actual numbers.

Can you please simplify it
 
  • #10
That part is up to you :-)

But as a hint, start by assigning d_1,t_1 to the first part of the journey and d_2,t_2 to the second part of the journey, and d,t to the full journey. And use the one piece of information you have regarding the connection between the two parts of the trip.
 
  • #11
rajatbbsr said:
A body covers half its journey with a speed of a m/s and the other half with a speed of b m/s Calculate the average speed of the body during the whole journey

The definition of average speed = total distance travelled/total time taken.

It's NOT simply the average of the speeds in different legs of the journey.

You've denoted the distance traveled in each leg by d1 and d2. Since you're given that the body covers half its journey in each leg, why not just denote the distance of a single leg by d?

OK, so the total distance is 2d.

Can you now find an expression for the time taken in each half of the journey in terms of its speed and the distance travelled?
 
Back
Top