Basic question regarding electricity

In summary, the conversation discusses the possibility of getting shocked by inserting a metal object into a single prong of an outlet. It is explained that this would only result in a shock if there is a conductive path for the electricity to flow through. The scenario is further explored with different variables such as wearing rubber soled shoes or standing in water. It is clarified that this phenomenon only occurs with AC electricity, not DC.
  • #1
sm8717
2
0
I have a very basic electrical question that I have not been able to discover the answer to.

Most of us have probably seen a scene in a movie/tv show where someone sticks a metal object into a prong of an outlet and gets a severe shock. The example that comes to mind for me is an episode of the tv show House, "97 seconds" where multiple people in the episode get shocked by inserting a metal knife into a single prong of a wall outlet (individually, during separate parts of the episode).

My understanding is that you are only going to get shocked unless current is flowing through you, and in order for that to occur there must be a conductive path for the electricity to flow from one terminal to the other of the source of voltage.

It would make sense to me if someone was shocked by inserting a knife in each hand into each prong of the outlet, thereby completing the circuit through your body, but otherwise I do not see how it is possible.

If it is relevant, you can address the case where the subject is wearing rubber soled shoes, and maybe another where they are barefoot and standing in a puddle of unpure water. (both cases only one knife in one prong of the outlet of course)

Any info is appreciated, thanks!

edit: I assume this has something to do with the path to ground, but I could use some clarification on the feasibility of that as in the scenario I mentioned it seemed like it would be distant enough to not be relevant.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
First of all I am not an expert on this. My understanding is that you would need potential: that is that the electrons need a path to ground. One of the prongs of an outlet is connected to the generating station as a ground and the other prong is connected to the generator output. When these two prongs touch there is potential: electrons can flow.
If you where to touch the prong from the generator output and you where not grounded in any way then nothing would happen. There may be a very small current until your body equalizes electrons from the generator output. Birds can land on power lines and not get harmed because they are not grounded. I have seen crews on TV that work on live power lines from a helicopter. After the crews discharge the potential between the power line and the helicopter they can safely work on the power lines. I don’t think you could get shocked if you inserted a knife in one prong of a wall socket. Like I said I am no expert so please don’t stick something in a wall socket to find out.
 
Last edited:
  • #4
DaleSwanson said:

Thanks, that is very informative. It still leads me to believe that what happened in House was not very plausible given that he was wearing shoes (then again, most things that happen in that show aren't plausible), but at least I have a better understanding now.
 
  • #5
Electricians stick their fingers in light bulb sockets to test for electricity, because if they are not grounded, the electric current is only in their finger. Any small current, even from a 12-volt auto battery, can be deadly if it travels across your torso (if you soak your hands in saltwater beforehand).
 
  • #7
You're confusing two different electrical phenomenon. The situation you present with the knife in an electrical outlet involves AC electricity. Your analysis of the situation indicates you are thinking of the problem as if it were DC hence your confusion.
sm8717 said:
I have a very basic electrical question that I have not been able to discover the answer to.

Most of us have probably seen a scene in a movie/tv show where someone sticks a metal object into a prong of an outlet and gets a severe shock. The example that comes to mind for me is an episode of the tv show House, "97 seconds" where multiple people in the episode get shocked by inserting a metal knife into a single prong of a wall outlet (individually, during separate parts of the episode).

My understanding is that you are only going to get shocked unless current is flowing through you, and in order for that to occur there must be a conductive path for the electricity to flow from one terminal to the other of the source of voltage.

It would make sense to me if someone was shocked by inserting a knife in each hand into each prong of the outlet, thereby completing the circuit through your body, but otherwise I do not see how it is possible.

If it is relevant, you can address the case where the subject is wearing rubber soled shoes, and maybe another where they are barefoot and standing in a puddle of unpure water. (both cases only one knife in one prong of the outlet of course)

Any info is appreciated, thanks!

edit: I assume this has something to do with the path to ground, but I could use some clarification on the feasibility of that as in the scenario I mentioned it seemed like it would be distant enough to not be relevant.
 

Related to Basic question regarding electricity

1. What is electricity?

Electricity is the flow of tiny particles called electrons, typically through a conductive material. It is a form of energy that powers many modern technologies.

2. How is electricity generated?

Electricity can be generated in a variety of ways, including burning fossil fuels, harnessing the power of moving water or wind, or converting sunlight into energy through solar panels.

3. What is the difference between AC and DC electricity?

AC (alternating current) electricity changes direction periodically, while DC (direct current) electricity flows in one direction. Most household outlets provide AC electricity, while batteries provide DC electricity.

4. What is the unit of measurement for electricity?

The unit of measurement for electricity is the ampere (A), which measures the flow of electric current, and the volt (V), which measures the force or pressure of the electricity. Other common units include watts (W) and ohms (Ω).

5. How is electricity used in everyday life?

Electricity is used in a wide range of everyday applications, including lighting, heating and cooling systems, electronic devices, transportation, and industrial processes. It has greatly improved our quality of life and is essential for modern society.

Similar threads

  • Electromagnetism
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
19
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
980
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
0
Views
672
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Electromagnetism
3
Replies
74
Views
12K
Replies
13
Views
3K
Replies
11
Views
852
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
5
Views
2K
Back
Top