- #1
- 19,443
- 10,021
Borek said:I like what NdGT said. Whenever there is a problem with finding an answer (and I mean questions that we put considerable amount of effort into solving), I wonder if the problem is not with the flawed question.
At least we should never assume our questions are the right ones. Many times in the history of science answers turned to be completely different to what we expected.
Nye never said meaning of consciousness is not worthy of discussing, he rebutted Tyson's butting in who said that we know nothing about consciousness and maybe there is no such thing as consciousness. Tyson's suggestion that we don't know anything about consciousness because there are books being written on it is like suggesting we didn't know anything about QM in the later half of the last century because Dirac and his ilk were still publishing then.lisab said:But that doesn't mean "meaning of consciousness" is not worthy of discussing - it just means untrained people don't know how to discuss it properly.
Bandersnatch said:Tyson was getting all excited and animated there, while Nye kept making fun of him
Enigman said:Tyson's suggestion that we don't know anything about consciousness because there are books being written on it is like suggesting we didn't know anything about QM in the later half of the last century because Dirac and his ilk were still publishing then.
This interaction between Bill Nye and Neil deGrasse Tyson occurred at the 2015 Isaac Asimov Memorial Debate at the American Museum of Natural History.
The panel was discussing the topic of "The Future of Space Exploration" and the conversation turned to the potential of human colonization of Mars.
When Neil deGrasse Tyson stated that he didn't think humans would ever live on Mars, Bill Nye responded with "The Earth is just too awesome, you know? Why would you want to live anywhere else?"
Neil deGrasse Tyson laughed and jokingly replied "You're just trying to sell Earth t-shirts, that's what you're doing."
The exchange between Bill Nye and Neil deGrasse Tyson was lighthearted and playful, with both scientists using humor to make their points about the future of space exploration. It was a friendly and amicable exchange between colleagues.