Calculating Thevenin Equivalent Voltage for a Complex Network

5 replies · 3K views · last reply
magnifik
Messages
350
Reaction score
0
I need help finding the thevenin equivalent voltage for the following network:
Circuit schematic with a voltage source V_i and 1 Ω resistor on the left, a 1 Ω resistor with dependent source aV_i in the middle, a dependent source bI_i and 1 Ω resistor on top, and load R_L on the right.


i did source transformations so that i could analyze it using the node voltage method.
TinyPic logo with the message: This image or video has been moved or deleted.

my equations are:
I1 = v1
(a) vx + vx - vT = v1 + av1 - bv1
2vx - vT = v1 + av1 - bv1
(b) vT - vx + vT = bv1
2vT - vx = bv1

when i simplify (by substituting vx), i get
vT = v1/3(a + b + 1)

however, the answer should be
vT = v1/2(a + b + 1 - ab)

help please! thanks.
 
Last edited:
magnifik said:
I need help finding the thevenin equivalent voltage for the following network:
Circuit schematic with a voltage source V_i and series 1 Ω resistor carrying current I_1 on the left, a 1 Ω resistor with dependent voltage source aV_i in the middle, a dependent voltage source bI_1, a series 1 Ω resistor, and load R_L on the right.


i did source transformations so that i could analyze it using the node voltage method.
Tinypie logo above the message: This image or video has been moved or deleted.

my equations are:
I1 = v1
(a) vx + vx - vT = v1 + av1 - bv1
2vx - vT = v1 + av1 - bv1
(b) vT - vx + vT = bv1
2vT - vx = bv1

when i simplify (by substituting vx), i get
vT = v1/3(a + b + 1)

however, the answer should be
vT = v1/2(a + b + 1 - ab)

help please! thanks.

I think I've spotted a problem with how you've redrawn your circuit.

I think it be should more like this,

Circuit schematic with a voltage source v1 on the left, two resistors labeled 1, a dependent current source av1 in the middle, a node Vx, and a dependent source bv1 with a series resistor 1 on top leading to terminals marked + and -.


EDIT: There's really no reason to apply source transformations to the circuit at all, the original circuit can be solve by writing two KVL equations.

[tex]\text{Equation 1:}[/tex]

[tex]Voc = I_{1} + aV_{1} + bI_{1}[/tex]

[tex]\text{Equation 2:}[/tex]

[tex]-V_{1} + 2I_{1} + aV_{1} = 0[/tex]

[tex]\text{Equation 2} \Rightarrow \text{Equation 1}[/tex]

This gives the expected result.

The Latex doesn't seem to be working, but hopefully you can follow through my work.
 
Attachments
  • Circuit schematic with a voltage source v1 and resistors labelled 1 on the left, a dependent current source av1 in the middle, node Vx, and a controlled source bv1 with a series resistor 1 at top right leading to terminals marked + and -.
    72c84j.png
    1.5 KB · Views: 500
Last edited:
can you explain for first KVL equation? I'm not sure where the I1 comes from
 
magnifik said:
can you explain for first KVL equation? I'm not sure where the I1 comes from

Here we are writing a KVL in the righthand loop.

Notice that the loop is open thus there is no current flowing in this loop except for the current in the vertical, leftmost branch.

This current is clearly I1 by writing a KCL at the top node.

Clear?
 
jegues said:
Here we are writing a KVL in the righthand loop.

Notice that the loop is open thus there is no current flowing in this loop except for the current in the vertical, leftmost branch.

This current is clearly I1 by writing a KCL at the top node.

Clear?

yup. thanks.