Calorimetry Lab Analysis (predict specific heat of unknown metal)

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a calorimetry experiment where participants are tasked with determining the specific heat of an unknown metal by measuring the temperature change of water after introducing the heated metal. The original poster expresses uncertainty about their results, which suggest an implausibly high specific heat value compared to known values for metals.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the methodology of the experiment, including the initial and final temperatures of both the metal and water. There are inquiries about the equations used to calculate specific heat and the potential confusion between Celsius and Fahrenheit temperatures. Some participants suggest reviewing the calculations and the assumptions made during the experiment.

Discussion Status

The discussion is ongoing, with participants providing feedback on the equations and calculations presented. There is a recognition of potential errors in temperature units and the need for clarity in the equations used. Some participants have offered guidance on how to express the equations more precisely, while others are exploring the implications of the results.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that the experiment does not involve a calorimeter, which may affect the accuracy of the results. There is also mention of time delays in transferring the metal from boiling water to room temperature water, which could introduce inaccuracies in the measurements.

  • #31
Wubblyboofus said:
do you think i need ideal gas law?

I have no idea, because I don't know what you are doing. Besides, this is not relevant to your question in this thread.

and do you think you can help me with the thing on google sheets?

A what?

Zz.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #32
$$C_{cube}=\frac{(30)(4.184)(26-20)}{(121.5)(100-26)}$$

?
 
  • #33
ZapperZ said:
I have no idea, because I don't know what you are doing. Besides, this is not relevant to your question in this thread.
well it turns out i don't need it as someone else explained to me

and google sheets is the thing that is kinda like microsoft excel that let's you make spreadsheets
 
  • #34
Chestermiller said:
$$C_{cube}=\frac{(30)(4.184)(26-20)}{(121.5)(100-26)}$$

?
0.084
 
  • #35
now we just need to find it for the other two trials, average it, and then find the metal with that specific heat

thank you so much!
 
  • #36
Wubblyboofus said:
0.084
Did I input the correct temperatures here?
 
  • #37
Chestermiller said:
Did I input the correct temperatures here?
yes i think you did
 
  • #38
but i fixed the spreadsheet data and now I am getting 1.1 J/gC
calorimetry is so weird
 
  • #39
Wubblyboofus said:
but i fixed the spreadsheet data and now I am getting 1.1 J/gC
calorimetry is so weird
Let's see your hand calculation.
 
  • #40
4.184*30*76.8/73.3/121.5=1.082
4.184*30*79.3/74/121.5=1.107
4.184*30*75.8/72.8/121.5=1.076

?
 
  • #41
Wubblyboofus said:
4.184*30*76.8/73.3/121.5=1.082
4.184*30*79.3/74/121.5=1.107
4.184*30*75.8/72.8/121.5=1.076

?
is the 76.8 in degrees C or degrees F? Is the 73.3 in degrees C or degrees F? What are the actual initial and final temperatures of cube and water for this case?
 
  • #42
Chestermiller said:
is the 76.8 in degrees C or degrees F? Is the 73.3 in degrees C or degrees F? What are the actual initial and final temperatures of cube and water for this case?
the 76.8 and 73.3 are changes in temperature
 
  • #43
Chestermiller said:
is the 76.8 in degrees C or degrees F? Is the 73.3 in degrees C or degrees F? What are the actual initial and final temperatures of cube and water for this case?
the actual are
trial namemass in gti in Ctf in Cmass water in gti water in Ctf water in Cct in Cct water in Cspecific heat in J/gC
UM1121.599.626.33022.899.673.376.81.082415239
 
  • #44
acronyms
ti initial temperature
tffinal temperature
ggrams
Cdegrees celsius
ctchange in temperature
Jjoules
UMunknown metal trial
LTlead trial
 
  • #45
How can the final temperature of the water be higher than the final temperature of the cube?
 
  • #46
the initial temp of the cube if before i put it into the boiling water
the final temp of the cube is after i put it in the boiling water for a couple minutes
the initial temp of the water is room temp (before i put the boiling cube in)
the final temp of the water is the highest temp the room temp water becomes after putting the cube in
 
  • #47
Wubblyboofus said:
the water ti and tf is how much the room temperature water was heated once the metal (at 212 C) was placed into it. so it goes from about 21 to 26 because the water has high specific heat so it is hard to raise its temperature even if a block of boiling metal is placed into it.
the metal ti and tf however is how much the metal was heated once placed into boiling water. so that would be from 21 to 212.

as i said earlier the procedure went as follows:
put metal into boiling water
metal is now at boiling temperature
put that same metal into room temp water
see how much the room temp water heats
calculate specific heat of metal
use that to identify the metal
You heated the water to 100C not 212C.
 
  • #48
Wubblyboofus said:
the initial temp of the cube if before i put it into the boiling water
the final temp of the cube is after i put it in the boiling water for a couple minutes
Are you aware that this has nothing to do with the measurement you are trying to make? The only reason for putting the cube in the boiling water was to establish its starting temperature for the subsequent measurement.
 
  • #49
tech99 said:
You heated the water to 100C not 212C.
yea i fixed that already
but i can't change the original post for some reason
i changed my spreadsheet though
 
  • #50
Chestermiller said:
Are you aware that this has nothing to do with the measurement you are trying to make? The only reason for putting the cube in the boiling water was to establish its starting temperature for the subsequent measurement.
oh
so would the new one be
water:
21 --> 26
metal:
212 --> 26
 
  • #51
this is due tomorrow dang
 
  • #52
and after i predict this i have to find the percent error of my calculations
 
  • #53
Wubblyboofus said:
oh
so would the new one be
water:
21 --> 26
metal:
212 --> 26
100 —> 26
 
  • #54
Chestermiller said:
100 —> 26
ok let me put it all thru the calculator again ugh
 
  • #55
i really appreciate your guys's help by the way. i probably would have never found my mistakes without you guys
thanks
 

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
5K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
23
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
785
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K