Can Artificial Photosynthesis be a Fossil Fuel Alternative?

AI Thread Summary
Artificial photosynthesis has the potential to replace fossil fuels, but its efficiency remains a concern, with current biological processes like the Calvin cycle achieving only about 6% efficiency. There is skepticism regarding whether artificial photosynthesis can outperform existing solar panel technology, which is also limited in efficiency. C4 crops, such as switchgrass, offer better biofuel options than traditional crops but still produce CO2 emissions when burned. The energy yield from switchgrass is significantly lower than gasoline, suggesting it may be more effective for electricity generation rather than direct combustion in vehicles. Overall, advancements in both artificial photosynthesis and solar panel efficiency are needed to make these alternatives viable.
T.O.E Dream
Messages
219
Reaction score
0
If we can achieve artificial photosynthesis, might it replace fossil fuels once and for all? Can it also be an effective engine in vehicles?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Do you have any suggestions for a new energy source or a new photosynthesis cycle? The Calvin photosynthesis cycle is very complex, and requires ~ 24 photons to make a single C6H12O6 (energy of oxydation ~ 29 eV), but we don't know any more efficient cycle (except C4).
Bob S
 
Is there something wrong with our current solar panels? Is there any reason to think that photosynthesis would be more efficient in converting solar flux to energy?
 
I read somewhere that photosynthesis is very efficient.

Now, I'm seeing sources that say it's very inefficient. Around 6% at maximum.

If that's the case, then I don't see solar panels getting replaced anytime soon...
 
Is there a way to make solar panels more efficient?
 
T.O.E Dream said:
Is there a way to make solar panels more efficient?
Yes lots of ways. if you also want them to be cheap, reliable, long lasting, manufacturable , easy to install and maintain as well then it gets a bit trickier
 
T.O.E Dream said:
If we can achieve artificial photosynthesis, might it replace fossil fuels once and for all? Can it also be an effective engine in vehicles?
I have also calculated ~6% for combustible biofuels such as miscanthus or switchgrass (C4 photosynthesis). C4 crops are more efficient combustion biofuels than Calvin cycle crops, except at higher latitudes. They also release CO2 and other pollutants back into the environment when combusted.
Switchgrass releases about 7500 Btu heat energy per pound when burned. This is equivalent to about 7.9 megajoules per pound, compared to 120 megajoules per gallon for gasoline. So anyone using switchgrass in an automobile with a 20 mpg rating would have to put ~ 1 pound of switchgrass into the firebox per mile while driving. Switchgrass might be better used at a public electricity utility; 1 pound of switchgrass could generate about 0.7 kilowatt-hours of electricity for electric vehicle battery charging.
Bob S
 

Similar threads

Back
Top