Can Prime Numbers x Satisfy x^2 = v^3 + 1?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pandaren
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Primes
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on finding all prime numbers x that satisfy the equation x^2 = v^3 + 1 for some integer v. Participants suggest factoring the right side of the equation into (v + 1)(v^2 - v + 1) and discuss the implications of this factorization. The prime number 2 is identified as a potential solution, leading to further exploration of how to express v in terms of x. Clarifications are made regarding the relationship between the factors of x^2 and the factors derived from the equation. The conversation concludes with a better understanding of the factorization process and its relevance to solving the problem.
Pandaren
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Hey everyone, I need help on this problem:

Find all prime numbers x such that x^2 = v^3 + 1 for some integer v.

Thanks a lot for your help, i appreciated.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Try factoring.
 
After I factored the right side, i got x^2 = (v + 1)(v^2 - v + 1) I don't see what to do next :frown:

Thank you for your help :smile:
 
You've found 2 factors, in terms of v.
Can you find all factors, in terms of x?
 
I don't understand the "all factors of x" part
you mean (x - 1)(x + 1) = v^3 ?
 
The only x that seem to work is x = 2
 
Well, x^2 is the square of the prime, x, right? You know the prime factorization of x^2, so you can write down all of its factors.


Since v+1 is a factor, v+1 must be equal to one of the numbers on that list...
 
Hurkyl said:
Well, x^2 is the square of the prime, x, right? You know the prime factorization of x^2, so you can write down all of its factors.


Since v+1 is a factor, v+1 must be equal to one of the numbers on that list...
you mean if 2 is a prime, then 2 = x, 2^2 = x^2
Then 2^2 = (v + 1)(v^2 - v + 1) Or 2 * 2 = (v + 1)(v^2 - v + 1)
Therefore 2 = v + 1 and 2 = v^2 - v + 1?
 
Last edited:
You know that (v+1)(v^2-v+1) is a factorization of x^2 into two factors, and you know that x * x is a factorization of x^2 into two factors, but you don't know that they're the same factorization.

However, you can write down all of the ways to factor x^2 into two factors, and you know that (v+1)(v^2-v+1) is going to be one of them.
 
  • #10
Ohh I understand now thanks for your help
 
Back
Top