Can We Really See the Past Through Science?

  • Thread starter Thread starter terencesiu
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the concept of seeing the past through science, particularly regarding light and sound. It is clarified that light cannot be slowed down, and even if sound could be slowed in a vacuum, it would not allow for hearing the past. Observing distant planets reveals their past due to the time it takes for light to travel, but this is not applicable to short distances or through artificial means. The conversation emphasizes that current observational tools, like telescopes, are bound by the speed of light, making the idea of a device to see the past impractical. Ultimately, the ability to observe the past is inherently linked to the nature of light and the limitations of our technology.
terencesiu
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
I am watching a movie about a person who can see the future. I have thought a lot of time and I think it is impossible, but how if we see the past? In fact, we can see the relative past of a planet which is far far away, since time is needed for light to pass to our eyes. But can we do that on a very short distance, by decreasing the speed of light/sound/etc? Does it possible? And are there any research about it? thank you.

My English is poor, hope you understand it.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
There is no way to decrease the speed of light.
 
then, how about decrease the speed of sound, by making the medium tends to be vacuum? Can we hear the voice from the past?
 
terencesiu said:
then, how about decrease the speed of sound, by making the medium tends to be vacuum? Can we hear the voice from the past?

Rarefying the medium slows the sound down but not appreciably, not practically.

Note that, even if you could find a way of making a light or sound signal travel slower, it would not allow you to see or listen to the past. It would simply mean any signal you sent after the device was in place would travel slower - which is pretty useless.

For example: email takes a few seconds to get from point to point around the Earth. If you slowed this transit time down to a year, you would not start getting emails from last year. No, it would simply mean that, when people started sending emails today, they would now take a month to arrive.
 
DaveC426913 said:
Rarefying the medium slows the sound down but not appreciably, not practically.

Note that, even if you could find a way of making a light or sound signal travel slower, it would not allow you to see or listen to the past. It would simply mean any signal you sent after the device was in place would travel slower - which is pretty useless.

For example: email takes a few seconds to get from point to point around the Earth. If you slowed this transit time down to a year, you would not start getting emails from last year. No, it would simply mean that, when people started sending emails today, they would now take a month to arrive.

I can mostly understand,
does it means that we can see the past of planets is because the medium "space" is already exists?
but, really thank you!:smile:
 
terencesiu said:
I can mostly understand,
does it means that we can see the past of planets is because the medium "space" is already exists?
but, really thank you!:smile:

No. Light does not need a medium to travel through.

It is kind of academic to talk about seeing the past of a distant planet. Since c is the speed limit on any connection between distant points, it is kind of meaningless to compare a point at our "present" with some point at a distant planet's "present".
 
DaveC426913 said:
No. Light does not need a medium to travel through.

It is kind of academic to talk about seeing the past of a distant planet. Since c is the speed limit on any connection between distant points, it is kind of meaningless to compare a point at our "present" with some point at a distant planet's "present".
:confused: I think I have more and more questions. How does the people can observe the planet? Do they get the picture of the planet instantly, or just get the picture after the device have been set up for a long period? If they can get the message instantly, does it means that we can see the past after the speed slowing device have been operated for a long period? I think it will be funny if it can be made.
 
terencesiu said:
:confused: I think I have more and more questions. How does the people can observe the planet? Do they get the picture of the planet instantly, or just get the picture after the device have been set up for a long period? If they can get the message instantly, does it means that we can see the past after the speed slowing device have been operated for a long period? I think it will be funny if it can be made.

What device? We don't have a device.

Our devices for observing planets are telescopes, which of course are limited to the speed of light.
 
Back
Top