Canceling Magnetic & Electric Fields: An O Level Student's Guide

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ahmed Abdullah
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
To cancel a magnetic field, one can use a magnetic shield made from high permeability materials, which effectively redirects magnetic field lines. For electric fields, enclosing a charge in a Faraday cage, a conductive box, can neutralize the field. While positive and negative charges can cancel each other out, they must be evenly distributed in space to achieve true electrical neutrality. Atoms can be neutral despite having charges due to uneven distribution, as seen in polar molecules like water. Full electron orbitals with opposite spins do not contribute to the atom's magnetic field, as their effects cancel each other out.
Ahmed Abdullah
Messages
203
Reaction score
3
Here is some very fundamental things troubling me. It follows...
How we can cancel
(1) the magnetic field produced by a magnet(so that there will be no magnetic field)
(2)the electric field produced by a charge (so that there will be no electric field)

Does same numbers of positive and negative charges cancel the field of each other in such a way that we have no electric field at all? Sounds silly but atoms are electrically neutral that way. If it is not that way then what is the definition of electrically neutrality? Is it not about having no net electric field?
In the same way, how two electrons in the same orbital having opposite spin cancel out the magnetic field of each other?

please explain in simple and basic terms (m An O level student) .
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Ahmed Abdullah said:
Here is some very fundamental things troubling me. It follows...
How we can cancel
(1) the magnetic field produced by a magnet(so that there will be no magnetic field)
(2)the electric field produced by a charge (so that there will be no electric field)

Does same numbers of positive and negative charges cancel the field of each other in such a way that we have no electric field at all? Sounds silly but atoms are electrically neutral that way. If it is not that way then what is the definition of electrically neutrality? Is it not about having no net electric field?
In the same way, how two electrons in the same orbital having opposite spin cancel out the magnetic field of each other?

please explain in simple and basic terms (m An O level student) .

(1) You can enclose the magnet in a magnetic shield. That is, a closed "box" formed by a high magnetic permeability alloy (as mu-metal) thick enough. How much thick depends on the magnetic flux that the shield has to "short-circuit".

(2) You can enclose the charge in a Faraday cage. That is, a closed conductive box. Any thickness work.

Positive and negative charges do not cancel unless they have the same total value and they have the good distribution in space. One "good" distribution is all positive or negative charge in the center surrounded uniformly by the charge of opposite sign (as an atom).

Some molecules (as water) are electrically neutral as they have as many electrons as protons. But the charges are not distributed in the "good" way, and they produce an electric field.

Full orbitals have each level filled with electrons of opposite spin, which cancel each other. These orbitals do not contribute to the magnetic field of the atom.
 
How does a magnetic shield work (in the simillar way a faraday cage does, I hope!)?
 
No. A magnetic shield is something that "conducts" the magnetic field much better than air, vacuum, etc. Lines of field "prefer" to pass through this material instead of traversing it, make a tour in the other side, and traverse the shield once again. But if you put a sheet of shield between the two poles of a horseshoe magnet, the field lines will happily traverse the shield to go from one pole to the other.
P.S. Do not tell anyone that I used the terms "conduct" and "prefer". It is not very scientific https://www.physicsforums.com/images/icons/icon12.gif
Wink
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thx a lot. :)
 
So I know that electrons are fundamental, there's no 'material' that makes them up, it's like talking about a colour itself rather than a car or a flower. Now protons and neutrons and quarks and whatever other stuff is there fundamentally, I want someone to kind of teach me these, I have a lot of questions that books might not give the answer in the way I understand. Thanks
Back
Top