• Support PF! Buy your school textbooks, materials and every day products Here!

Car accelerating up a hill

  • Thread starter nateb27
  • Start date
1
0

Homework Statement:

Find the time that it takes for a car to reach the top of a hill.
The car can accelerate at 2.93 ft/s^2
The hill's slope = 6.4 %
The final velocity = 203mph
The initial velocity = 0mph

Homework Equations:

d = v^2/ 2a
t = v (f) / a
t = d (remaining) / v (f)
QUESTION:
If all the curves were removed, making a straight line from top to bottom, how quickly could a car reach the top of a mountain?

VARIABLES:
The mountain has a slope of 6.4%
The car's initial velocity is 0.
The car's top speed is 203 mph, (which will also be its final velocity as it crosses the finish line)
This car will accelerate at an average of .091 g (2.93 ft/s2).
The 12.42 mile long mountain course has over 156 turns. (Not sure what to do with this information. It says we remove all the turns, so the course should no longer be 12.42 miles, right?)

GIVEN EQUATIONS:
d=v^2/2a
t=v_f/a
t=d_remaining/v_f

I got that the time is equal to 1 minute and 41 seconds on one attempt, another gave 3 minutes and 7 seconds, and my latest attempt gave 4 minutes and 1 second. If anyone can help me get the answer, I would greatly appreciate it.
 

Answers and Replies

berkeman
Mentor
56,131
6,156
Welcome to the PF, Nate. :smile:

Can you post your work for the 3 methods so we can look for mistakes? That would be the easiest way to try to help you figure it out. Thanks for making such a complete problem statement post, BTW.

You can use the "Attach files" button below the Edit window to upload a PDF or JPEG or similar image of your work. Please be sure the picture is clear, and right-side-up. Thanks.
 
haruspex
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
2018 Award
32,126
4,810
Homework Statement: Find the time that it takes for a car to reach the top of a hill.
The car can accelerate at 2.93 ft/s^2
The hill's slope = 6.4 %
The final velocity = 203mph
The initial velocity = 0mph
Homework Equations: d = v^2/ 2a
t = v (f) / a
t = d (remaining) / v (f)

QUESTION:
If all the curves were removed, making a straight line from top to bottom, how quickly could a car reach the top of a mountain?

VARIABLES:
The mountain has a slope of 6.4%
The car's initial velocity is 0.
The car's top speed is 203 mph, (which will also be its final velocity as it crosses the finish line)
This car will accelerate at an average of .091 g (2.93 ft/s2).
The 12.42 mile long mountain course has over 156 turns. (Not sure what to do with this information. It says we remove all the turns, so the course should no longer be 12.42 miles, right?)

GIVEN EQUATIONS:
d=v^2/2a
t=v_f/a
t=d_remaining/v_f

I got that the time is equal to 1 minute and 41 seconds on one attempt, another gave 3 minutes and 7 seconds, and my latest attempt gave 4 minutes and 1 second. If anyone can help me get the answer, I would greatly appreciate it.
So much in the problem statement is unclear.
Is the quoted max acceleration when going up the straight line (6.4% incline) or on the flat? If the former, the slope information is irrelevant.
Are we supposed to assume the max acceleration is achieved all the way to the finish or only until it reaches max speed?
Why is the 2.93 ft/s2 first given as max acceleration then as "average"? Why not just say it is the acceleration?

Taking the simplest interpretation, constant acceleration to given max speed, I agree with your first answer. But as @berkeman asks, please post your other methods.
 
20
1
"haruspex" The acceleration is "average" going up the incline until Vf 203MPH
 
haruspex
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
2018 Award
32,126
4,810
"haruspex" The acceleration is "average" going up the incline until Vf 203MPH
That doesn't address either of my quibbles.

It is also stated as a maximum ("can accelerate at..."). If the number is both average and maximum over an interval it must be constant.

It is still unclear whether, having accelerated up the max speed, it has reached the top of the hill or continues at that max speed for a way.
 
20
1
That doesn't address either of my quibbles.

It is also stated as a maximum ("can accelerate at..."). If the number is both average and maximum over an interval it must be constant.

It is still unclear whether, having accelerated up the max speed, it has reached the top of the hill or continues at that max speed for a way.
It says the car WILL accelerate at that average speed..203mph is top speed
 
20
1
. Slope of 6.4%
. Car top speed 203 mph
. Car has a peak
acceleration of over I g. Assume
this car will accelerate at an
average of .091 g (2.93 ft/s2)
The 1 2.42 mile long Pike's Peak
course has over 156 turns
 
20
1
QUESTION:
If all the curves were removed, making a straight line from top to bottom, how quickly could a car reach the top of a mountain?
 
20
1
I'm assuming the 6.4% slope has to be factored in in order to get a "true" acceleration...so far ive gotten an angle of 3.66 degrees from that slope. now trying to factor in the "G's" effect from that slope into the given acceleration
 
jbriggs444
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
7,866
2,773
The car's top speed is 203 mph, (which will also be its final velocity as it crosses the finish line)
This car will accelerate at an average of .091 g (2.93 ft/s2).
Since we are given average acceleration and top speed we can compute elapsed time. We can then divide total distance by that elapsed time to get average speed. The resulting average speed exceeds 203 miles per hour.

The problem statement is inconsistent.
 
20
1
still gotta account for the slope and its G force impact on the car
 
berkeman
Mentor
56,131
6,156
@ojorojo -- are you related to the OP account @nateb27 ? Just curious. I got vertigo when the replies to questions meant for the OP started coming from you. :smile:
 
20
1
Lol...I understand. I have the same problem as the OP is trying to solve thats all. But i don't see Nate chipping in so I'm assuming he is just reading the posts..😁
Im not sure if this is the formula i should use to find the true acceleration
a=g*SIN(tetha)...would that be a negative? as in:
a=-9.8m/s2*(3.66)....?thanks you
 
jbriggs444
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
7,866
2,773
a=g*SIN(tetha)...would that be a negative? as in:
a=-9.8m/s2*(3.66)....?thanks you
Not following that. How is ##\sin \theta## going to get as high as 3.66?
 
I have been working on this same question. Can you review the attached for any errors?
 

Attachments

haruspex
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
2018 Award
32,126
4,810
We can then divide total distance by that elapsed time
The given distance is along the real, curvy road, not the fictitious straight line road. It is unclear whether, even with the straight line course, the max acceleration applies all the way to the top of the hill. In the curv d road case presumably it does not: the maintains the given acceleration up to the max speed then continues at that speed.
That said, it makes no sense that the same max acceleration would apply in both scenarios.
 
haruspex
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
2018 Award
32,126
4,810
still gotta account for the slope and its G force impact on the car
As I posted, that is unclear. See post #3. I.e. does the given max acceleration refer to driving on the flat or when driving up this hill?
 
haruspex
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
2018 Award
32,126
4,810
It says the car WILL accelerate at that average speed..203mph is top speed
You mean at that average rate, yes? An acceleration is not a speed. And it says that acceleration is both the average and the max, which can only be true if it is constant.

But this still leaves open the possibility that it reaches the max speed before reaching the top of the hill, then continues at that max speed.
The text in post #1 suggests to me that the acceleration applies all the way to the top, which yields an easy way to find an answer. If that is not the intention, I do not think there is enough information. @nateb27 posted several answers, but we have yet to see how these were obtained.
 
haruspex
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
2018 Award
32,126
4,810
D = 12.42 miles.
That is along the real, curvy road, not the straight line we are being asked to consider.
 
20
1
Looks to me that start (a) to finish (b) are completely uphill and the speed is 0 at (a) to 203mph at (b)...yes 12.42 miles are the total real course mileage including 156 turns...the mileage to be ran its assumed to be shorter
 
haruspex
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
2018 Award
32,126
4,810
Looks to me that start (a) to finish (b) are completely uphill and the speed is 0 at (a) to 203mph at (b)...
Yes, but that does still not specify whether it reaches top speed before the top of the hill. We are told the max (constant) acceleration applies until the max speed is reached, and that the max speed applies at the top, but not whether the acceleration applies to the top.
 
20
1
Screenshot_20191105-135028_Twitter.jpg
Screenshot_20191105-135021_Twitter.jpg
Screenshot_20191105-135035_Twitter.jpg
 
20
1
how can one figure remaining distance on the given 12.42miles if its all turns and curves regardles of how many miles the car has traveled on a straight line?.its the 12.42m just there to mislead people on this calculation?
 
20
1
Unsolvable..?.Why so salty?..can u work with whats presented and not assume anything like oxigen levels and stuff like that but the given the assumed acceleration?
 
20
1
I think u are really misinterpreting the picture.
Pikes Peak its a real race course..and including its 156 turns its actually a total of 12.42m from start to finish. What its asked here is to eliminate the curves..GET OFF THE ACTUAL COURSE and pretend to drive straight through from start to finish..straight line..which at the end of the day it could be 7 to 9 miles total..(im just assuming).
 

Related Threads for: Car accelerating up a hill

  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
45
Views
6K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
744
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
6K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
3K
Top