Engineering Circuit with two voltage source,

Click For Summary
The discussion centers on applying Kirchhoff's Voltage Law (KVL) to a circuit with two voltage sources. The user is confused about the signs of the current terms in their KVL equation, specifically why the book's solution includes +6i while their own calculation yields -6i. Clarification is provided that in circuits with multiple voltage sources, the direction of current flow must be consistently marked, and potential differences should be treated according to their orientation. The user realizes that they misunderstood how to account for the voltage sources' effects on the circuit. Ultimately, the importance of correctly identifying current directions and potential differences in KVL applications is emphasized.
th3plan
Messages
93
Reaction score
0
In the picture u can see there are two voltage sources, I am confused one how to apply KVL to this. the book has this problem worked out and they get -12+4i+2v-4+6i=0 but i don't get this , i get this -12+4i+2v-4v-6i=0 and solutions isn't the same, what is my problem? For some reason there getting +6i and I am getting -6i. WHy does this happen. Can someone please explain clearly, how to solve something like this, and for future circuits ?
 

Attachments

  • my circuit drawn.JPG
    my circuit drawn.JPG
    7.1 KB · Views: 592
Physics news on Phys.org
th3plan said:
In the picture u can see there are two voltage sources, I am confused one how to apply KVL to this. the book has this problem worked out and they get -12+4i+2v-4+6i=0 but i don't get this , i get this -12+4i+2v-4v-6i=0 and solutions isn't the same, what is my problem? For some reason there getting +6i and I am getting -6i. WHy does this happen. Can someone please explain clearly, how to solve something like this, and for future circuits ?

Hi th3plan! :smile:

I can't see the picture yet, but I assume that you've drawn one arrow the wrong way round.

In any circuit problem with more than one loop, you must draw arrows on each straight section (not just one for each loop), and mark each arrow with the (unknown) current, i1, i2 etc.

Then look at every junction on the diagram, and check that KVL I is satisified.​

If you do this for your problem, I'm sure you'll find there's a junction where it isn't. :smile:
 
lets say its going clockwise the current -12+4i+2v-4v-6i=0 , i get this but i don't understand why its wrong the second battery its throwign me off
 
tiny-tim said:
Hi th3plan! :smile:

I can't see the picture yet, but I assume that you've drawn one arrow the wrong way round.

In any circuit problem with more than one loop, you must draw arrows on each straight section (not just one for each loop), and mark each arrow with the (unknown) current, i1, i2 etc.

Then look at every junction on the diagram, and check that KVL I is satisified.​

If you do this for your problem, I'm sure you'll find there's a junction where it isn't. :smile:

Its a 1 loop tim
 
th3plan said:
Its a 1 loop tim

hmm … I suppose I'm just going to have to wait for the diagram … :redface:

I wonder what the 12 is going to be? :smile:
 
I uploaded the circuit again, please explain me why its +6i not -6i, and how do two batteries act on a circuit like this
 

Attachments

  • ef30606591101a0da16bd9c8186edd4c.jpg
    ef30606591101a0da16bd9c8186edd4c.jpg
    5.7 KB · Views: 547
I can't see your second image yet, so assuming it's the same.
I suggest you actually draw current arrows around the loop.
Yes, even though it is a single loop.

Without the rest of the circuit.
If you have two batteries +(12)-+(4)-, how do they act?
 
th3plan said:
In the picture u can see there are two voltage sources, I am confused one how to apply KVL to this. the book has this problem worked out and they get -12+4i+2v-4+6i=0 but i don't get this , i get this -12+4i+2v-4v-6i=0 and solutions isn't the same, what is my problem? For some reason there getting +6i and I am getting -6i. WHy does this happen. Can someone please explain clearly, how to solve something like this, and for future circuits ?
th3plan said:
I uploaded the circuit again, please explain me why its +6i not -6i

Hi th3plan! :smile:

ok, I can see the first picture now.

It shows three voltages sources (two "facing" one way, and one the other way), and two resistors, all in series.

(btw, why couldn't you have said that? :wink:)

The book multiplies the current, i, by the two resistances, 4 and 6, and adds them: 4i + 6i.

You want to subtract them: 4i - 6i. Why??

The resistances themselves are neutral, and the current, i, is flowing the same way, since, as you pointed out earlier, there's only one loop.

(that's why i assumed there were two loops …*it's the only way to get both i and -i)
, and how do two batteries act on a circuit like this

You just treat them like any other potential difference, in any loop in KVL 2 … if the potential differences are "facing" opposite ways, then of course you subtract them. :smile:
 
im dumb, i figured it out heh
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
6K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K