Clapton equation for water ice coexistence

  • Thread starter Thread starter RJWills
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Ice Water
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around deriving the slope dp/dT of the water-ice coexistence line using the Clapeyron equation. The participant initially calculated Δv and dp/dT but expressed uncertainty about incorporating the latent heat of fusion correctly. They questioned whether to use the change in enthalpy as Δu + pΔv or Δv + pΔv. A revised calculation suggested a value of -13.48 atm/K, but concerns about unit consistency and pressure units were raised. The conversation emphasizes the importance of clarity in notation and unit conversion in thermodynamic calculations.
RJWills
Messages
16
Reaction score
0
I meant to put Clapeyron equation, auto correct had other ideas...

Homework Statement



The densities of ice and water are 0.917 g cmE-1 and 1.00 g cmE-1 respectively. The latent heat of fusion of ice is 333 J gE-1. Use this information to derive the slope dp/dT of the water-ice coexistence line in atm/K at 1 atm pressure at 273K

Homework Equations



dp/dT= ΔH/TΔv = (Δv + pΔv)/ TΔv

And of course ρ = m/v

The Attempt at a Solution



V ice = vI, v water = vW
VI=1/0.917 vW=1 ∴ Δv= -0.0905125
∴ dp/dT=2*(-0.0905125)/-273*0.0905125 = 0.007326 atm/K

However I think this is wrong because I've not used the latent heat of fusion. A suspicion is that I may be using the wrong formula, my lecturer didn't have very distinguishable u's and v's... Is the equation for change in enthalpy Δu+pΔv or Δv+pΔv. If the former is true (seems more likely) how do I use the lhf?

Thanks :)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
:smile: Got it! I wish I had been more of a pain in the backside to the lecturer when he was writing down notes. He would never reference what the meaning of the symbols, just write them down.

1st year undergrads, be annoying to lecturers. I sure as hell know I'm going to be annoying next year!
 
Just a quick check of my answer, hope you don't mind:

dp/dT=(ml)/TΔv
= 333/ 273*(-0.0905125) = -13.48 atm/ K

I have assumed that this is for 1g of water.
 
Looks ok except you haven't kept track of your units. So you still have some work to do there.
 
Is it that I've used cm-3 instead of m-3 which I would have to use because of the standard units to calculate pressure?
 
Yes, that's part of the problem. Also, you need to think about your pressure unit.
 
Back
Top