Clarification of electric potential difference

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the confusion surrounding the sign of electric potential difference, particularly why texts often present it as positive despite the possibility of negative values when the final potential is lower than the initial. Participants clarify that while potential difference can indeed be negative, examples typically use positive values for simplicity. The negative sign in equations like ΔV = -εΔd is acknowledged, but its purpose is questioned, with a consensus that direction conventions can influence the sign used in calculations. Additionally, it is noted that the magnitude of potential is what ultimately affects electrical relationships such as current and resistance. Understanding these nuances is essential for grasping the concept of electric potential difference.
keroberous
Messages
15
Reaction score
1
I have some questions regarding the sign of potential difference. For example, given the literal definition as the difference in potential between two locations it should be possible for potential difference to be negative if the final potential is less than the initial, but while reading texts they always use positive values for potential difference, like "a proton moves through a potential difference of (some positive number)".

Or we defined potential difference to be ## \Delta V=-\varepsilon \Delta d ## which rearranges to ## \varepsilon =-\frac {\Delta V} {\Delta d} ## but I'm not sure what purpose the negative serves here because in all of the examples in the text they just use the equation for ## \varepsilon ## without the negative.

This part of potential difference is what I find the most confusing no matter how many times I read about it.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
keroberous said:
they just use the equation for εε \varepsilon without the negative.
Could you quote some reference for this change of sign in action? Is it in more than one text?
 
  • Like
Likes Dale
keroberous said:
it should be possible for potential difference to be negative if the final potential is less than the initial,
Definitely, yes.

keroberous said:
they always use positive values for potential difference, like "a proton moves through a potential difference of (some positive number)".
They just chose positive numbers for their examples. It doesn’t mean negative numbers are not possible

For the rest, a specific reference would be helpful, as @sophiecentaur suggested
 
  • Like
Likes sophiecentaur
Here are two questions and I'm not sure how they are different.

242845

242846


242847

242848
 
For 6 they are ambiguous about the direction so you can assume any direction convention you like. May as well choose the one that makes it positive.

For 8 they are explicit about the direction so you just have to follow the math, which leads to a negative number in this case
 
In 8 the field points along the +ve x axis. Therefore, this is the direction of force on a positive particle. Since the force is in the direction of decreasing potential, E = -dV/dx, ie V falls, as x increases.
 
I think that in most practical situations, it doesn't matter which direction you model the current to run as long as your are consistent with that. Neg to Pos is correct of course but you often see it modeled the other way around. The main thing that matters is the magnitude of the potential as it determines amps, watts and ohms relationships.
 
Back
Top