- #1
Happiness
- 679
- 30
Why are ##<j_1j_2m_1m_2|jm>## and ##<j_2j_1m_2m_1|jm>## negative of each other when ##j_1+j_2-j## is odd as given below?
I would expect ##<j_1j_2m_1m_2|jm>## and ##<j_2j_1m_2m_1|jm>## to always have the same sign since nature doesn't care which particle we label as particle 1 and which as particle 2.
From (6.274), isn't it true that
##|j_1j_2m_1m_2>\,=|j_1m_1>|j_2m_2>\,=|j_2m_2>|j_1m_1>\,=|j_2j_1m_2m_1>##?
And hence
##<j_1j_2m_1m_2|=\,<j_2j_1m_2m_1|##?
And so ##<j_1j_2m_1m_2|jm>## and ##<j_2j_1m_2m_1|jm>## should always have the same sign.
##j## is the general angular momentum quantum number and ##m## is the associated magnetic quantum number.
I would expect ##<j_1j_2m_1m_2|jm>## and ##<j_2j_1m_2m_1|jm>## to always have the same sign since nature doesn't care which particle we label as particle 1 and which as particle 2.
From (6.274), isn't it true that
##|j_1j_2m_1m_2>\,=|j_1m_1>|j_2m_2>\,=|j_2m_2>|j_1m_1>\,=|j_2j_1m_2m_1>##?
And hence
##<j_1j_2m_1m_2|=\,<j_2j_1m_2m_1|##?
And so ##<j_1j_2m_1m_2|jm>## and ##<j_2j_1m_2m_1|jm>## should always have the same sign.
##j## is the general angular momentum quantum number and ##m## is the associated magnetic quantum number.