Complicated Grad School Decision Help

In summary, the person is finishing their undergraduate program and is looking at graduate schools, but is unsure of where to apply due to their GPA, test scores, and research experience. They are interested in nanotechnology and are struggling to find a program that focuses on that specific topic. They are also unsure about the significance of the prestige of a graduate program and whether a more specific nanotech Masters program would be more beneficial than a physics Ph.D.
  • #1
OnlytheEnergy
2
0
After years of diligence, my undergraduate program will be ending after this year. I have yet to decide on any graduate schools to apply to and don't really think it is worth applying to schools I am sure I won't be accepted to. My problems are as follows:
-My GPA is at a 3.23 entering my senior year (too many B's) though I am at a decent private university.
-I am not the best test taker so expect my GRE score to be in about the same percentile (probably a bit lower) than my 29 on the ACT.
-Majoring in Physics, Minoring in Chemistry and Mathematics
-I've done decent research for three summers but have not done any REUs or anything like that.
-My interests in research and future plans are always overlapping Physics and Chemistry. I am becoming very interested in Nanotechnology like piezoelectric nanogenerators and other physics based chemistry topics (or vice versa).

It is here that my problems lie. Firstly, finding a program that will focus on something I am interested in (maybe not a physics or chemistry graduate program, I have read about Nanotechnology Masters degrees but they are few and far between) seems very difficult as I don't really know how to look without going to each university's website and reading what research each of the professors are doing. I need a way to narrow it down without searching the schools based on ranking or location, but instead by searching the research done there... is it possible?
More importantly, without an outstanding GPA, GRE, or Research experience (though I really hope 3 summers of research is nothing to shake a finger at), what kind of chances do I have for getting into grad school. More specifically, is it more realistic to apply to grad schools that aren't ranked in the top 25 or 50 or whatever; By doing so hopefully having better chances of acceptance and a RA or TA job. It is of the utmost importance that, in getting accepted to a school, I have some form of living stipend on top of paid tuition. I know that is a lot to shoot for, but with a less prestigious school as a goal, is it unlikely?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
OnlytheEnergy said:
It is here that my problems lie. Firstly, finding a program that will focus on something I am interested in (maybe not a physics or chemistry graduate program, I have read about Nanotechnology Masters degrees but they are few and far between) seems very difficult as I don't really know how to look without going to each university's website and reading what research each of the professors are doing. I need a way to narrow it down without searching the schools based on ranking or location, but instead by searching the research done there... is it possible?
At this stage of the game you should be reading as much as you can about the fields that interest you. You may not understand everything, but you should be able to make your way through review articles or articles in magzines like Nature or Physics Today. Look at who's publishing the research that you're interested in and look them up to see if they have any graduate positions available.

Too many people seem to worry about the 'presitige' of the program they apply to, when it makes a lot more sense to worry about the type and quality of research coming out of the programs.

There's no way to really make the search for a graduate position that much easier. You have to do some legwork or you essentially end up relying on someone else's opinion of a program.

I'm not sure why you seem to think you need an REU program to have 'research experience.' Three summers of research is the same thing, except you haven't done it through a formal program.

Also, just about all graduate programs support their students through combination of RAs or TAs and stipends.
 
  • #3
I guess I may be underestimating my research done on my campus because our advisers are always pushing REUs for the summer. A lot of people in our physics department have ended up at CalTech, MIT, and University of Chicago physics programs, so I just assumed that going to a "prestigious" school was better even if the research isn't of exactly what you are looking for.

As I make my way through reading abstracts and articles I think may interest me, I have come across some papers that were written out of the authors usual research realm. Is it worth contacting a graduate faculty member if they only have one paper published on the interesting topic if the rest of their research doesn't seem to continue with that topic?

As for Nanotechnology Masters and the like, I read a couple of times today that these are more of a conglomerate Masters program used to focus and train specific topics, whereas a physics masters or something would be far reaching and seems like it wouldn't prepare you quite as well (at the masters level), even for physics related jobs. If I knew I wanted to do research in the field of nanotechnology, wouldn't a more specific Nanotech Masters program be a better option (including later down the road) than a physics Ph.D that leads me to similar Nanotech research or jobs? Or would the Ph.D make me that much more hireable and qualified for those jobs..

To Ph.D, or Not to Ph.D. That is the question...
 

1. What factors should I consider when making a complicated grad school decision?

When making a complicated grad school decision, it is important to consider factors such as the program's reputation, cost and financial aid options, location, faculty and research opportunities, and career prospects after graduation.

2. How do I determine which graduate program is the best fit for me?

To determine which graduate program is the best fit for you, it is important to research and compare the programs' curriculum, faculty, research opportunities, and overall fit with your interests and career goals.

3. Should I prioritize a higher-ranked program over a program that offers better financial aid?

This ultimately depends on your individual priorities and goals. Consider the long-term benefits of a highly ranked program versus the immediate financial burden of a program with better aid options. It may also be worth researching if there are alternative sources of funding available for the higher-ranked program.

4. Is it worth going into debt for a graduate degree?

This depends on the specific program and your career goals. It is important to carefully consider the potential return on investment for a graduate degree and whether the debt will be manageable in the long run. Additionally, research if there are alternative funding options available such as scholarships or assistantships.

5. How should I weigh the benefits of a prestigious program versus a program that aligns more with my interests?

This decision ultimately depends on your personal priorities and career goals. While a prestigious program may hold more weight in certain industries, it is important to also consider if the program aligns with your interests and will provide you with the skills and knowledge needed for your desired career path.

Similar threads

  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
18
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
3
Views
950
Replies
7
Views
834
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
2
Views
938
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
28
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
26
Views
1K
Back
Top