Contradictory FBD's for simple pulley problem

1 reply · 3K views · last reply
mordechai9
Messages
204
Reaction score
0
I have a basic pulley problem which has been troubling me.

Consider the system as shown in the attached picture. We have a massless pulley attached to the ceiling and a mass suspended from one side of the pulley.

If we take the free-body-diagram by 'cutting' where the red box is, we find the tension in the bottom rope is equal to the tension in the top rope. But if we take the free-body-diagram by 'cutting' at the green box, then we find the tension in the top rope is twice the tension in the bottom rope, since the tension in the rope is everywhere the same.

What is going wrong here?
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a pulley hanging from a ceiling with a rope over it, one end of the rope ending in a block below and the other end running down to the floor, with a red box and a green box outlining two cut regions.
    pulley.jpg
    7.3 KB · Views: 487
Nevermind. I just forgot for the red-box FBD you still have to include the weight of the mass, so actually it just says the tension in the top rope is equal to twice mg again. Doh. Too long since I did basic physics.