Is Downwash a Myth in Lift Theory?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Wing 11
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Lift
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the existence of downwash in lift theory, with Doug McLean arguing that it does not exist due to zero integral in mathematical models. However, participants challenge this view, emphasizing the importance of real-world observations over theoretical calculations. They highlight evidence of downwash and question the interpretation of McLean's statements regarding downward air flow. A timestamp from 41:00 to 47:00 is suggested for those interested in this specific part of the lecture. The conversation ultimately reflects a divide between theoretical and practical understandings of lift and downwash.
Wing 11
Messages
2
Reaction score
1


Doug Mclean talk about common lift misconceptions.I agree with most of what he said but he claims that downward air flow "downwash" do not exist because integral is zero.

I don't agree with this statement,leave mathematics and see what happening in real world.
Downwash evidence:


What do you think about that and which lift theory do you support?
 
  • Like
Likes Robert M
Engineering news on Phys.org
Wing 11 said:
but he claims
How about a timestamp given it's a long lecture?
 
A.T. said:
How about a timestamp given it's a long lecture?
41:00 - 47:00 min
 
Wing 11 said:
but he claims that downward air flow "downwash" do not exist
He doesn't say that. He just says that the downward momentum doesn't accumulate in the atmosphere as a whole. The increased reaction from the ground cancels it.
 
  • Like
Likes Robert M
Thread 'Turbocharging carbureted petrol 2 stroke engines'
Hi everyone, online I ve seen some images about 2 stroke carbureted turbo (motorcycle derivation engine). Now.. In the past in this forum some members spoke about turbocharging 2 stroke but not in sufficient detail. The intake and the exhaust are open at the same time and there are no valves like a 4 stroke. But if you search online you can find carbureted 2stroke turbo sled or the Am6 turbo. The question is: Is really possible turbocharge a 2 stroke carburated(NOT EFI)petrol engine and...
I need some assistance with calculating hp requirements for moving a load. - The 4000lb load is resting on ball bearing rails so friction is effectively zero and will be covered by my added power contingencies. Load: 4000lbs Distance to travel: 10 meters. Time to Travel: 7.5 seconds Need to accelerate the load from a stop to a nominal speed then decelerate coming to a stop. My power delivery method will be a gearmotor driving a gear rack. - I suspect the pinion gear to be about 3-4in in...

Similar threads

Back
Top