Coulombic force of repulsion/attraction between ions

  • Thread starter cookiemnstr510510
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Force Ions
In summary: Well, no. FCC stands for "fine-crystal" or "finer-crystal" and is just a classification for a particular crystal structure. CaO has a cubic structure, so the distance between two O2- ions is going to be the same regardless of whether you are calculating the force between two nearest neighbor O2- ions or between two Ca2+ ions.
  • #1

Homework Statement


The ionic radius of the Ca2+ ion is 0.106nm. The ionic radius of the O2- ion is 0.132nm.
a.Calculate the coulomb force of repulsion between nearest neighbor O2- ions in CaO (which has the NaCl-type structure).
b. Calculate the colombia force of repulsion between nearest neighbor Ca2+ ions in CaO (which has the NaCl-type structure).
c. Calculate the coulomb force of attraction between Ca2+ ions and O2- ions in CaO (which has the NaCl-type structure).

Homework Equations


Fc=-k(Z1q1)(Z2q2)/a2
k=constant=9x109Nm2/C2
Z represents the valences of the two ions
a is the interatomic spacing
q is the magnitude of charge of the electron

The Attempt at a Solution


I believe I can do c:
a=0.106nm+0.132nm=0.238nm
Fc= - k(+2 x 1.602x10-19c)(-2 x 1.602x10-19c)/(0.238x10^-9m)2 = 1.63x10-8 N

I have a couple questions:
1. What is the significance of the problem telling us "which has the NaCl-type structure" in each part? Is this just telling us that CaO is bonded ionically?
2. I know that repulsive force(Fr)+attractive force(Fc)=0, therefore Fr=-Fc
So does this mean that I can calculate the attractive force between two nearest neighbor O2- ions, then flip the sign and call it the repulsive force?
3. If this is true then are we saying there is an attractive force between two negatively charged things (O2-'s? I realize within CaO the Ca2+ and O2- have an attractive and repulsive force which equals zero (that is why they are held together within the molecule).

I guess I want to know if the same process can be used for part C on part A and B, and if so why?

Thanks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
cookiemnstr510510 said:
1. What is the significance of the problem telling us "which has the NaCl-type structure" in each part? Is this just telling us that CaO is bonded ionically?
This is necessary to figure out the distance between two like ions. NaCl has a cubic structure. If the crystal structure had been different, then the distance between say two O2- ions would not be the same.

cookiemnstr510510 said:
2. I know that repulsive force(Fr)+attractive force(Fc)=0, therefore Fr=-Fc
So does this mean that I can calculate the attractive force between two nearest neighbor O2- ions, then flip the sign and call it the repulsive force?
Fc is the Coulomb force, which is not necessarily an attractive force. Whether it will be attractive or repulsive depends on the sign of Fc.

cookiemnstr510510 said:
3. If this is true then are we saying there is an attractive force between two negatively charged things (O2-'s? I realize within CaO the Ca2+ and O2- have an attractive and repulsive force which equals zero (that is why they are held together within the molecule).
You have to be careful here, as real bonding is much more complicated than simply calculating attractive and repulsive forces, since it is quantum mechanical in nature.
 
  • Like
Likes cookiemnstr510510
  • #3
DrClaude said:
This is necessary to figure out the distance between two like ions. NaCl has a cubic structure. If the crystal structure had been different, then the distance between say two O2- ions would not be the same.Fc is the Coulomb force, which is not necessarily an attractive force. Whether it will be attractive or repulsive depends on the sign of Fc.You have to be careful here, as real bonding is much more complicated than simply calculating attractive and repulsive forces, since it is quantum mechanical in nature.
thank you! Will respond tomorrow when I have more time to read it over
 
  • #4
Okay, I am gathering from what you are saying is that Fc could either be a coulombic force of attraction or repulsion.
In the case of O2-, a=0.132nm + 0.132nm=0.264nm=0.264x10-9m
Z1=-2, Z2=-2, q=1.602x10-19C
Fc=-(9x109Nm2/C2)((-2)(1.602x10-19C))((-2)(1.602x10-19C))/((0.264x10-9m)2)= -1.33x10-8N would be the repulsive force between two nearest neighbor O2- ions? Not asking to check my math, just wondering if this is the correct method to obtain the answer for the question.
Thanks!
 
  • #5
cookiemnstr510510 said:
Not asking to check my math, just wondering if this is the correct method to obtain the answer for the question.
Well, yes and no. Actually, I'm not sure how to disentangle the two here. The method is correct in that you are using the right formula for ##F_c##, but incorrect in that you are not thinking properly about where the ions are sitting. Making a drawing might help.
 
  • #6
DrClaude said:
Well, yes and no. Actually, I'm not sure how to disentangle the two here. The method is correct in that you are using the right formula for ##F_c##, but incorrect in that you are not thinking properly about where the ions are sitting. Making a drawing might help.
hmm. okay. Does this have to do with the crystal lattice of CaO? If so since it is NaCl type it would also be FCC. In that case I know what FCC unit cells look like. But I am not sure where two nearest neighbor O2-'s would lie. I haven't been taught how an actual compound would arrange itself within a unit cell.
 
  • #7
cookiemnstr510510 said:
hmm. okay. Does this have to do with the crystal lattice of CaO? If so since it is NaCl type it would also be FCC. In that case I know what FCC unit cells look like. But I am not sure where two nearest neighbor O2-'s would lie. I haven't been taught how an actual compound would arrange itself within a unit cell.
Be careful: if you take only one type of ion, then the structure is FCC, but both ions together form a simple cubic structure. The link I gave in post #2 shows a picture of the structure, so you can use this to figure out the distance between two like ions.
 
  • #8
ahhhh okay, this makes much more sense! thank you Dr. Claude
 

1. What is the Coulombic force of repulsion/attraction between ions?

The Coulombic force of repulsion/attraction between ions is a fundamental interaction between charged particles. It is the force that exists between two charged ions due to their electric charges. This force can either be attractive or repulsive, depending on the charges of the ions.

2. How is the Coulombic force of repulsion/attraction between ions calculated?

The Coulombic force between ions can be calculated using the Coulomb's Law. This law states that the force between two point charges is directly proportional to the product of their charges and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them.

3. What factors affect the strength of the Coulombic force between ions?

The strength of the Coulombic force between ions is affected by two main factors: the magnitude of the charges and the distance between the ions. The larger the charges of the ions, the stronger the force will be. The force also decreases as the distance between the ions increases.

4. How does the Coulombic force between ions impact the stability of ionic compounds?

The Coulombic force between ions plays a crucial role in the stability of ionic compounds. The force of attraction between positively and negatively charged ions holds the compound together, making it stable. The stronger the Coulombic force, the more stable the compound will be.

5. Can the Coulombic force between ions be disrupted or overcome?

Yes, the Coulombic force between ions can be disrupted or overcome. This can happen when an external force, such as heat or pressure, is applied to the ions, causing them to move closer or farther away from each other. In some cases, the force can also be disrupted if the ions are in a solution, where they can be surrounded by other ions or molecules that can shield or weaken the Coulombic force.

Suggested for: Coulombic force of repulsion/attraction between ions

Replies
2
Views
815
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
40
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
580
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
690
Replies
2
Views
952
Replies
8
Views
969
Replies
188
Views
6K
Replies
7
Views
976
Back
Top