Crying for help

  • Thread starter dotcom
  • Start date
  • #1
17
0

Homework Statement



A +30uC charge is placed 40cm away from an identical +30uC charge. How much work would be required to move a +0.5uC test charge from a midway between them to a point 10cm clover to either of the charges?

Homework Equations



E=V/d, W=qV, k=8.99*10^9

The Attempt at a Solution



well...

W=qV=(0.5*10^(-6)){(30*10^(-6)k/0.1)-(30*10^(-6)k/0.2)}=1.32

the answer should be 0.45J.....

Please, anyone who understands this question, explain me how to get the answer!!!!!
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
hage567
Homework Helper
1,509
2

W=qV=(0.5*10^(-6)){(30*10^(-6)k/0.1)-(30*10^(-6)k/0.2)}=1.32


There shouldn't be a negative sign there, so that part of your answer is wrong.

I think you need to find the change in potential energy from when the test charge is sitting between the two +30uC charges, to when it is moved 10cm over. That is the work done in moving it. So if you fix the calculation above, you are half done.
 
  • #3
17
0
I tried with
W=qV=(0.5*10^(-6)){(30*10^(-6)k/0.1)(30*10^(-6)k/0.2)}
but the answer was then too big.....

I then assumed that the potential energy is 0 when the test charge is sitting between the two +30uC charges (as it's balanced).
And the energy when it is moved 10cm over is:

force to the left=(0.5*10^(-6))(30*10^(-6))k/0.1^2=13.485
force to the right=(0.5*10^(-6))(30*10^(-6))k/0.3^2=1.498

using E=F/q,
E=(13.485-1.498)/(0.5*10^(-6))=11.987

therefore, W=qEd=0.5*10^(-6)*11.987*0.1=1.198

which is not the right answer....
can anyone suggest me the correct way to go???
 
  • #4
5,428
292
The PE of the test charge sitting between the others is just twice what you'd get if there was only one 20cm away.

After moving, you are 10cm from one charge and 30cm from the other. Find the difference between the initial and final energies.
 
  • #5
17
0
So the initial PE is

net initial force =2*((0.5*10^(-6))(30*10^(-6))k/0.2^2 =6.7425
PE=F/q=6.7425/(0.5*10^(-6))=13485000

W=qEd=(0.5*10^(-6))*13485000*0.2=1.3485


net final force =((0.5*10^(-6))(30*10^(-6))k/0.1^2 +((0.5*10^(-6))(30*10^(-6))k/0.3^2=14.9833
PE=F/q=14.9833/(0.5*10^(-6))=29966666

W=qEd=(0.5*10^(-6))*29966666*0.1=

W required=1.4983-1.3485=0.1498

I still cannot get the right answer......
Where did I fall into a trap???
 
  • #6
5,428
292
Well, you can't be faulted for effort. You're doing it the hard way.
You don't need to calculate the forces, because PE = k.q.q/r.

So,

initial energy=2*((0.5*10^(-6))(30*10^(-6))k/0.2 = ??
final energy=((0.5*10^(-6))(30*10^(-6))k/0.1 +((0.5*10^(-6))(30*10^(-6))k/0.3=??

and

work = final energy - initial energy
 
Last edited:
  • #7
17
0
Oh, I finally got the right answer, following Mr/Ms Mentz114's way! Thank you so much!!!

But...I still can't understand why the energy in both directions are added together for calculating the potential energy. Aren't the charges at right and left end both positive? Then don't they exert equal and opposite force on the test charge in the midway?
 
  • #8
5,428
292
I'm glad to hear it.

Your question is a good one. If we moved the test charge to the left, the big charge on the right is helping us, so we are doing negative work wrt to it. But the big charge on the right opposes us, so we do positive work against it.
There are two terms in the final energy, and if we compare with the two (equal) terms in the initial energy, one as gone up, and the other down.
 

Related Threads on Crying for help

Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
6K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
620
Top