Current Electricity: Why Does Same Current Pass Through Resistors?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around the behavior of electric current in series and parallel resistor configurations, exploring why the same current passes through resistors in series and how resistors affect the potential energy of charges in a circuit. The scope includes conceptual understanding and analogies to clarify these electrical principles.

Discussion Character

  • Conceptual clarification
  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants assert that current remains the same in series resistors because there is only one path for the current to flow, likening it to water flowing through pipes.
  • Others propose that while the current is the same, the voltage across each resistor drops, indicating that resistors do affect the current indirectly by altering the voltage.
  • A participant mentions that if the current were not the same, it would lead to an accumulation of electrons, contradicting the neutrality of the wire.
  • Some participants use a hydraulic analogy to explain that increasing resistance (like a longer or narrower pipe) requires more effort to maintain the same flow, but the flow rate (current) remains constant in series.
  • There is a discussion about the effect of changing resistors on current, with some stating that replacing a resistor with one of different resistance will change the current, depending on the total resistance in the circuit.
  • In parallel arrangements, participants agree that the current through identical resistors will be the same, as they have the same resistance value.
  • One participant explains that resistors decrease the potential of charges by causing collisions that convert kinetic energy to heat, referencing the Drude model.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the principle that current remains the same in series circuits, while there are multiple views on how resistors affect voltage and current. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the nuances of how resistors function in different configurations.

Contextual Notes

Some statements depend on specific conditions, such as the type of current (DC or AC) and the arrangement of resistors (series vs. parallel). The hydraulic analogy, while useful, has limitations and may not capture all aspects of electrical behavior.

FizixFreak
Messages
154
Reaction score
0
why is current always same for series resistances i mean if a current passes through a resistor a then same current will pass through resistor b does the first resistor not reduces current
 
Physics news on Phys.org
FizixFreak said:
why is current always same for series resistances i mean if a current passes through a resistor a then same current will pass through resistor b does the first resistor not reduces current

Current is continuous through a loop conductor (at least for a DC current or an AC current where the loop size is much smaller than a wavelength). Think of it as beeds on a string being pulled/pushed through a pipe...
 
Current is the flow of electrons, voltage tells us something about the force on the electrons.

The flow through the whole series is affected by both resistors all at once. The voltage drops with each resister in series.
 
berkeman said:
Current is continuous through a loop conductor (at least for a DC current or an AC current where the loop size is much smaller than a wavelength). Think of it as beeds on a string being pulled/pushed through a pipe...

i m not quite catching up here can you please elaborate
 
If the current in series combination isn't same everywhere, there'd be accumulation of free electrons at some place and the wire would go on charging up, but the wire must be electrically neutral, and there's no good reason for this not to be true unless in relative motion
 
I think this is a perfectly reasonable query for a beginner to make.

This is where the hydraulic analogy is appropriate (please don't spoil this thread with discussion other failings of this analogy)

Imagine that your series resistors are like pipes, one after the other.

If you keep pumping water into one end it has to come out of the other or burst the pipes. Of course the longer the pipes the harder you have to pump to push the water through.

Resistors are like this, if you push current into one end it has to come out of the other.
Of course the is something which is lost in passing the resistor. This is the voltage. The greater the resistance the greater the voltage loss.
 
FizixFreak said:
why is current always same for series resistances i mean if a current passes through a resistor a then same current will pass through resistor b does the first resistor not reduces current

Yes it does because the voltage across b is now less. Using I=E/R, if the resistance increases (by adding the second resistor), then the current will drop.
 
Studiot said:
I think this is a perfectly reasonable query for a beginner to make.

This is where the hydraulic analogy is appropriate (please don't spoil this thread with discussion other failings of this analogy)

Imagine that your series resistors are like pipes, one after the other.

If you keep pumping water into one end it has to come out of the other or burst the pipes. Of course the longer the pipes the harder you have to pump to push the water through.

Resistors are like this, if you push current into one end it has to come out of the other.
Of course the is something which is lost in passing the resistor. This is the voltage. The greater the resistance the greater the voltage loss.

okay so i think i got it according to the analogy as the water moves through a pipe with a small diameter that pipe will be considered to offer higher resistance but the same amount of water will flow through the pipe just as it will pass through a pipe of larger diameter right?:confused:
 
I deliberately didn't mention the pipe diameter, I said longer.

But yes a smaller diameter pipe offers greater resistance to flow than a larger one so you have to pump harder to push the flow through.

Buckethead had a slightly different interpretation of you post and thinking about it he might have been right.

I though you meant putting one resistor after another (hence my comment about pipes).
This is called a series circuit and since there is only one path available all the current that flows into the first resistor , flows out and into the second one and so on, like water in the pipes.

Alternatively if you meant that you have one resistor connected to a supply (battey etc) and you change it for a different one will you get a different current, the answer is yes. The battery voltage will not change (within reason) but the current depends upon the total resistance seen by the battery.
 
  • #10
Studiot said:
I deliberately didn't mention the pipe diameter, I said longer.

But yes a smaller diameter pipe offers greater resistance to flow than a larger one so you have to pump harder to push the flow through.

Buckethead had a slightly different interpretation of you post and thinking about it he might have been right.

I though you meant putting one resistor after another (hence my comment about pipes).
This is called a series circuit and since there is only one path available all the current that flows into the first resistor , flows out and into the second one and so on, like water in the pipes.

Alternatively if you meant that you have one resistor connected to a supply (battey etc) and you change it for a different one will you get a different current, the answer is yes. The battery voltage will not change (within reason) but the current depends upon the total resistance seen by the battery.

let say i have two resistances in parallel arrangment of the same value now when the circuit is established will the currents through both be the same as the resistances have the same value ?
 
  • #12
russ_watters said:
Yes.

how do the resistors decrease the potential of the charges in a current loop i mean hoe do these resistors work?
 
  • #13
FizixFreak said:
how do the resistors decrease the potential of the charges in a current loop i mean hoe do these resistors work?


The electrons bump into the materials that make up the resistor. Each collision leeches off energy from the electrons and transfers it as a vibration to the resistor's atomic lattice. This vibration is heat. So the resistors convert the kinetic energy of the electrons to heat via collisions. This is known as the Drude model if you would like to look it up.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 38 ·
2
Replies
38
Views
6K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
8K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K