Derivation of Continuity Equation in Cylindrical Coordinates

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on deriving the continuity equation in cylindrical coordinates using the conservation of mass. Participants identify a common mistake in the evaluation of the radial velocity term, emphasizing the importance of accounting for the changing surface area as fluid flows. One user expresses gratitude for assistance in correcting their oversight regarding this fundamental aspect. Another user requests a complete, corrected derivation to better understand the continuity equation for mass transfer in cylindrical coordinates. The conversation highlights the collaborative effort to clarify and resolve the derivation process.
jhuleea
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Help! I am stuck on the following derivation:

Use the conservation of mass to derive the corresponding continuity equation in cylindrical coordinates.


Please take a look at my work in the following attachments. Thanks! =)
 

Attachments

  • part1.jpg
    part1.jpg
    48.5 KB · Views: 4,294
  • part2.jpg
    part2.jpg
    29.2 KB · Views: 9,869
Last edited:
Engineering news on Phys.org
I think it's in the first attachment where you chose to evaluate only \rho v_r[/tex] between r and r+dr and not the entire term. You forgot here to include the r, which comes down to taking into account the changing radial velocity but not the change in surface area the fluid flows through.
 
da_willem,

Thank you thank you thank you! After picking over my work for about a week now, I can't believe I oversaw this rudimentary step!

Your help is greatly appreciated! =)
 
No problem, glad to be of help.
 
"the change in surface area the fluid flows through"

that's the one that had me puzzled for ages, too. once you see it though (or at least once it's pointed out) it seems so obvious.

so thanks from me too:biggrin:
 
Help

Hey, I'm doing the same problem and was wondering if you could possibly post the corrected solution to this problem asap.

Thanks,

James
 
in the outward mass flow rate expression posted above, the r-plane surface area expands moving outwards, so the 1st term should be (r+dr) dtheta dz (rho vr)...etc.

fix that, then combine flow rates and divide by dV = dr dz dtheta and you're A for away
 
just want to be sure, should it be like this below?

dV\frac{d\rho}{dt}=dV\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial t}+d\theta dz{[r \rho u_{r}]}\right|^{r+}_{r-}+dr dz{[\rho u_{\theta}]\right|^{\theta +}_{\theta -}}+rd\theta dr {[\rho u_{z}]\right|^{z+}_{z-}}
 
Can i get the whole of the corrected derivation please .
 
  • #10
i went to know how i can prove the continuity equation of mass transfer in cylindrical coordinates
 
Back
Top