Derivatives with detailed pictures and work help

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around the topic of derivatives, specifically focusing on two problems involving logarithmic differentiation and the application of the chain rule. Participants are attempting to clarify their understanding of the differentiation process and the correct application of logarithmic properties.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants are discussing the differentiation of functions expressed in logarithmic form and exploring the use of the chain rule. There are attempts to rewrite expressions and differentiate both sides of equations. Questions arise regarding the correctness of their logarithmic manipulations and differentiation steps.

Discussion Status

Several participants have provided feedback on each other's attempts, with some guidance offered on how to approach the differentiation. There is an ongoing exploration of different interpretations of the problems, and while some clarity has been achieved, no consensus has been reached on the final answers.

Contextual Notes

Participants are working within the constraints of homework guidelines, which may limit the number of problems discussed at once. There is also a recognition of potential misprints and the importance of clarity in mathematical expressions.

asdfsystema
Messages
87
Reaction score
0
deleted by accident .. ahh
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Speaking only for myself, I would be more inclined to help you on a single problem rather than a half dozen all at once.
 
good idea. i'll change it right now
 
asdfsystema said:
Please take a look and help me out. Simple derivatives that I'm confused with.

Thank you in advance :)

EDIT : Sorry Mark44. you're right. I put on two problems this time if that's okay with you . thank you !
Mark44 said:
Speaking only for myself, I would be more inclined to help you on a single problem rather than a half dozen all at once.

Yup … that was what put me off a few hours ago!

ok, in 1. they want you to write it in the form log[f(x)] = …, and differentiate both sides.

So start with … what is log[f(x)]?

And in 2., try using the chain rule … what do you get? :smile:
 
thank you tim,

Attempt at #1

log[f(x)]= log[ (x^2)(x-3)^9 / (x^2+3)^5 ]
log[f(x)] = log(x^2)(x-3)^9 - log (x^2+3)^5 ?

try#1
log[f(x)]= log(x^2)+log(x-3)^9-log(x^2+3)^5
i'm not sure if it is this ===== 2log(x) + 9log(x-3) - 5log(x^2+3)[/quote]
Yes, log(ab)= b log(a).
Now, differentiate.

try #2
log[f(x)]= log(x^2)+log(x-3)^9-log(x^2+3)^5
or if it is this method ===== 2x/x^2 + 9log(x-3)-5log(x^2+3)
===== 2x/x^2+ 9*1/x-3 - 5* 2x/x^2+3
and 2x/x^2= 2/x, of course: the derivative of 2log x is 2/x.


Are there 2 #2s?
Attempt at #2
f(x)= 5ln(5x+7ln(x)), find f'(x)
5ln(u)*du/dxu= 5x+7ln(x)) du/dx= 5+ 7*1/x ==== 5+7/x

5ln(5x+7ln(x))*5+7/x ?

f'(3)= 5ln(5(3)+7ln(3))*5+7/3 ??
No, the derivative of 5ln(u) is NOT 5 ln(u)*du/dx, it is (5/u)*du/dx.


Thank you very much ^^
 
Last edited by a moderator:
asdfsystema said:
thank you tim,

Attempt at #1

log[f(x)]= log[ (x^2)(x-3)^9 / (x^2+3)^5 ]
log[f(x)] = log(x^2)(x-3)^9 - log (x^2+3)^5 ?

try#1
log[f(x)]= log(x^2)+log(x-3)^9-log(x^2+3)^5
i'm not sure if it is this ===== 2log(x) + 9log(x-3) - 5log(x^2+3)

try #2
log[f(x)]= log(x^2)+log(x-3)^9-log(x^2+3)^5
or if it is this method ===== 2x/x^2 + 9log(x-3)-5log(x^2+3)
===== 2x/x^2+ 9*1/x-3 - 5* 2x/x^2+3

hmm … messy, but mostly correct …

the lines I would pick out to string together for a proper answer are:

log[f(x)]= log[ (x^2)(x-3)^9 / (x^2+3)^5 ]

log[f(x)]= log(x^2)+log(x-3)^9-log(x^2+3)^5

= 2log(x) + 9log(x-3) - 5log(x^2+3)

then you should differentiate both sides (you only did the RHS):

d/dx(log[f(x)]) = 2x/x^2+ 9*1/x-3 - 5* 2x/x^2+3

and then complete that equation, and multiply both sides by … something :wink: … to get an equation with d/dx(f(x)) on the LHS on its own. :smile:
Attempt at #2
f(x)= 5ln(5x+7ln(x)), find f'(x)
5ln(u)*du/dx
u= 5x+7ln(x)) du/dx= 5+ 7*1/x ==== 5+7/x

5ln(5x+7ln(x))*5+7/x ?

f'(3)= 5ln(5(3)+7ln(3))*5+7/3 ??

u= 5x+7ln(x)) du/dx= 5+ 7*1/x ==== 5+7/x is correct,

but the next line is completely wrong … try again! :smile:
 
hey guys,

1.

log[f(x)]= log[ (x^2)(x-3)^9 / (x^2+3)^5 ]

log[f(x)]= log(x^2)+log(x-3)^9-log(x^2+3)^5

= 2log(x) + 9log(x-3) - 5log(x^2+3)

d/dx(log[f(x)]) = 2x/x^2+ 9*1/x-3 - 5* 2x/x^2+3

1/f(x) * f'(x) = 2/x + 9/x-3 -10x/x^2+3

f'(x)= (2/x + 9/x-3 -10x/x^2+3) * (x^2)(x-3)^9/(x^2+5)^5

I got f(x) from the original equation

f'(3)= (2/3+9/0 - 30/12) * (9)(0)^9/(9+5)^5

Um ... is f'(3) = 9 ?



2.
I used d/dx 5ln(u) = 5/u * du/dx

so continuing off from there, 5/5x+7ln(x) * 5+7/x is the answer?

f'(3)= (5/5(3))+7ln(3) * 5+7/3

==== 1/3 + 7.6902 * 7.3333
final answer f'(3) = 56.7287 ?

Thanks , I tried to make it as clear as possible this time haha :)
 
asdfsystema said:
f'(x)= (2/x + 9/x-3 -10x/x^2+3) * (x^2)(x-3)^9/(x^2+5)^5


Much better! :biggrin:

(though you have a misprint at the end … 5 instead of 3 :wink:)

f'(3)= (2/3+9/0 - 30/12) * (9)(0)^9/(9+5)^5

Um ... is f'(3) = 9 ? [/B]

Well, you have 09/0 …

wouldn't it have been better to cancel an (x - 3) before you put x = 3? :rolleyes:
I used d/dx 5ln(u) = 5/u * du/dx

so continuing off from there, 5/5x+7ln(x) * 5+7/x is the answer?

f'(3)= (5/5(3))+7ln(3) * 5+7/3

==== 1/3 + 7.6902 * 7.3333
final answer f'(3) = 56.7287 ?

Thanks , I tried to make it as clear as possible this time haha :)

Yes … much clearer!

But clarity isn't just for the reader's benefit … it's for your benefit also …

so your next aim should be to use brackets more often … in fact, whenever they're needed … you've made at least one mistake because you've misread a non-existent bracket. :redface:
 
thank you , i will do that more often !

1. sorry i made a mistake last time , i meant f'(3) = 0 (the 9 is too close to the 0)

(2/x + 9 - 10x/x^2+3) * ( (x^2)((x-3)^8)/ (x^2+3)^5 =

(2/3 + 9 - 30/12) * ( (9)*(0) / (12)^5 ) = 0 because 9*0 = 0
 
Last edited:

Similar threads

Replies
46
Views
5K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
26
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
16
Views
2K
  • · Replies 27 ·
Replies
27
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
5K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K