Discover Challenging Chemistry Problems: Find Your Next Challenge!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Acut
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Chemistry
AI Thread Summary
The discussion highlights a perceived gap in challenging chemistry problem books compared to those available in math and physics. Participants reference the use of chemistry olympiad questions as a primary source for difficult problems. A specific book from the 1950s, "Problems in Physical Chemistry" by Lars Gunnar Sillén, is mentioned as a valuable resource, although its availability is questioned. There is a comparison made between the creativity of IChO (International Chemistry Olympiad) problems and those in physics, noting that while IChO problems can be challenging, they often rely on specific knowledge rather than creative problem-solving. Participants express a preference for problems that require creativity over rote knowledge, indicating a desire for more innovative chemistry challenges.
Acut
Messages
226
Reaction score
0
There are books with challeging questions in math and in Physics. However, I've never heard of problem books (challeging problem books) in Chemistry. My main source of problems in chemistry are chemistry olympiad questions.

Do you know any challeging chemistry problems book?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
There was a very interesting book with questions that I have used back in eighties during physical chemistry course. It was already old (judging from how these books looked like they were published at least ten years earlier in Poland, and I think it was a translated book, so original must have been even older). As far as I remember most questions (or perhaps even all questions) there were taken from some original publication, so you were given experimental values as determined by original authors and you were asked to calculate whatever they have calculated. Unfortunately, it was almost 30 years ago and I don't remember neither title nor authors. But I will ask.
 
OK, I am almost sure that's the book:

Problems in physical chemistry,
Sillén, Lars Gunnar
New York, Prentice-Hall, 1952
 
Thanks Borek!
I couldn't find it though.:frown:

Does anybody else know any other challenging chemistry book?
 
try IChO problems
 
thrill3rnit3 said:
try IChO problems
Well, IChO and IChO preparatory problems are hard, but I don't find them as creative as Irodov is in Physics. When they're hard, it's usually because they demand a specific fact you don't know or they involve a lot of calculations.
In fact, the tests which select students who will represent my country at IChO are more creative than most IChO problems... they usually demand more creativity than knowledge - just the kind of problems I like.
 
TL;DR Summary: Book after Sakurai Modern Quantum Physics I am doing a comprehensive reading of sakurai and I have solved every problem from chapters I finished on my own, I will finish the book within 2 weeks and I want to delve into qft and other particle physics related topics, not from summaries but comprehensive books, I will start a graduate program related to cern in 3 months, I alreadily knew some qft but now I want to do it, hence do a good book with good problems in it first...
TLDR: is Blennow "Mathematical Methods for Physics and Engineering" a good follow-up to Altland "Mathematics for physicists"? Hello everybody, returning to physics after 30-something years, I felt the need to brush up my maths first. It took me 6 months and I'm currently more than half way through the Altland "Mathematics for physicists" book, covering the math for undergraduate studies at the right level of sophystication, most of which I howewer already knew (being an aerospace engineer)...

Similar threads

Replies
16
Views
4K
Replies
8
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
18
Views
663
Replies
3
Views
18K
Back
Top