Distance/Rate/Time word problem

  • Thread starter Thread starter acen_gr
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Word problem
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a distance, rate, and time problem involving a Cessna 150 aircraft affected by wind. The user attempts to calculate the average wind speed using equations derived from the tailwind and headwind scenarios. They arrive at a wind speed of 57.69 mph, while the textbook states the answer is 30 mph. The community suggests that the user needs to clarify their equations and calculations to identify where the error occurred. The conversation emphasizes the importance of accurately expressing and solving the equations to arrive at the correct answer.
acen_gr
Messages
63
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


A Cessna 150 averages 150 mph in still air. With a tailwind it is able to make a trip in 2 1/3 hours. Because of the headwind, it is only able to make the return trip in 3 1/2 hours. What is the average wind speed?



Homework Equations


(1) If x = wind speed and y = still air speed
∴ resultant speed (tailwind) = x + y
∴ resultant speed (headwind) = x - y

(2) d = rt


The Attempt at a Solution


let x = wind speed
still air speed = 150 mph
tailwind time = 2 1/3 hours
tailwind speed = 150 + x
headwind time = 3/12 hours
headwind speed = 150 - x

I used these as given for the problem, expressed distance in terms of tailwind/headwind time and rates, set distance as constant (equates), solves for x then gets 57.69 as answer.
but in the book, the answer is 30 mph. What is the problem with my solution?

Thanks in advance.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Well, your solution is wrong! And we can tell you what you did wrong because you do not say what you did. Please write out the equations exactly as you used them and how you solved.
 
let x = wind speed
still air speed = 150 mph
tailwind time = 2 1/3 hours
tailwind speed = 150 + x
headwind time = 3 1/2 hours
headwind speed = 150 - x

d = rt

tailwind:
d = (150 + x)(2 1/3)
d = 100 + 2 1/3 x

headwind:
d = (150 - x)(3 1/2)
d = 225 - 3 1/2 x

d = d

100 + 2x/3 = 225 - 3x/2
2x/3 + 3x/2 = 125
4x + 9x = 125(6)
13x = 750
x = 57.69

@HallsOfIvy, sorry..
 
acen_gr said:
let x = wind speed
still air speed = 150 mph
tailwind time = 2 1/3 hours
tailwind speed = 150 + x
headwind time = 3 1/2 hours
headwind speed = 150 - x

d = rt

tailwind:
d = (150 + x)(2 1/3)
d = 100 + 2 1/3 x

headwind:
d = (150 - x)(3 1/2)
d = 225 - 3 1/2 x

d = d

100 + 2x/3 = 225 - 3x/2
2x/3 + 3x/2 = 125
4x + 9x = 125(6)
13x = 750
x = 57.69

Note that 3 1/2=3.5=7/2 and 2 1/3 =7/3.

ehild
 
Back
Top