Electric Generators: Mechanical Engineer Questions

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around electric generators, particularly in the context of wind turbines and their controllers, as well as the comparison between AC and DC generators. Participants explore the functionality of controllers in maintaining output voltage, the distinctions between alternators and generators, and the efficiency and cost implications of using different types of generators for specific applications.

Discussion Character

  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants clarify that the term "generator" can refer to both AC and DC units, with distinctions often made in specific contexts, such as automotive applications.
  • There is a discussion about the role of controllers in wind turbines, which are used to maintain a steady output voltage despite variable wind speeds.
  • One participant proposes a cost comparison between using a DC generator and an AC alternator with a rectifier, questioning which would be more efficient in the long term given the same specifications.
  • Another participant raises questions about the load requirements, distance for power transmission, and the necessary voltage and current specifications for the proposed DC power generation.
  • Concerns are expressed regarding the power capacity needed for effective energy recuperation in electric vehicles, suggesting that typical DC systems may not be suitable for high power applications.
  • A query is posed about the behavior of motors when reversing power supply, specifically whether reversing the power supply to the stator would cause the motor to act as a brake.
  • Some participants express uncertainty about the implications of reversing terminals on generators and motors, leading to further clarification requests.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on the efficiency and cost-effectiveness of AC versus DC generators, as well as the implications of reversing power supply in motors. Multiple competing views remain on these topics.

Contextual Notes

Discussions include various assumptions about load requirements, efficiency, and the specific applications of generators and motors. The conversation reflects a range of technical perspectives without resolving the complexities involved.

bhaazee
Messages
79
Reaction score
0
I am a Mechanical Engineer and have less idea on Generators.

In wind turbines as the generators would be driven at variable speed by the wind, some type of controllers are used to provide a steady output, say, maintaining a constant voltage.

My question is what is the function of this controller? means what it actually does?

Also, in generators (small scale and large scale) which is the most preferred one? AC or DC? and why?

Regards.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
The "generators" used on wind turbines are generally alternators (that produce ac power), not generators (that produce dc power). In small alternators, the rotor is made of permanent magnets, and the power output is the stator. The alternator is multipole (to make it more efficient at low RPM), and multiphase (to make rectification to dc more efficient). The small DIY (up to ~1000 watt) often use axial magnetic field rotors like shown in

http://www.instructables.com/id/DIY-1000-watt-wind-turbine/#

The 3 phase ac output is rectified and converted to a voltage suitable for charging batteries.

The large (1 to 3 MW) public utility units are much more complex multipole asynchronous alternators with dc current excited rotors. The ac stator output (variable frequency) is rectified and then inverted to enable connecting to the grid (fixed frequency).
 
Actually, the term "generator" can be used for AC as well as DC units. The power plants refer to their AC generating units simply as "generators".

It was the automotive industry, I'm pretty sure, that makes the distinction. Early auto units generated DC (commutation), hence they were referred to as generators. Then when the AC units were introduced, the term "generator" would still have been correct, but to distinguish they used "alternator".

For AC units, either "generator" or "alternator" is correct.

Also, induction generators maintain fixed frequency when connected to the grid even when speed varies.

Claude
 
Thanx for the reply guys.

Now assume I need to generate dc power (say 1 KW capacity) from some source.
Case 01: I am using a generator (dc). Therefore, I don't need a rectifier.
Case 02: The other case is I am using an Alternetor (AC). Here I need an rectifier.

In cost means case 01 is advantageous. However, in efficiency means which will be advantageous in long term. Assume that the specification for both Alternator and Generator are the same.

Regards.
 
What is the load for this DC power?
How far you want to send the power?
Do you want high volts/low current, or low V, etc..?
What is the duty cycle/life requirement (how long do you need it)/reliability requirement?
 
the voltage is 48 V.
The current is 1000 W/48 V
The power generated is stored in a battery say at 3 m distance.
The power generation is carried out at a frequency of 20 times/min

Simple example can be a energy recuperation in a Car. The generator life span has to be 10 to 20 years.
 
bhaazee said:
The current is 1000 W/48 V
...
Simple example can be a energy recuperation in a Car. The generator life span has to be 10 to 20 years.

You will need a capacity of at least 10kW to get any useful recovery from a car under electric braking, more likely 50kW would be better.

This is why electric power in vehicles is a few 100 volts, so, for example, a typical electric car might run, say, 300V-400V and 200A. Managing the power at these capacities requires heavy duty IGBT swithing modules, so whether you regard chopping up and re-constituting currents from a DC battery as 'DC' or 'AC', it becomes rather moot.

So, if you are talking electric vehicles then, no, DC makes no sense. You need commutation-free synchronous AC systems to handle that much power.

1000W is just about what your power steering or air-con will take at peak loads. Car traction is an order of magnitude (or two) power difference.
 
Thnx. One more query. consider a normal dc generator at home. If I reverse the terminals, the direction of rotation is reversed.

Now, in a motor with both Stator and Rotor as coil of wire, a rotation is created in clockwise direction. Consider, that stator carries the temporary magnets. Now, if I reverse the power supply to temporary magnets, then the attraction between stator and rotor becomes repulsion. This means, the motor will behave like brakes. Am I right? If yes, is this possible for both AC and DC?
 
bhaazee said:
Thnx. One more query. consider a normal dc generator at home. If I reverse the terminals, the direction of rotation is reversed.

Now, in a motor with both Stator and Rotor as coil of wire, a rotation is created in clockwise direction. Consider, that stator carries the temporary magnets. Now, if I reverse the power supply to temporary magnets, then the attraction between stator and rotor becomes repulsion. This means, the motor will behave like brakes. Am I right? If yes, is this possible for both AC and DC?

Sorry, I am unclear on what you mean. If you reverse the terminals on a generator then you get the 'negative output' of what you had, but that rather depends on where the wires go!

If you are generating a field for a DC rotor by means of an electromagnetic coil, and then you reverse the coil, then, yes, it would brake the rotor until it comes to a stop, then will act as a motor in the opposite direction. I am unclear on this question, it seems clear what would happen. Am I missing something?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 74 ·
3
Replies
74
Views
10K
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 38 ·
2
Replies
38
Views
6K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
5K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
3K