Electron configuration quantum numbers

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around determining the quantum numbers for electrons in a neutral carbon atom in its ground state. The original poster seeks clarification on the electron configuration and the assignment of quantum numbers, specifically for the 1s, 2s, and 2p orbitals.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • The original poster attempts to derive quantum numbers based on the electron configuration of carbon, expressing confusion about filling the 2p orbital and the rules governing electron placement.
  • Some participants suggest a systematic approach to filling orbitals, referencing principles such as Hund's Rule and the Aufbau principle, while others emphasize the importance of understanding the underlying concepts rather than relying on tables.
  • Questions arise regarding the definitions of subshells and the implications of quantum numbers, particularly concerning the values of l and m for different types of orbitals.

Discussion Status

Participants are actively engaging with the original poster's questions, providing guidance on how to approach the problem. There is a mix of interpretations regarding the rules for filling orbitals, and while some clarity is being offered, there is no explicit consensus on the original poster's understanding of the principles involved.

Contextual Notes

The original poster notes that their course focuses on quantum physics and the Schrödinger equation, which may not cover the Aufbau principle or Hund's Rule in detail. This context suggests a potential gap in foundational knowledge that could be influencing their understanding of electron configurations.

Unskilled
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
I need help with this problem :)

Problem: Give the quantum numbers (n, l, ml, ms) for each electron in one neutral carbonatom in ground state.


My solution: I look at a table to get the electron configuration and for a carbonatom i get 1S^2 2s^2 2p^2

For s
n=1, l=0, ml=0, ms=+-1/2
n=2, l=0, ml=0, ms=+-1/2
n=2, l=1, ml=-1,0,1, ms=??
For p
n=2, l=0, ml=0, ms=??
n=2, l=1, ml=-1,0,1, ms=??

My question: From the two first shells from s i get 4 electrons, so i have to get 2 more, but from where do i get those 2? It must be som kind of rule but i can't find any. pls help :)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
you first two lines for the 1s ans 2s shells are correct

since you have [itex]2p^2[/itex] and there are only 2 electrons in the p orbital we fill electrons in the spaces with ascending order of ml value with spin +1/2 electrons first and then -1/2 electrons

that is, only m=-1 and ml=0 are occupied with spin +1/2 electrons
 
Firstly, you definitely shouldn't have to look up the electronic configuration of carbon in a table. For a lanthanide, that's ok. But you need to be able to figure out the electronic configurations of the first four periods by yourself. There's only a few basic rules you need to use (Aufbau principle, Pauli's Exclusion principle, Hund's Rule of Maximum Multiplicity, stability of half and fully filled shells). Maybe you should study your textbook more thoroughly.

As for your question, it will be helpful to work digrammatically. Draw small boxes for each orbital, group them together by subshells and put each shell in its own row. Then start filling up electrons. Carbon has 6 electrons. First 2 go in 1s. Next 2 go in 2s. Next 2 go in 2p, and Hund's rule demands that they occupy two separate 2p orbitals with same spin.

For 1s2, you have (n,l,m,s) = (1,0,0,+1/2) and (1,0,0,-1/2)
For 2s2, (2,0,0,+1/2) and (2,0,0,-1/2)
For 2p2, (2,1,-1,+1/2) and (2,1,0,+1/2)

You are mistaken in your understanding of what s and p mean. They are labels to denote subshells, the value of l. Whatever the shell, s always means l=0 and p always means l=1. After that, m varies from -l to +l. Really, this is all very basic stuff that forms the foundation of chemistry. You really should read your textbook of introductory chemistry more thoroughly.

Molu
 
loom91 said:
Firstly, you definitely shouldn't have to look up the electronic configuration of carbon in a table. For a lanthanide, that's ok. But you need to be able to figure out the electronic configurations of the first four periods by yourself. There's only a few basic rules you need to use (Aufbau principle, Pauli's Exclusion principle, Hund's Rule of Maximum Multiplicity, stability of half and fully filled shells). Maybe you should study your textbook more thoroughly.

As for your question, it will be helpful to work digrammatically. Draw small boxes for each orbital, group them together by subshells and put each shell in its own row. Then start filling up electrons. Carbon has 6 electrons. First 2 go in 1s. Next 2 go in 2s. Next 2 go in 2p, and Hund's rule demands that they occupy two separate 2p orbitals with same spin.

For 1s2, you have (n,l,m,s) = (1,0,0,+1/2) and (1,0,0,-1/2)
For 2s2, (2,0,0,+1/2) and (2,0,0,-1/2)
For 2p2, (2,1,-1,+1/2) and (2,1,0,+1/2)

You are mistaken in your understanding of what s and p mean. They are labels to denote subshells, the value of l. Whatever the shell, s always means l=0 and p always means l=1. After that, m varies from -l to +l. Really, this is all very basic stuff that forms the foundation of chemistry. You really should read your textbook of introductory chemistry more thoroughly.

Molu


Thanks for the help, for this problem i think i understand how it works. But in generall I'm very confused.
The course i have is quantum physics, and my book doesn't say anything about Aufbau principle and hund's rule. We are just studing the Schrödinger equation and from that learning about quantum number and so on.
I read about hund's rule but i don't get it very well. You were talking about s gives l=0 and p gives l=1 does this mean that this continues like this and d gives l=2 and so on? and we must pick m from -1 to 1 or in the d case from -2 to 2? If so it is very good thing to remember. Which rule och princip gives this? is it hund's rule?
 

Similar threads

Replies
55
Views
6K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
1K