Electronegativity difference NaH

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the classification of sodium hydride (NaH) as an ionic compound despite its electronegativity difference being less than 1.7. Participants note that NaH is considered an ionic hydride because it involves hydrogen bonded to highly electropositive metals like alkali metals. There is debate about whether NaH is purely ionic or possesses some covalent character. Some argue that due to the weak metallic bonds in alkali metals, NaH is predominantly ionic, while others suggest that all bonds exhibit some degree of covalent character. The conversation also touches on the challenges of distinguishing between ionic and covalent bonds at the quantum level, emphasizing that practical properties, such as conductivity and brittleness, can help identify NaH as an ionic compound. Overall, the consensus leans towards NaH being ionic with some covalent characteristics.
Radwa Kamal
Messages
12
Reaction score
0
Although the electronegativity difference between sodium and hydrogen in NaH is less than 1.7 , it is ionic bond WHY??
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
Who told you it was ionic?
 
Any alkaline metal hydride is ionic

Ionic hydrides
Ionic or saline hydride, is a hydrogen atom bound to an extremely electropositive metal, generally an alkali metals or alkaline Earth metals.
source:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydride#Ionic_hydrides
 
Do you think it is purely ionic or might it have a bit of covalent character to it?
 
I think it is purely ionic because for metals with weak metallic bond like alkaline metals it's a must to lose its valence electron completely for them they are are rarely found in covalent compounds.
 
Last edited:
Bah, everything's got a bit of a covalent character to it and vice-versa :) Do the actual QM calculations and you won't find nice integers popping up very often..
 
Thanx 4 enrichin me by this info in fact my study is somehow limited because am still in high school I didn't study QM calculations
 
Radwa Kamal said:
Thanx 4 enrichin me by this info in fact my study is somehow limited because am still in high school I didn't study QM calculations

Hi,

This is the same as, I have heard about as, this is what I have studied in my time.

Thanks!
 
Radwa Kamal said:
Thanx 4 enrichin me by this info in fact my study is somehow limited because am still in high school I didn't study QM calculations

With an electronegativity difference of only 1.7 it is likely a very polarized covalent bond or an very covalent ionic bond. Semantics.
 
  • #10
The only way I can tell to distinguish the two cases is on a macroscopic level. Let's face it, on a quantum level there's basically no straightforward way of telling ionic from covalent. (all the atoms are in a lattice and there's electrons everywhere)
So, if you hit a large crystal of NaH with a hammer, would it shatter? if you melt NaH (in an inert atmosphere), will it conduct electricity?
My gut says yes to both, and therefore I would say NaH is ionic.
 
  • #11
Yea its a Ionic Compound ( due to its properties) with more Covalent Character : )
We know nothing is Purely(100%) ionic or covalent : )
 
Back
Top