Elementary Trigonometry problem

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a problem from Israel Gelfand's Trigonometry textbook, specifically Exercise 7, which asks to describe the set of points X satisfying the equation AX^2 + BX^2 = AB^2. The original poster attempted to manipulate the equation but became confused about the notation, mistakenly interpreting AX as A multiplied by X. Clarification was provided that the equation should be interpreted in terms of distances, specifically |AX|^2 + |BX|^2 = |AB|^2, which relates to the geometric configuration of points A, B, and X. Participants emphasized that the problem involves describing curves based on varying values of A and B, highlighting the importance of understanding the geometric context. Overall, the discussion underscores the need for clarity in mathematical notation and interpretation.
GeorgeDirac
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
My problem is from Israel Gelfand's Trigonometry textbook.

Page 9. Exercise 7: Two points, A and B, are given in the plane. Describe the set of points X such that AX^2+BX^2=AB^2.

The attempt at a solution
Since problem asked to describe set of points X such that AX^2+BX^2=AB^2, I tried to solve for X, and got

AX^2+BX^2=AB^2\to<br /> X^2(A+B)=AB^2\to<br /> X^2=\sqrt{\frac{AB^2}{A+B}}

This got me nowhere though, so I would appreciate some hints on how to approach the problem.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Well, X is a set of points ... so ##X=\{\vec X_1,\vec X_2,\cdots\}:\vec X_i=(x_{i1},x_{i2},\cdots ) ; i = 1,2,\cdots##?

Or do you know they mean that ##X \in \mathbb{R}##?

If the second, then the equation you got gives you a set of curves for different A and B.
Treat A and B as axes.
 
I think the OP's problem is "describe the set of points X such that <br /> \overline{AX}^2 + \overline{BX}^2 = \overline{AB}^2&quot;, where \overline{AB} denotes the distance between A and B.
 
pasmith said:
I think the OP's problem is "describe the set of points X such that <br /> \overline{AX}^2 + \overline{BX}^2 = \overline{AB}^2&quot;, where \overline{AB} denotes the distance between A and B.

Yes, that is my problem, I am very stupid, I don't know why I thought that AX meant A*X.
 
I recommend asking Pythagorus.

(and a mind-reading star for pasmith :-) )
 
Ah - "points A B and X" ... <sigh>

More like:
##|AX|^2+|BX|^2=|AB|^2##

##\overline{AB}## would normally denote the line segment between A and B.

... well spotted that individual.
 
GeorgeDirac said:
AX^2+BX^2=AB^2\to<br /> X^2(A+B)=AB^2\to<br /> X^2=\sqrt{\frac{AB^2}{A+B}}

And even if it was A\times X^2, then \displaystyle X^2\ne\sqrt{\frac{AB^2} {A+B}}
 
Back
Top