fluidistic
Gold Member
- 3,928
- 272
Well, they are making the claim that the energy doesn't travel in the wire (and that Poynting vector points radially inward the wire, this part is correct). Veritasium says that the energy flux flows one-way from the battery to the lightbulb when an AC is used. But this is wrong. He also says the energy that flows out of the battery ends up in the load and doesn't come back to the battery, whereas in reality there's an energy flux component that follows the current's direction, so that statement is also wrong. Also, I already wrote earlier that I focused on the claim ''Energy doesn't flow in wires'', which btw is the thumbnail of Veritasium's video. I found this shocking since I thought there was some energy flowing there (that.energy comes from the battery by the way).Baluncore said:You are making a different claim. The web claim is that electrical energy from a generator, that reaches the load, does not travel inside the conductor(s). The web claim does NOT assume the conducting wires of the circuit have no resistance. We know real wires get hot, but that thermal energy does not reach the load as useful electrical energy.
Overall they focus only on the Poynting vector part, missing out an energy flux that goes like the current density.