Energy source for hot place on cloudy / rainy days without wind?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around generating electricity in a hot, cloudy, and rainy environment, specifically for a scenario where daily energy needs are 50Wh. Participants explore various methods and technologies for electricity generation without the option of larger batteries or fuels like petrol.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Experimental/applied

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest using wide spectrum solar cells that can capture infrared and ultraviolet light, although uncertainty exists about the current availability of such technology.
  • Concerns are raised about the efficiency of solar panels on cloudy days, with estimates indicating a potential output reduction to 5-10% of sunny day performance.
  • One participant proposes using larger solar panels to compensate for reduced output on cloudy days, suggesting that a significant increase in panel size may be necessary.
  • Another participant introduces the idea of using Peltier modules and the Seebeck effect, noting that small temperature differences can generate electricity.
  • Discussion includes the potential of thermoelectric systems and thermionic emission as alternative methods for converting heat to electricity, with inquiries about the efficiency and availability of commercial products.
  • Questions arise regarding the stacking of thermoelectric modules to enhance efficiency, with clarification that stacking may not be beneficial for power generation due to challenges in optimizing temperature differences.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the best methods for generating electricity under the specified conditions, with no consensus reached on a single solution. Various technologies and their feasibility are debated, indicating a range of opinions on effectiveness and practicality.

Contextual Notes

Participants note limitations such as the dependency on specific environmental conditions, the variability of cloudy days, and the assumptions made regarding available resources and technologies.

PraAnan
Messages
77
Reaction score
1
Say you're in a place either 15 degrees north or south of the equator where average temperatures are over 25C (77F), a large majority of days are either cloudy or rainy and there isn't any wind.

You need 50Wh a day for your needs and the battery you have happens to have a capacity of 50Wh as well so you need to generate every single day. You can buy things but not a battery with a larger capacity or fuels such as petrol.

How do you generate electricity?
(can either use retail products or late stage experimental technology)

I'm currently thinking of going for some sort of wide spectrum solar cells which are receptive to IR and UV as well a larger portion of the visible spectrum but I have no idea if this technology currently exists in the real world.
Also, how much less electricity will a normal solar cell generate on a cloudy day?


This isn't homework, it's a voluntary problem solving project for us to do that doesn't effect our final grades but does have nice rewards.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
PraAnan said:
Say you're in a place either 15 degrees north or south of the equator where average temperatures are over 25C (77F), a large majority of days are either cloudy or rainy and there isn't any wind.

You need 50Wh a day for your needs and the battery you have happens to have a capacity of 50Wh as well so you need to generate every single day. You can buy things but not a battery with a larger capacity or fuels such as petrol.

How do you generate electricity?
(can either use retail products or late stage experimental technology)

I'm currently thinking of going for some sort of wide spectrum solar cells which are receptive to IR and UV as well a larger portion of the visible spectrum but I have no idea if this technology currently exists in the real world.
Also, how much less electricity will a normal solar cell generate on a cloudy day?


This isn't homework, it's a voluntary problem solving project for us to do that doesn't effect our final grades but does have nice rewards.

It's still schoolwork, so I'll move it to the HH forums.

Is there any running water available? If it is cloudy and rainy, I'd expect there to be running creeks or streams in the area...
 
I'm pretty sure it's 50Wh (180kJ)

@berkeman
I understand, I just thought that I would get more replies in the engineering section of the forum.

Daily water needs are fulfilled by a nearby manual bore-well. No other water sources are mentioned so I guess we have to assume that there isn't any running water.

I did miss one point in my initial post, your own energy can't be used to generate electricity.
 
Solar PV will generate on cloudy days if you have big enough panels. In some cases the output is down to 5-10% of what it is on a sunny day. So short answer is to buy really big panels perhaps 10-20 times bigger.

In the real world it might be cheaper to buy a bigger battery. Depends on how long cloudy days persist and what the implications are for running out of electricity. Is it used to power a refrigerator storing vital medicine or just a reading light?
 
Look into Peltier modules and the Seebeck effect. A single small module can produce about 1.7W with a small temperature difference. See a demo.

Temperature differences can be achieved by solar collector or even by heating water (fire!) on cloudy days.
 
PraAnan said:
Say you're in a place either 15 degrees north or south of the equator where average temperatures are over 25C (77F), a large majority of days are either cloudy or rainy and there isn't any wind.

You need 50Wh a day for your needs and the battery you have happens to have a capacity of 50Wh as well so you need to generate every single day. You can buy things but not a battery with a larger capacity or fuels such as petrol.

How do you generate electricity?
(can either use retail products or late stage experimental technology)

I'm currently thinking of going for some sort of wide spectrum solar cells which are receptive to IR and UV as well a larger portion of the visible spectrum but I have no idea if this technology currently exists in the real world.
Also, how much less electricity will a normal solar cell generate on a cloudy day?


This isn't homework, it's a voluntary problem solving project for us to do that doesn't effect our final grades but does have nice rewards.

Finally... A PV question that matches the parameters in my location...

My 50 watt panel put out an optimal 0.03 watts 40 minutes ago(1 hour and 20 minutes prior to high noon). It is a cloudy day. Though I'm at 45° north, and your cloudy day might not be my cloudy day.

So many variables, so little time...
 
I have done previous research on thermoelectrics and they are a good option.

I came across a new (for me anyway) form of heat to electricity converter in the form of thermionic emission. This seems interesting because from looking around it may be more efficient than thermoelectricity so you'd need less wood for power production.

There seems to be quite a bit written about it but are there any commercial products available?
 
I have a question about thermoelectrics which I've been wondering about.

There seem to be stacked modules when it comes to cooling applications but is it possible to stack modules on top of each other to increase efficiency when generating electricity?

pl88989-peltier_cooler_module_four_stage_stack_tec4_247_series_15x40mm.jpg
 
  • #10
For cooling, modules are stacked because each one produces a limited amount of temperature difference for a given working current. By stacking, these temperature differences can be summed.

For power generation you're applying a temperature difference and obtaining a potential difference and current. You want to maximize the temperature difference (or at least operate the module at its optimum temperature difference). Stacking doesn't help with this, in fact it would make getting each module to its optimum ΔT more difficult.
 

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
35
Views
8K
  • · Replies 27 ·
Replies
27
Views
4K
Replies
34
Views
5K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 24 ·
Replies
24
Views
4K
  • · Replies 152 ·
6
Replies
152
Views
12K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
5K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K