Entropy -- prove it increases for irreversible process

1 reply · 3K views · last reply
jangseok seo
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
hi all,

Entropy rate balance for a control volume: rate of entropy change dS_cv/dt equals sum of Q-dot over T plus sum of m-dot_i s_i minus sum of m-dot_e s_e plus sigma-dot gen, with labels for rate of entropy change, rate of entropy transfer and rate of entropy generation.

this is Entropy Rate Balance for Control Volumes.

in the case of throttling process,


Entropy rate balance for a control volume: 0 = m-dot(s1 - s2) + sigma-dot cv, where m-dot is mass flow rate, s1 and s2 are inlet and outlet specific entropies, and sigma-dot cv is the entropy production rate.
.throttling process is irreversible process, so (S2- S1) must be greater than zero.

what i want to know is to prove that (s2-s1) is greater than zero.

Thank you in advance.
 
Attachments
  • Entropy rate balance for a control volume: dS_CV/dt equals the sum over j of Q_j dot over T_j, plus the sum over i of m_i dot s_i, minus the sum over e of m_e dot s_e, plus sigma_CV dot. Labelled as rate of entropy change, rate of entropy transfer, and rate of entropy generation.
    upload_2015-5-20_2-7-59.png
    10.2 KB · Views: 754
jangseok seo said:
hi all,

View attachment 83647
this is Entropy Rate Balance for Control Volumes.

in the case of throttling process,


View attachment 83652.throttling process is irreversible process, so (S2- S1) must be greater than zero.

what i want to know is to prove that (s2-s1) is greater than zero.

Thank you in advance.
I thought we had already answered this question in the following thread: https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/throttling-process.814170/#post-5112310. Were you dissatisfied with the explanation given in that thread? If so, what was it that you disagree with?

Chet