Explaining the Function of Battery & Ground in an Electric Circuit

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the function of batteries and grounding in electric circuits, particularly in the context of discharge tubes and Van de Graaff generators. Participants explore the movement of electrons, potential difference, and the role of grounding in circuits, seeking clarification on these concepts without reaching definitive conclusions.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants question how a battery functions in a circuit with discharge tubes, particularly regarding electron movement and the concept of potential difference.
  • There is a proposal that a battery pushes electrons from its negative terminal to the positive terminal, creating a potential difference, but the exact mechanism and implications are debated.
  • One participant mentions that grounding the negative terminal sets it to 0 volts, which influences the potential of the positive terminal, but this is challenged by others who argue about the implications of grounding.
  • Concerns are raised about the ability of a battery to induce charge movement over long distances, with references to electromagnetic principles and the limitations of electric fields.
  • Participants express confusion about the physical meaning of potential difference and grounding, with requests for clarification on these concepts in non-mathematical terms.
  • Some participants discuss the operation of cathode ray tubes and the role of heating the cathode to emit electrons, while others seek to understand the specific function of batteries in Van de Graaff generators.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on the explanations of battery function and grounding. Multiple competing views and uncertainties remain regarding the mechanisms of electron movement and the implications of grounding in circuits.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include varying interpretations of potential difference and grounding, as well as unresolved questions about the specific roles of batteries in different types of circuits, such as discharge tubes and Van de Graaff generators.

sudar_dhoni
Messages
90
Reaction score
0
sudar_dhoni said:
see the attachment
please explain the function of battery and ground in the picture
my doubt was that in discharge tubes the 2 plates are connected to some voltage source
let it be battery for instance see the fig in this case between the two plates there is empty space then what does the battery here do
does it send electrons to cathode which deposits on it and the cathde induces +charge on the anode and electrons return back
that is my doubt am i right or wrong
but when i consulted my physics teacher he told me that it can't induce to such long distances , he told that what happens is that electrons in anode are attracted by +terminal of the battery and when they reach the +terminal they repel the electrons in the - terminal which goes to the cathode as a result of repulsion

my main doubt is what is the meaning that battery maintains potential difference i can't understand this term can any1 explain in terms of charge movement (not mathematical)
also i read in
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/HFrame.html
about ground reservoir analogy i can't understand these lines

THE GROUND PROVIDES REFERRENCE VOLTAGE.THE GROUND CAN SUPPLY CHARGE TO CIRCUIT BUT ITS MAIN FUCTION IS TO HOLD THE VOLTAGE OF NEARBY WIRES AT THE VOLTAGE OF EARTH
PLZ ELECTRICAL ENGINEERS PLZ GUIDE ME ALSO I HAVE MANY DOUBTS IN RLC WHICH I WILL ASK IN NEW THREAD
 

Attachments

  • image.png
    image.png
    17.8 KB · Views: 623
  • diode_vacuum_tube.gif
    diode_vacuum_tube.gif
    3.9 KB · Views: 661
  • Gas_Discharge_Tube.jpg
    Gas_Discharge_Tube.jpg
    27.9 KB · Views: 584
Engineering news on Phys.org


sudar_dhoni said:
what is the meaning that battery maintains potential difference
The battery has some chemical reaction that pushes the electrons from the - terminal to the + terminal with a specific amount of energy. This amount of energy per electron is a voltage or in other words a potential difference.
 


DaleSpam said:
The battery has some chemical reaction that pushes the electrons from the - terminal to the + terminal with a specific amount of energy. This amount of energy per electron is a voltage or in other words a potential difference.

i know that but in many books its written the plate is maintained at postitive potential
a battery is connected so that it sets up a potential difference

let it be battery for instance see the fig in this case between the two plates there is empty space then what does the battery here do
does it send electrons to cathode which deposits on it and the cathde induces +charge on the anode and electrons return back
that is my doubt am i right or wrong
but when i consulted my physics teacher he told me that it can't induce to such long distances , he told that what happens is that electrons in anode are attracted by +terminal of the battery and when they reach the +terminal they repel the electrons in the - terminal which goes to the cathode as a result of repulsion

also why is that - terminal of battery is grounded in van de graff
in van de graff current can't flow from battery since it is not open circuit
in many cases circuits will not be complete as in discharge tube vacuum tube.In these cases battery can't supply current then what else it does
if u answer it maintains potential differece please tell me the meaning of it and please explain about my grounding doubt as mentioned in this same quote
 


sudar_dhoni said:
i know that but in many books its written the plate is maintained at postitive potential
That is not exactly correct. If the negative terminal is grounded (0 Volts by definition) then the positive terminal will have a positive potential. But you could just as easily ground the positive terminal in which case the negative terminal would have a negative voltage of the same magnitude as the positive terminal did previously. It really is a potential difference that a battery supplies.
sudar_dhoni said:
let it be battery for instance see the fig
Which figure? You have three figures showing two completely different kinds of devices.
sudar_dhoni said:
when i consulted my physics teacher he told me that it can't induce to such long distances
I don't know what he meant by this. Electromagnetism has no range limitation, although the field of a point charge falls off as 1/r². It gets weaker over distance, but it never stops.
 


That is not exactly correct. If the negative terminal is grounded (0 Volts by definition) then the positive terminal will have a positive potential. But you could just as easily ground the positive terminal in which case the negative terminal would have a negative voltage of the same magnitude as the positive terminal did previously. It really is a potential difference that a battery supplies.

thats what i want to know the meaning behind what u have stated above (physical meaning like previously u told that voltage is energy gained or lost by unit charge)

"The battery has some chemical reaction that pushes the electrons from the - terminal to the + terminal with a specific amount of energy. This amount of energy per electron is a voltage or in other words a potential difference." the electron has higher energy at one site and 0 energy at the other.

like that i also what the meaning of what



Which figure? You have three figures showing two completely different kinds of devices.I don't know what he meant by this. Electromagnetism has no range limitation, although the field of a point charge falls off as 1/r². It gets weaker over distance, but it never stops.
first i was referring to discharge tube
next i wanted u to explain the role of battery in van de graff
 


sudar_dhoni said:
thats what i want to know the meaning behind what u have stated above (physical meaning like previously u told that voltage is energy gained or lost by unit charge)
OK, so basically a battery does work on an electron as it moves it from the + terminal to the - terminal. For example, in a car battery the chemical reactions do 12 eV of work on each electron resulting in a potential energy increase of 12 Joules for every Coulomb of electrons moved from the + to the - terminal. Or 12 Joules/Coulomb is 12 Volts.

The ground is just an arbitrary place that you call 0 Volts. In other words, you set your potential energy at ground equal to 0. This is completely analogous to the fact that if you are working a problem involving gravitational potential energy (mgh) you can set your h=0 point anywhere you want.

sudar_dhoni said:
first i was referring to discharge tube
next i wanted u to explain the role of battery in van de graff
I don't really know anything about van de graff generators, but I will try to answer about cathode ray tubes. Basically, you heat up the cathode until it is so hot that electrons begin to boil off the surface. Then, if you have negatively charged the cathode and positively charged the anode then the electrons will be repeled from the cathode and attracted to the anode by Coulombs law. They will accelerate gaining kinetic energy (measured in eV) equal to the potential difference (measured in V) between the anode and cathode.
 
Last edited:


OK, so basically a battery does work on an electron as it moves it from the + terminal to the - terminal. For example, in a car battery the chemical reactions do 12 eV of work on each electron resulting in a potential energy increase of 12 Joules for every Coulomb of electrons moved from the + to the - terminal. Or 12 Joules/Coulomb is 12 Volts.

The ground is just an arbitrary place that you call 0 Volts. In other words, you set your potential energy at ground equal to 0. This is completely analogous to the fact that if you are working a problem involving gravitational potential energy (mgh) you can set your h=0 point anywhere you want.

i almost 99.9%got it
the one doubt that i have is in electronics the negative terminal is grounded which means according to u negative terminal is 0 volts
the grounding of - terminal is a way of representation of an arbitrary place that you call 0 Volts in this case u connect it with - terminal to show that - terminal is at 0 volts that is the unit charge has no energy at 0 volts
am i right did u get to my point?
 


Yes, that is correct.
 
  • #10


That is this thread and I responded :frown:
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
3K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
3K
  • · Replies 27 ·
Replies
27
Views
6K
Replies
6
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
4K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
7K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 58 ·
2
Replies
58
Views
8K