I Famous 'Aspect Experiment' -- Which Type of Polarizers Were Used?

Click For Summary
The discussion centers on identifying the type of polarizers used in the famous 1982 Aspect experiment. Participants suggest that the polarizers were likely crystal polarizers, with a strong inclination towards calcite, although Nicol prisms are also made from calcite. The experiment's diagrams indicate the polarizers appeared cubical, which rules out Nicol prisms. There is mention of Wollaston's prisms in the theoretical framework, but no definitive material details are provided in the thesis. Efforts are being made to contact researchers for clarification on the specific polarizers used.
d_bar_x
Messages
4
Reaction score
1
TL;DR
Which type of polarizers were used?
Does anyone know exactly which kind of polarizers were used in the famous Aspect experiment from 1982? I've read they were crystal polarizers. Does that mean Calcite, or Nicol, or something else?

[Reference link added by the Mentors:]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aspect's_experiment
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
With the use of two-channel polarizers, we have performed an experiment following much more closely the ideal scheme of Figure 1. Our polarizers were polarizing cubes with dielectric layers transmitting one polarization and reflecting the orthogonal one.††

††A similar experiment, using calcite two channel polarizers, had been considered at the University of Catania
from https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0402001 it is a bit ambiguous, but I would guess calcite too.

Edit: Note that Nicol prisms are made of calcite too, but in Aspect's habilitation, he refers to Wollaston's prisms (unfortunately only in theoretical framework and not the experimental one). In diagrams of the experiments the polarizers look very cubical, definitely not Nicol.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes DrChinese and berkeman
Thanks. I'll try to contact one of those researchers to find out which polarizers.
d_bar_x
 
d_bar_x said:
Thanks. I'll try to contact one of those researchers to find out which polarizers.
d_bar_x
In the thesis (unfortunately in French) there are several details of the polarizers and optical commutators, however no mention of the material.
 
For the quantum state ##|l,m\rangle= |2,0\rangle## the z-component of angular momentum is zero and ##|L^2|=6 \hbar^2##. According to uncertainty it is impossible to determine the values of ##L_x, L_y, L_z## simultaneously. However, we know that ##L_x## and ## L_y##, like ##L_z##, get the values ##(-2,-1,0,1,2) \hbar##. In other words, for the state ##|2,0\rangle## we have ##\vec{L}=(L_x, L_y,0)## with ##L_x## and ## L_y## one of the values ##(-2,-1,0,1,2) \hbar##. But none of these...