Find Hydrophilic Material to Absorb Non-Water Liquid

  • Thread starter Thread starter Metiz
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Material
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around finding a random absorbent material that can absorb a liquid lighter than water while being hydrophilic and not absorbing water itself. Participants highlight the challenges of achieving this due to the conflicting requirements of physical and chemical selectivity. The consensus is that most materials that do not absorb water tend to be hydrophobic. One suggested product, PigMats, is mentioned as an absorbent that captures fuels and oils without absorbing water, though it is noted that these materials are typically hydrophobic. The conversation also touches on the need for specific configurations of absorbent materials and liquids, indicating that while the search is complex, there may be solutions worth exploring. Additionally, a separate inquiry about materials that are electrically non-conductive yet thermally conductive is introduced, but it remains less developed in the discussion.
Metiz
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
hello

does anyone here know of a random absorbant material that can absorb a rondom liquid that is LIGHTER than water and preferbaly hydrophilic but DOES NOT absorb water?

(what kind of material and fluid)

thanks in advance
 
Last edited:
Engineering news on Phys.org
Sounds to me like this is virtually impossible. You normally have two parameters with which to tune absorption/adsorption processes - physical selectivity and chemical selectivity.

Physical selectivity usually involves choosing/making pore sizes in relation to the size of the molecule being absorbed. You've ruled that out because you want to adsorb any general liquid lighter than water.

Chemical selectivity is also ruled out, because the easiest way to not absorb water is if the material is hydrophobic (eg: oil-treated fibrous absorbents). But you want something that it hydrophilic.
 
Last edited:
Maybe he means that the liquid is hydrophilic, unlike oil, which does not mix with water?
 
theCandyman said:
Maybe he means that the liquid is hydrophilic, unlike oil, which does not mix with water?
Hmmm, yes that makes sense. But I draw a blank on that count too.
 
I'm not a chemist, but PigMats are an item we use all the time in test cells. They absorb fuels, oils, etc... but no water. Just a thought.
 
Fred, most fuels and oils (in fact, most every single one I know) is hydrophobic. I'd be really surprised if your pig mat absorbed alcohol.
 
Gokul43201 said:
Fred, most fuels and oils (in fact, most every single one I know) is hydrophobic. I'd be really surprised if your pig mat absorbed alcohol.
I think I'll try a little test on Tuesday. I'll keep you updated.
 
Gokul43201 said:
Sounds to me like this is virtually impossible. You normally have two parameters with which to tune absorption/adsorption processes - physical selectivity and chemical selectivity.

Physical selectivity usually involves choosing/making pore sizes in relation to the size of the molecule being absorbed. You've ruled that out because you want to adsorb any general liquid lighter than water.

Chemical selectivity is also ruled out, because the easiest way to not absorb water is if the material is hydrophobic (eg: oil-treated fibrous absorbents). But you want something that it hydrophilic.


I think you're getting the wrong id. It's not like I'm trying to absorb next to ALL liquids that are lighter than water etc. I just want 1 liquid that works in the "configuration" of my first post (so if liquid A works and I need absorbant material D to let it do what I wan't it to do; what liquid, what material? just a random configuration that works like that)

FredGarvin said:
'm not a chemist, but PigMats are an item we use all the time in test cells. They absorb fuels, oils, etc... but no water. Just a thought.

Could you tell me some more about those PigMats?

By the way, it's not completely necessary for the fluid to be water. Any other fluid that behaves like mentioned above would work to.
 
Last edited:
Metiz said:
Could you tell me some more about those PigMats?
A Pig(R)Mat is generally a polypropylene-fiber bag containing a hydrophobic filler (typically cellulose) and often, a fire retardant.
 
  • #10
Hey Fred, so did you take your PigMat to the bar ?
 
  • #11
thermally conductive electrically ninconductive material

Hi friends
Is there any material which is electrically non-conductive but thermally highly conductive.
 
  • #12
FredGarvin said:
I'm not a chemist, but PigMats are an item we use all the time in test cells. They absorb fuels, oils, etc... but no water. Just a thought.

on the fishing boats, we use what we call 'diapers' or 'oil rags'. They look kind of like big, floppy wafers, and they absorb oil and fuel, but not water.

These look right:

http://www.northerntool.com/images/product/images/1095085_lg.gif
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top