Find Normal and Tangential components of accelaration

Click For Summary
The discussion focuses on finding the normal and tangential components of acceleration for a particle described by the polar equation of motion. Participants express confusion over deriving the necessary components and equations, particularly regarding the relationships between the tangent vector, normal vector, and curvature. Key equations discussed include the definitions of the tangent vector and normal vector, as well as the curvature formula. The conversation highlights the importance of correctly applying derivatives and understanding the distinction between vector and scalar forms. Ultimately, clarity is achieved on the relationships between the vectors and their magnitudes, leading to a better understanding of the problem.
  • #31
I found the answer The question is not about ##\vec{T}## or ##\vec{N}##.We are in wrong way the equation is ##\vec{a}=d^2s/dt^2(\vec{T}+k\vec{N})## here the components is ##d^2s/dt^2## for ##\vec{T}## and ##d^2s/dt^2k## for ##\vec{N}##.

##ds/dt=√(1+(dy/dx)^2)##
##y=(t^2+1)\vec{j}## → ##dy =2t\vec{j}##,
##x=t\vec{i}## →##dx=t\vec{j}##
##ds/dt=√(1+(2t/1)^2)##
##d^2s/dt^2=8t/2√(1+4t^2)=4t/√(1+4t^2)##
Which I checked I found the right answer.I will do the same thing for ##\vec{N}## but there's k. k=magnitude of ##d\vec{T}/ds##. ##d\vec{T}/ds=d\vec{T}/dt/(ds/dt)## ##d\vec{T}/dt=2j## and ##ds/dt=√(1+(2t/1)^2)## so ##d\vec{T}/ds=2j/√(1+(4t^2)## and the magnitude is ##2/√(1+(4t^2)## but the answer is 2/(1+(4t^2)3/2
What I am missing ?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #32
I guess I mixed everything :frown::frown::frown::frown::frown::frown::frown::nb):nb):nb)
 
  • #33
Well I found some mistakes...
First of all avoid writting x,y as vectors when they are not...
It would be correct to write x=t \Rightarrow dx = dt and y=t^2+1 \Rightarrow dy= 2 t dt

Also the reason you don't get the right answer is because in \frac{d \vec{T}}{ds} you didn't take the derivatives of the unit-tangent vector, just a tangent vector...you used \vec{T} = \hat{i} + 2t \hat{j} \Rightarrow |\vec{T}|= \sqrt{1+4t^2} \ne 1...
If you do the derivative with the unit-tangent vector correctly (I did it) you will get the result you ask for.
 
  • Like
Likes RyanH42
  • #34
ChrisVer said:
Well I found some mistakes...
First of all avoid writting x,yx,y as vectors when they are not...
It would be correct to write x=t⇒dx=dtx=t \Rightarrow dx = dt and y=t2+1⇒dy=2tdty=t^2+1 \Rightarrow dy= 2 t dt
Ok,thanks for this

"Also the reason you don't get the right answer is because in \frac{d \vec{T}}{ds} you didn't take the derivatives of the unit-tangent vector, just a tangent vector...you used \vec{T} = \hat{i} + 2t \hat{j} \Rightarrow |\vec{T}|= \sqrt{1+4t^2} \ne 1...
If you do the derivative with the unit-tangent vector correctly (I did it) you will get the result you ask for."
Ok.As you said I did it and I understand.I want to ask one question what's the realtionship between ##\vec{T}## and ##k##and ##\vec{N}##.I thought or see ##d\vec{T}/dt=k\vec{N}## ?
 
  • #35
\frac{d \vec{T}}{ds} = k \vec{N}
 
  • Like
Likes RyanH42
  • #36
I understand it thanks the magnitude will give us k but in the vector form this.This vector calculus is really hard.Thanks again for help.
 

Similar threads

Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
792
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • · Replies 25 ·
Replies
25
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
3K