Find the frictional force acting on a solid cylinder

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
Kaushik
Messages
282
Reaction score
17
Homework Statement
A solid cylinder of mass m is wrapped with an inextensible light string and, is placed on a rough inclined plane as shown in the figure below. The frictional force acting between the cylinder and the inclined plane is?
Relevant Equations
$$T + f_{s} = mg*sin(60)$$
$$r \times T = r \times f_{r}$$
Diagram of a solid cylinder wrapped with a string, resting on a rough incline at 60 degrees, with the string running up to a hatched ceiling support.

This was the answer key provided:

Free-body diagram of a solid cylinder on a 60 degree incline, with tension T and friction f acting up the slope and mg sin60 acting down the slope; below it is the worked equilibrium solution with f = 0.2 mg.

My questions are the following:
  1. if the force required for rotational equilibrium is more than the limiting static friction, then the body will rotate aka slip over the surface. When it slips, the frictional force will be kinetic and not static, right?
  2. If I use ##f = 0.2mg## (as given in the answer key), then ##T = f = 0.2mg## for rotational equilibrium. But we must also maintain translational equilibrium. But, ##T + f = 0.4mg ≠ mgsin(60)##. Isn't this contradicting?
 
  1. I agree. At t=0 you have ##\mu_s mg\cos\theta## but immediately after it is ##\mu_k mg\cos\theta##. I suppose the exercise asks for t = 0
  2. There is no equilibrium, so ##T\ne f##.