Find the height the block rises to after an elastic collision

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the maximum height a block rises to after an elastic collision involving two blocks with magnets that prevent them from touching. The initial kinetic energy and potential energy equations are used to derive the velocity of the first block before the collision. Participants clarify that the kinetic energy of the second block should not be included in the final height calculation since some energy is transferred to it during the collision. There are concerns about the setup of the problem, particularly regarding the conservation of momentum and the forces at play due to the magnets. The conversation emphasizes the need for careful variable notation and the potential flaws in the problem's assumptions.
Neon32
Messages
68
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement



Two blocks are free to slide along a frictionless wooden track ABC as shown below. The block of mass m1 = 5.09 kg is released from A. Protruding from its front end is the north pole of a strong magnet, repelling the north pole of an identical magnet embedded in the back end of the block of mass m2 = 9.50 kg, initially at rest. The two blocks never touch. Calculate the maximum height to which m1 rises after the elastic collision.

Answer in m

figure:
p9-26.gif


Homework Equations


We'll use law of energy conservation: KEi+P.Ei=K.Ef+P.E
+
Vf=(m1-m2/m1+m2)Vi

The Attempt at a Solution


K.Ei+P.Ei=K.Ef+P.Ef
m1gh=1/2 m1 V1i2[/B]
So we get V1i=9.90 m/s.

Substituting in V1f=(m1-m2/m1+m2)Vi, w get:
V1f=-3.3m/s

1)I want to know if what I did above is correct.

2) My second question is

I'll use the law of energy conservation again so we can find the maximum height:
The second body will acquire velocity so there is kinetic energy after collision:

1/2m1 v12+1/2 m2 V22=m1gh(new height)
Is this one correct?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Updated.
 
Neon32 said:
m1gh=1/2 m1 V1i2
Did not get this part.
it is given that ##V_{1i} = 0##.
 
Buffu said:
Did not get this part.
it is given that ##V_{1i} = 0##.

This is velocity of mass 1 right before it collides with body 2.
 
Neon32 said:
Substituting in V1f=(m1-m2/m1+m2)Vi, w get:
V1f=-3.3m/s

1)I want to know if what I did above is correct.
Yes that is correct. (if the calculations are correct).

Neon32 said:
1/2m1 v12+1/2 m2 V22=m1gh(new height)
You did not clarify what v12 and v22 means here so I assume :-
v12 - velocity of m1 after collision.
v22 - velocity of m2 after collision.

You will get the same height this way (because 1/2m1 v12+1/2 m2 V22 = initial energy of the body m1). Which is incorrect since some energy is transferred this way.
You should not consider the kinetic energy of second body in your equation, i.e 1/2 m2 V22 should not come.

Please use subscript and superscript in writing variables, it is hard to understand.
Capture.PNG
 
Buffu said:
Which is incorrect since some energy is transferred this way.
Sorry for this ambiguous statement. I meant to say that some energy is transferred to m2, so height of m1 will be less than initial.
 
The question looks a bit flawed to me. If the magnets are strong enough to prevent collision, m2 will start to move when m1 is still some way short of it. From the diagram, it will still be on the arc. This means momentum will not be conserved, since the normal force has a horizontal component and it will be more than merely enough to support m1.
Glossing over that...
Neon32 said:
Substituting in V1f=(m1-m2/m1+m2)Vi, w get:
Please use parentheses correctly. That cannot be what you mean.
Neon32 said:
V1f=-3.3m/s
Please check that. I make it a bit less.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes BvU
Neon32 said:

Homework Equations



Vf=(m1-m2/m1+m2)Vi

If you know that equation, can see you a good way to solve the problem without calculating any velocities?
 
  • Like
Likes BvU
Back
Top